Umineko no Naku Koro ni Episode 4: Alliance of the Golden Witch - Vol. 3 Ch. 13 - Sakutarou

[MangaDex]

 

[Kadesx]

Alright, fuck Rosa!

Seriously, what's wrong with her?

 

[nodamnbrakes]

Man, I hate episode 4; Rosa is the worst.

 

[Oysterwhite]

Yeah, the character went from a decent depiction of an abusive mom to straight out devil. Which is very stupid by the way, since her manipulative nature and selfishness on the first episodes was way more realistic imo.

 

[CrimsonReaper]

Fuck Rosa the rotten bitch. She hooks up and fools around with men neglecting her responsibilities as a mother and leaves Maria for days alone and when Maria gets lost because of her own selfish actions she abuses her as if a 9 year old can look up for themselves. She only views maria as an emotional pillar and she beats her up whenever she in any way damages her image in front of others. She's so despicable, I would be very glad if Maria kills her. She deserves it. God I hate her so much.

 

[CrimsonReaper]

Lambda sweeps in and turns the situation to her advantage. Now she has Ange in the palm of her hand. Wonder if Bern knew that would happen and factored that into her plan.

 

[rachetmarvel]

@Oysterwhite

Not really, Rosa has been hinted to being this despicable before, we have seen her being mentioned of going out with various men, abusing Maria, and leaving Maria alone in the past volumes. The difference this time is that we are actually seeing her interaction with Maria privately now, unlike in the previous volumes when she was in public.

Remember this is the same woman that beat her child , until she was swollen, in public, and left Maria alone in the rain, in the garden were Beatrice found her. So her acting like this to Maria in private is not that far fetched,and just like rosa herself said when she was being tortured by Beatrice in the golden land, she is a very bad mother.

 

[RMXStudio]

Yeah, the character went from a decent depiction of an abusive mom to straight out devil. Which is very stupid by the way, since her manipulative nature and selfishness on the first episodes was way more realistic imo.

Unfortunately, this is...entirely realistic.
Real "mothers" have done immensely worse, from beating their children to death to allowing their children to be beaten in their stead by abusive partners. There's a whole YT channel dedicated to detailing crimes against children by their own parents, often resulting in the death of that child.
It's all realistic. I hate to say it, but it is, indeed, well within the realm of possibility.