Umineko no Naku Koro ni Chiru Episode 5: End of the Golden Witch - Vol. 5 Ch. 23 - Adjourn

[MangaDex]

 

[rachetmarvel]

This is so stupid, firstly this is proof that the red truth is bullshit, some of Battlers blue truth were actually legit queries , but it was not effective because of some bullshit nox whatever red truth, like seriously how is the detective not a suspect ? Who was their to verify that the detective was actually surveying Battler in his room ? Why don't they use the fingerprint technique to show that the Aunt actually entered the room or even touched the dead bodies ?

They only proved that other people didn't do the killing, but they never actually proved that the Aunt did it. Using the process of elimination, makes this mystery less then a third rate mystery , thus the nox what ma call it should not be used as a bases for the red truth.

Secondly ,the fact that Battlers red truth was not effective, but the nox one was, kinda removed the point of the red truth in the first place. Remember, Blatter has once used the red truth in Beatrice game before, it was just before he got himself erased , so why can't he do it now?

 

[battttleeer]

i hate this

 

[RMXStudio]

At first, I thought I was perhaps a bit too unknowing to follow what was going on.
But no, this episode just breaks the rules of the previous episodes. It's really terrible.
Maybe that's the point, though. This is the board made by two witches who don't care anything about the game Beato set up before. It's boring, with a Mary Sue detective, half-baked accusations, and, most irritatingly, a conviction against an innocent person.
I hope something turns this episode around before it's over, otherwise, it will be my most hated one.

 

[the9813]

Doesn't the red truth of Krauss being dead break Knox 2nd?