"Zako ni wa Kaji ga Oniai da www" to Iwareta Kaji Level 9999 no Ore, Tsuihousareta no de Boukensha ni Tenshokusuru ~Saikyou Buki de Musou Shinagara G…

[caioellery]

this fucking title

 

[Darkshade13]

Editors looking at some other series' title: "Shit, that's like.... way too long."

This series' author: "lol, watch this."

 

[othtim]

I think the name is too short, it needs to be longer

 

[chanmyse]

in fews year, the title could be a preview, or a story of itself.

 

[Dragorage]

Well I've seen a lot of these with almost the same moral of the story like "don't kick out the person who makes the team stronger" but I still get a kick out of them

 

[kilenem]

The premise isn't terrible but the execution is awful. A guild fired their Black smith because they thought he was to expensive. He didn't need to be an over powered adventurer.

 

[ExtinctTurtle]

these mfs are a dime a dozen atp dawg 😿

 

[avefenixflames]

This manga is too dumb and uninspired, has the most generic premise, the most generic villains and girls with more boobs than brains that instantly fall in love with the MC for the most stupid of reasons. The whole thing feels like the wet dream of a 13 year old boy that has no experience interacting with other people.

 

[PuruNyan]

I've been contemplating on dropping this manga, it was great at first and thank you for translating current and future groups

 

[merce6]

Why you read if there's a mouthful of title

 

[Kkkayoh]

Long ass title

 

[hidgepidge]

I read 8 chapters before dropping. It was 7 chapters too many. 4/10 bad.

 

[Elaborate]

Entirely too basic. I rate it 6/10.

We all know the 'fired from the party' genre. A classic analogy for workplace drama/power fantasy, where the idiot boss fires you but really, you were the one keeping the workplace together, so without you, the whole company goes under.

Well, that's exactly what you get here. The MC is a weaponsmith, he gets fired, takes all his weapons with him when he goes, and then his whole guild goes under because of their substandard weapons while the MC is off impressing pretty girls with his shiny weapons.

The author clearly hasn't thought about this much. There are no subversions, variations or complications.
The boss did exactly zero comparison tests between the old and new supplier, used zero hedging of bets, and goes down like a chump.
...The best thing about the manga is that it makes me imagine a better manga where the protagonist is a guildmaster carefully weighing his supplier options and party composition, and trying his best not to hurt people's feelings when he fires them.

To summarize, it's a decent introduction to the genre, but has nothing new to contribute to it.