Yurige no Heroine ni Tensei Shita Ore, Nazeka Are ga Haeta Mama desu - Ch. 1

Group Leader
Joined
Dec 29, 2023
Messages
248
Careful. You don't wanna get banned for being reasonable.

I already deleted two draft replies because it'll probably get me banned again. Can't really talk reason on this forum.
You probably got banned for implying trans people are not normal and having unresolved mental health issues instead of being reasonable. You had the choice not to but you still did, so yes that's transphobic and the ban was justified.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 28, 2018
Messages
642
I have bad (or good?) news for you. Cis men do not think about being girls. If someone genuinely thinks and WANTS that, its not just "haha, funny joke". They're probably an egg. Whether they realize it yet or not (or how far they want to take those feelings) the specific reasons why don't really matter in this context. They aren't happy in their own body and they want to look/present differently.
They do, the same as "cis" women do as well. I have put examples before, why do you ignore them? Thinking about being another gender because they think it's better is actually a rather common thing that happens to both men and women.

Many have problems, for different reasons they have different desires. Two of my closest friends (females) have thought many times when they were teenagers that they wished they were born male due to society pressure they got back in the day, one of them is now a happy mother that would not change that for anything and the other simply understood that nothing should force her to be something that she is not.

People having a problem doesn't mean that they are always one thing, similar to autism being a spectrum and not every type of autism is the same - as well as some things inside the spectrum doesn't point out as the person being autistic, such as ADHD.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
346
Thank you for the chapter.
I ignore the title, so mr wiener surprised me lol
and i feel bad for her
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 28, 2025
Messages
1,280
They do, the same as "cis" women do as well. I have put examples before, why do you ignore them? Thinking about being another gender because they think it's better is actually a rather common thing that happens to both men and women.

Many have problems, for different reasons they have different desires. Two of my closest friends (females) have thought many times when they were teenagers that they wished they were born male due to society pressure they got back in the day, one of them is now a happy mother that would not change that for anything and the other simply understood that nothing should force her to be something that she is not.

People having a problem doesn't mean that they are always one thing, similar to autism being a spectrum and not every type of autism is the same - as well as some things inside the spectrum doesn't point out as the person being autistic, such as ADHD.
honestly I think all of this is silly to try and ascertain from the first chapter.

Could this be a title concerning a trans character? Maybe, maybe not. So far I think it's just ambiguous enough that it could be read either direction based on the dialogue presented, and only time and actual progression and development of the plot and the protagonist character will tell if one is the case over the other or if there's some unseen potential third option that I don't want to discount the notion of out of ignorance.
I personally think it'd be cool if there was at least some exploration of dysphoria and what it means to be "happy in the body you have versus the one you want to have" given some of the monologue presented thus far, but I also realize that it depends on the aim and intent of the author - so I'll just wait for more chapters and see what's what from there.

Though I must say I think I'll just ignore the discussion posts after this chapter because I cannot imagine it won't just look like this one each and every time.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Jul 5, 2023
Messages
404
I have bad (or good?) news for you. Cis men do not think about being girls. If someone genuinely thinks and WANTS that, its not just "haha, funny joke". They're probably an egg. Whether they realize it yet or not (or how far they want to take those feelings) the specific reasons why don't really matter in this context. They aren't happy in their own body and they want to look/present differently.

Ignoring the fact that the term "cis man" is retarded since there are only men and women, allow me, a man, to support @Jhonathan45's claims.

I'm a guy nearing my thirties that's tall and in shape. Got reasonably attractive once I lost the extra weight and grew my hair out. I'm happy with what I've achieved. I'm "happy in my own body", as you people call it.

Still, if I encountered the typical reincarnation scenario where you can ask things from a god, I'd restart my life as a beautiful girl.

Does this mean I'm repressing my inner woman? No. I simply find the female form more appealing, which is also why in games I create female characters to play as. After all, I'd rather spend hours staring at a girl's ass than a guy's.

It's basically a fetish. And I reckon that most trans women have a similar kind of fetish (can't speak for women since they have different issues). Just that they take it too far and try to make it reality, when in reality it's impossible. Not yet, at least.

Currently, a man (and women too, of course, but I'm choosing to tackle just one side for this) can go through all sorts of treatments and operations to achieve a passable female appearance, but it is yet impossible for that man to give birth. The DNA hasn't changed, either. It's only the outer shell that changed. Not to mention that hormone treatments tend to sterilise the patient. One essentially becomes a cripple.

Now, if technology gets to the point where you can get submerged into a special juice tank to sleep for a few weeks while your body is changed from one sex to the other at the atomic and DNA level, with internal organs and appearance changing to match? Sure. I'll try and see what it's like to be a woman. May alternate genders every few months, even. Sounds like fun.

So basically, I admire the female form and would prefer to have it, but, being a denizen of reality, I choose to do the most with what I have instead of living in delusion.

Understand that I'm against the normalisation of transitioning not because I don't understand it, but because I know too much about it and its consequences.

I may get banned for this, but if it saves just one person from the pain of realising too late that you've ruined your entire life, and that detransitioning barely helps at all, then go ahead and ban me.
 
Joined
May 3, 2025
Messages
12
"Trans people: Hey this kinda reads like they're Trans!
The comment section: OMG SHUT THE FUCK UP NOT EVERYTHING IS TRANS AHDUWGGSHSHDH"


GOD FUCKING DAMMIT I know Trans people sometimes jump at the slightest details to say a character is Trans (yay for not being represented in media and having people bitch about it and deny it wether it's subtle or brick to the face direct...

But this one reeks of trans, like bitch wtf the MC is all "oh i wish i was a girl so i could be yuri and everything" (unlike that other recent manga of the gay guy that turns into a girl but really doesn't give off any Trans vibes so gender identity ≠attraction drama wooo).
What is the recent manga about the gay guy who turns into a girl?
 
Joined
Dec 16, 2020
Messages
12
Oh yeah I read a vn similar premise to this when the guy is crossdressing to go to a all-girl school. A cute trap story so let's see where is this going or this story maybe the heroine is actually a guy this whole time but the dev hide it or the guy doesn't read that far yet for the reveal
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 28, 2025
Messages
1,280
Ignoring the fact that the term "cis man" is retarded since there are only men and women, allow me, a man, to support @Jhonathan45's claims.

I'm a guy nearing my thirties that's tall and in shape. Got reasonably attractive once I lost the extra weight and grew my hair out. I'm happy with what I've achieved. I'm "happy in my own body", as you people call it.

Still, if I encountered the typical reincarnation scenario where you can ask things from a god, I'd restart my life as a beautiful girl.

Does this mean I'm repressing my inner woman? No. I simply find the female form more appealing, which is also why in games I create female characters to play as. After all, I'd rather spend hours staring at a girl's ass than a guy's.

It's basically a fetish. And I reckon that most trans women have a similar kind of fetish (can't speak for women since they have different issues). Just that they take it too far and try to make it reality, when in reality it's impossible. Not yet, at least.

Currently, a man (and women too, of course, but I'm choosing to tackle just one side for this) can go through all sorts of treatments and operations to achieve a passable female appearance, but it is yet impossible for that man to give birth. The DNA hasn't changed, either. It's only the outer shell that changed. Not to mention that hormone treatments tend to sterilise the patient. One essentially becomes a cripple.

Now, if technology gets to the point where you can get submerged into a special juice tank to sleep for a few weeks while your body is changed from one sex to the other at the atomic and DNA level, with internal organs and appearance changing to match? Sure. I'll try and see what it's like to be a woman. May alternate genders every few months, even. Sounds like fun.

So basically, I admire the female form and would prefer to have it, but, being a denizen of reality, I choose to do the most with what I have instead of living in delusion.

Understand that I'm against the normalisation of transitioning not because I don't understand it, but because I know too much about it and its consequences.

I may get banned for this, but if it saves just one person from the pain of realising too late that you've ruined your entire life, and that detransitioning barely helps at all, then go ahead and ban me.

Glad you've figured out your situation for yourself.
You also don't speak for every human being and their individual experiences and existences.

Acting like you're qualified to do so, is where you're going wrong. You're entitled to your personal perspective and what it means to you as an individual, but pretending that because you've figured your singular life out that anyone who experiences and feels differently is delusional, is as laughable as it is absurd.

You don't know the lived experience of anyone but yourself. You can't. Pretending otherwise is a fool's errand and makes you look like a child.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 28, 2025
Messages
1,280
Oh yeah I read a vn similar premise to this when the guy is crossdressing to go to a all-girl school. A cute trap story so let's see where is this going or this story maybe the heroine is actually a guy this whole time but the dev hide it or the guy doesn't read that far yet for the reveal
it seemed like the protagonist has played the game through at least once or twice given the bit of narrative about "using my in-depth knowledge of the game from playing it so much I should be able to avoid getting found out", so unless it's real hidden in the lore of the game, every character in the game-turned-reality is female.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Oct 12, 2019
Messages
78
I have bad (or good?) news for you. Cis men do not think about being girls. If someone genuinely thinks and WANTS that, its not just "haha, funny joke". They're probably an egg. Whether they realize it yet or not (or how far they want to take those feelings) the specific reasons why don't really matter in this context. They aren't happy in their own body and they want to look/present differently.
Stop that. Don't limit what people can and can't think, do or be.
The goal of gender nonconformity is to make society a more accepting place, to give people the permission to be what they want to be, without having to care about others judging or trying to force them in small boxes.
Some people think about being the other gender without having gender dysphoria or being transexuals, this happens due to a variety of reason, such as insecurity, depression dissatisfaction with conventional gender norms. If someone express such a feeling we shouldn't try to immediately put them on hormones or add more trouble to their live by forcing them to question and deny their identity(egg theory), we should try to understand that person and find the source of this feeling.


You're probably a good person and said that without intending any harm, however what you said is dismissive and can bring pain to others.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 25, 2018
Messages
357
I have bad (or good?) news for you. Cis men do not think about being girls. If someone genuinely thinks and WANTS that, its not just "haha, funny joke". They're probably an egg. Whether they realize it yet or not (or how far they want to take those feelings) the specific reasons why don't really matter in this context. They aren't happy in their own body and they want to look/present differently.
that's uh, wrong there bud.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Oct 12, 2019
Messages
78
Oh yeah I read a vn similar premise to this when the guy is crossdressing to go to a all-girl school. A cute trap story so let's see where is this going or this story maybe the heroine is actually a guy this whole time but the dev hide it or the guy doesn't read that far yet for the reveal
Maidens are falling in love with me?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top