What's Wrong With You, Duke? - Vol. 2 Ch. 84

Active member
Joined
May 27, 2020
Messages
89
"Wait, it was time travel all along?"
"Always has been."

I actually love this twist. I've always wanted a long-form story that pulled this kind of thing, but felt I'd never get it because no writer would want to risk telling the audience "yeah, the past few seasons/books were just the bad end prologue, lol". Pleasantly surprised.
 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
76
Savescumming 101 I see.
It'll be interesting to see what changes, I just hope it won't spend too many chapters building up to something again.

And I guess Zevahn is back as well then, kinda good since he had such a swift end, kinda bad since he likely won't be the same character. He might get picked up by Rowan through some odd circumstances and get to fight the prince though, or maybe he'll even end up preventing the assassination of the other royals.

Final note, given Erin and Sophia had money, what are the chances they'll bail Erin's father and Rowan would have to search everywhere for them eventually?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
250
huh. consider me surprised. from how it was going I expected it to go back to the moment the magic circle activated not all the way back to when the wish was made.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Nov 30, 2020
Messages
321
got siked real hard here lmao
some days I purposefully search for cheesy reincarnation/regression nobles stories and some days I'm like nah time to break that cycle
THIS WAS A PLOT TWIST THAT SLAPPED ME IN THE FACE
I'll take it tho
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
May 23, 2020
Messages
2,853
oh god. what a twist. instead of the Female Lead who got isekai'd to the past, it's the Male Lead instead! that's quite new (for me at least)

while this makes me glad that they're both alive and makes me hopeful that Rowan altering the past would make for a better future, it breaks my heart that it's only Rowan that remembers their 'future' which is now in the 'past'. He's the only one who has the memory of those days they spent together with so much love 😭😭😭

just end me now, won't you, author? it'll hurt less.
 
Member
Joined
May 4, 2020
Messages
85
Well, it is still not an isekai, it's a regression. Semantics, my friend. 🥸

Of course, I'm just bickering, I'm not really seriously criticizing. But for those curious:

"Isekai" (異世界) means "[transported to] the other world". It is also called "transmigration".

This series however is a "Regression" since the MC regressed through time. It can also be called "Return", but "return" is a more general term for any MC returning--whether through time and/or space. When a person who was isekai'd or thrown into a different dimension comes back, it's also called a "Return". For the sake of distinction, most people exclusively specify "Regression" for MC who went back in time, while "Returnee" refers to MCs who returned to a place they were in or a position that they once had.

Lastly we have "reincarnation" where the MC did die/disappear but later on inhabit a different body, often in the same world. Now, reincarnation is quite broad as it focuses on the cause of transmigration/regression--which, for reincarnation is, of course, death.

An isekai can be a reincarnation if the MC died before being transmigrated to a new world, but for clarity, it's simply called isekai'd--especially if Truck-kun delivered them.

Similarly, a "Returnee" can also be a "reincarnator" if they died in the world they returned FROM and instead inhabited a new body in the world they returned TO.

Regressions on the other hand, often trigger on death, and since it's about turning back time, the MC isn't really considered to have reincarnated even if they did inhabit a new body, as in a body that wasn't theirs before they died--such cases are only considered "Regression" and/or "Returnee", depending on what aspect of the return the author wants to highlight.

All of these are just semantics, by the way. Tropes evolve after all.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top