Versus

Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2020
Messages
44
Lmao One Punch Man's creator One made an Isekai? Oh man, I wish so dearly to hear the story behind this. Did he think it up? Or did his editor and publisher ask him to jump on the Isekai bandwagon? Either way I'd give my left arm to watch/hear about that pitch or meeting.
 
Active member
Joined
Jan 11, 2023
Messages
37
"After exactly 1 year of scanlating Versus, 47 Heroes are stopping their translations. Their initial worry with the kmanga simulpub was that a lot of people would be region locked and priced out of reading, but it seems that the translation is available from different websites (mangasee123.com). The switch to this version of translations means that a lot of names will change, so we highly recommend re-reading from the start on this website. So from H_Malik6828, SDOAJ, Parallax, and all the other people who helped out along the way, it’s been a pleasure."
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 5, 2019
Messages
1,166
It's an interesting concept and setting but the execution is kinda falling flat for me. I think the real problem is there's too many universes and some are very clearly getting shafted. The decision-making and leadership is almost exclusively coming from the humans of the magic and machine worlds, while other worlds are demoted to being fodder for fights or even worse, get to do literally nothing at all and have no apparent specialty or use like the ones from the Kaiju and Mad Max worlds. Heck, the humans from the nature world haven't talked or done anything whatsoever outside of their introduction. This bloat also shows in the existential threats seeming not very equal and flat out not existential for some, like what is the existential threat in the Mad Max universe and how will it pose any threat to, say, the robot world humans? Or the existential threat of the curse/disease... It's literally in their base infecting the king yet the council isn't even considering it or attempting to stymie it using the other world's powers. The king got sick and quarantined... And then nothing. He hasn't died or spread the illness despite multiple days passing without even attempting treatment, which makes it seem like even less of a threat than diseases that exist in the real world.

It's too ambitious for its own good. I think 7 universes would've been a lot more manageable and make for a better story.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jan 14, 2021
Messages
146
it suppose to be isekai story but turn out being another copy multiverse boring marvel type

it suppose to be record ragnarok similar plot theme but turn out less interesting & disappointing

it suppose to be overpower mc but turn out be "power of friendship"

it suppose to be great manga art because its monthly releasing but actually the art is ugly so it can't even be considered monthly type manga art.
this magaka just lazy as like boruto manga.

this mc not even has 2/3 heroine, even there no 1 girl relationship
I can barely tell what you're trying to say, nor how any of this actually connects to the story.
 
Joined
Jul 28, 2024
Messages
1
c'est censé être une histoire d'isekai mais il s'avère que c'est une autre copie du multivers ennuyeux du type Marvel

c'est censé être un enregistrement avec un thème d'intrigue similaire à Ragnarok mais il s'avère moins intéressant et décevant

c'est censé être Overpower MC mais en fait c'est "le pouvoir de l'amitié"

c'est censé être un excellent manga car il est publié mensuellement, mais en fait, l'art est moche, donc il ne peut même pas être considéré comme un manga de type mensuel.
ce magaka est juste paresseux comme le manga Boruto.

ce MC n'a même pas 2/3 d'héroïne, même là il n'y a pas de relation avec une fille
tu as eu 0/20 ma pauvre...

Tout d'abord, il n'a jamais été annoncé comme un Isekai puisque c'est un shonen. Et je ne vois pas en quoi l'existence du multivers rendrait l'œuvre ennuyeuse (ps : Marvel n'a pas inventé le concept de multivers)

Le seul point commun entre ces deux mangas est que plusieurs personnages/groupes vont s'affronter. Il en faut si peu pour dire que ces deux-là sont les mêmes ? D'autant que Record of Ragnarok n'est pas le meilleur exemple à citer pour l'histoire qui est littéralement inexistante (en 90 chapitres) alors qu'en moins de 20 chapitres, Versus reste plus captivant. Ou les personnages eux-mêmes, dans Record of Ragnarok, à part quelques exceptions on ne sait que très peu de choses sur les personnages, idem pour le style visuel qui est bon mais pas incroyable pour une œuvre mensuelle.

Je ne suis pas sûr que nous lisions la même œuvre, le mangaka fait un excellent travail, il suffit de regarder les chapitres récents pour le comprendre.

Enfin pour finir, tu évoques le pouvoir de l'amitié, mais de qui te moques-tu ? Au contraire le mc est impuissant (pour l'instant) et on nous fait comprendre qu'il ne vaut rien.

Et pour mettre les choses en contexte, 12 mondes viennent de s'intégrer dans le vôtre, il y a des menaces bien plus dangereuses que celles déjà présentes donc vous voyez, je ne suis pas sûr que trouver l'amour soit une priorité.

Bref, vous répondre était très ennuyeux et probablement inutile mais voir une personne critiquée avec si peu d'objectivité me rend fou, bonsoir.
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2024
Messages
2
it suppose to be isekai story but turn out being another copy multiverse boring marvel type

it suppose to be record ragnarok similar plot theme but turn out less interesting & disappointing

it suppose to be overpower mc but turn out be "power of friendship"

it suppose to be great manga art because its monthly releasing but actually the art is ugly so it can't even be considered monthly type manga art.
this magaka just lazy as like boruto manga.

this mc not even has 2/3 heroine, even there no 1 girl relationship
Well basically, this manga ain't generic. Your taste seems like more akin to harem and usual trash isekai's and it's really alarming to think that you prefer generic tropes in isekai. Pretty bad taste tbh.
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2024
Messages
2
It's an interesting concept and setting but the execution is kinda falling flat for me. I think the real problem is there's too many universes and some are very clearly getting shafted. The decision-making and leadership is almost exclusively coming from the humans of the magic and machine worlds, while other worlds are demoted to being fodder for fights or even worse, get to do literally nothing at all and have no apparent specialty or use like the ones from the Kaiju and Mad Max worlds. Heck, the humans from the nature world haven't talked or done anything whatsoever outside of their introduction. This bloat also shows in the existential threats seeming not very equal and flat out not existential for some, like what is the existential threat in the Mad Max universe and how will it pose any threat to, say, the robot world humans? Or the existential threat of the curse/disease... It's literally in their base infecting the king yet the council isn't even considering it or attempting to stymie it using the other world's powers. The king got sick and quarantined... And then nothing. He hasn't died or spread the illness despite multiple days passing without even attempting treatment, which makes it seem like even less of a threat than diseases that exist in the real world.

It's too ambitious for its own good. I think 7 universes would've been a lot more manageable and make for a better story.
Uhmm i think the problem lies with you and not the manga. It's not ambitious, all of the universes were handled really well and it didn't fell flat for us, in fact it gives us hype feeling every new chapter. The characters were doing all their part. Now, about the king? These people already tried to heal the king but they can do nothing, and now what? The king died and the reason why the curse is not spreading fast is because of a parasite living inside the king, plus add to the fact that they're doing a quarantine. You're starting to look funny, the latest chapter is 19 and you require heavy character developments? You already want the solution when it's still 19 chapters in? What stup*d*ty. For the mad max part of your argument, did you know that there is an Anime called hakuto no ken where it is a madmax reference and they had ridiculous powers?

Every world has their own specialty and their doing their part on it, you just gotta wait for their turn since, as i said, the manga chapters are still really few. You cannot expect to witness everyone's usefulness on such a low amount of chapters. Im starting to doubt if you ever read the manga. It looks like you just browsed through it. The story is really good and it's already a lot better than a ton of anime's released out there. Heck, this manga is even way more better than Kagurabachi. In fact, when i read your comment i can sense that this is not the type of manga that you prefer. It seems like you're more into generic type of manga. Maybe your favourite manga is Redo of Healer.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 20, 2018
Messages
713
tu as eu 0/20 ma pauvre...

Tout d'abord, il n'a jamais été annoncé comme un Isekai puisque c'est un shonen. Et je ne vois pas en quoi l'existence du multivers rendrait l'œuvre ennuyeuse (ps : Marvel n'a pas inventé le concept de multivers)

Le seul point commun entre ces deux mangas est que plusieurs personnages/groupes vont s'affronter. Il en faut si peu pour dire que ces deux-là sont les mêmes ? D'autant que Record of Ragnarok n'est pas le meilleur exemple à citer pour l'histoire qui est littéralement inexistante (en 90 chapitres) alors qu'en moins de 20 chapitres, Versus reste plus captivant. Ou les personnages eux-mêmes, dans Record of Ragnarok, à part quelques exceptions on ne sait que très peu de choses sur les personnages, idem pour le style visuel qui est bon mais pas incroyable pour une œuvre mensuelle.

Je ne suis pas sûr que nous lisions la même œuvre, le mangaka fait un excellent travail, il suffit de regarder les chapitres récents pour le comprendre.

Enfin pour finir, tu évoques le pouvoir de l'amitié, mais de qui te moques-tu ? Au contraire le mc est impuissant (pour l'instant) et on nous fait comprendre qu'il ne vaut rien.

Et pour mettre les choses en contexte, 12 mondes viennent de s'intégrer dans le vôtre, il y a des menaces bien plus dangereuses que celles déjà présentes donc vous voyez, je ne suis pas sûr que trouver l'amour soit une priorité.

Bref, vous répondre était très ennuyeux et probablement inutile mais voir une personne critiquée avec si peu d'objectivité me rend fou, bonsoir.

Did you just translate the original message just to be able to respond to it in French? :question:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top