The Swordmaster's Reincarnation

[MangaDex]

 

[Aztecreader]

Up to chapter 8 and it isn't bad but also not mid.

MC basically obtained swordmaster level before his death and was reincarnated into the body of a commoner adopted by nobility.

The thing that I find annoying is everyone accepted his amnesia story way to quick especially since he was a brat before hand and never practiced the sword unlike other stories where the MC slowly changed instead of instantly becoming OP since his body isn't used to the strain or has the muscles to swing the sword the way he is swinging...also the girl to call him master so fast was ..eh like girl have you ever even had a teacher??

Also how does a child of nobility not know who one of the heroes of mankind look like or even know about him but the commoners do.

 

[Jaxs]

Dropped after reading 3 chapters. Premise is that MC was a chief of security and a swordmaster before death and reincarnates as a servant serving a noble family. Normally, you will think that MC will act maturely due to his past experience. However, after reincarnation he acts like a pathetic loser. For example at chap 2, a noble approached MC with bad intend and MC apologized to him for particular no reason. Bruh what? My brain melts after reading this chapter and completely drop it after chapter 3. Should rename this manhwa as "Pathetic Reincarnation of the Swordmaster". Overall reading experience 2/10

 

[sumaria]

Based on what I remember from reading the novel, which was years ago by now, I don't have high hopes for this work and I'm genuinely surprised it got a manhwa adaptation. It's essentially a slice-of-life story more than an action story.

 

[Demavend]

Dropped after reading 3 chapters. Premise is that MC was a chief of security and a swordmaster before death and reincarnates as a servant serving a noble family. Normally, you will think that MC will act maturely due to his past experience. However, after reincarnation he acts like a pathetic loser. For example at chap 2, a noble approached MC with bad intend and MC apologized to him for particular no reason. Bruh what? My brain melts after reading this chapter and completely drop it after chapter 3. Should rename this manhwa as "Pathetic Reincarnation of the Swordmaster". Overall reading experience 2/10

Bruh... He was freshly reincarnated and trying to orient himself, and him being civil is perfectly fine reason. Also, this is a world with nobility FFS of course he's going to be cautious and try not to put himself in a bad situation. This isn't one of those power fantasy type stories with the MC pubstomping on every single threat without a care in the world for consequences.

 

[adi13841]

putting it on hold, its pretty mid , plot is mid and pacing is also slow , characters building is little lazy , will wait till it gets around 100 or so chapters

 

[phuquang1908]

Mid is 7, this one is 6.5. Everything kinda slow, the plot fill with a lot of hole, the exercution is true mid. Almost good enough to read to passing time

 

[stfuad]

Mid on this site is literally 5/10 which describes this. It’s not horrible, the plots pretty basic, arts typical for these. I’m kinda interested in this, but I don’t want to sit through a bunch of battle scenes to find out. Also long strips kinda suck and I can’t get past the name Motorolia. It’s like some evil company is going to swoop in and sell you cell phones.

 

[anonaddict]

Mid on this site is literally 5/10 which describes this. It’s not horrible, the plots pretty basic, arts typical for these. I’m kinda interested in this, but I don’t want to sit through a bunch of battle scenes to find out. Also long strips kinda suck and I can’t get past the name Motorolia. It’s like some evil company is going to swoop in and sell you cell phones.

Motorolie is motor oil in danish so i assumed it would be an auto repair shop

 

[anonaddict]

no one in this acts rationally at any point, it works best if you dont remember what happened in the last chapter so you wont go "wait a second thats stupid, why dont they just do the super obvious thing?"
instead mc will be fighting an enemy commander, retreat to a castle, tell everyone to prepare for invasion but not tell them that there is a powerful commander among then that they should look out for. the pattern is ongoing and they never stop taking unconventional route to create drama by doing the most illogical thing possible

 

[driftingbout23]

honestly I wouldn't even consider this mid [6] (that's my definition of mid btw)

it's fairly avg [5] honestly it could be worse and it probably is worse than I think I did mange to get to chapter 61 tho which is something

the only real quailty/reason u read this one is to fill the hole damn reincarnation has left


quite literally think of a faster paced damn reincarnation with mid art bad world building and terrible characters with one of the worst power scaling you've ever heard of and there you go

temu damn reincarnation

edit: more criticism

he may as well spawned in with the heads of God's he slayed as a sperm cell there's not a single chapter/fight that feels like he's going to lose. the closest time was due to rocks caving in. every character in this just exist to prove how strong most of it is just him falling to his knees and killing them with an artifact by the way he gets. he's like a 3rd rate swordman. it doesn't follow a linear power progression I mean.. and it's just a 15 year old power fantasy