Shi ni Modori Reijou wa, Kanpeki na Shiawase wo Teniireta - Vol. 1 Ch. 4 - The Villainess Who Was Rejected from Her Engagement Replays the Condemnati…

[MangaDex]

 

[l0liconn]

Vol 1 is done! Thanks for reading! I'll start working on the next volume as soon as I can

 

[xKIZUKIx]

Ok with this ending the volume, I'd say we're 2/4 decent with the 1st and last being the decent ones, while the middle chapters are the bad ones. overall very nice, translation.

 

[Mandobard]

Aww that was a sweet one. Tho it’s funny she still needed higher help to change her fate but that’s politics

 

[gjxy]

I liked this one. Also, the regression helped to Justify why the other noble girls bullied that girl in both second and first lives. That's nice.

 

[Tju]

decent, but it would have helped if they had included maybe a page more were they show how she gets closer to the crown prince, because right now we only get told it happens, it feels not very convincing.

 

[Sophie-Chan59]

Actually this wasn't a bad one, and it could have been a great concept for a serialized manga.
We could have seen more of what happened during her investigation, and how she fell for the Crown Prince, instead of the past, but I liked it.

 

[animehuntress]

The one thing that will always confuse me about these condemned villainesses is their fates. Unless they literally try to kill the "heroine" then their fates are usually extreme... Plus where are the teachers, especially since one of the capture targets is usually a teacher. Generally I have to shut off my brain to enjoy these, but it kind of makes you wonder 🤔. Is bullying really such a big deal that these ladies must die, be imprisoned, or sent to a brothel?

 

[EggMiner]

The one thing that will always confuse me about these condemned villainesses is their fates. Unless they literally try to kill the "heroine" then their fates are usually extreme... Plus where are the teachers, especially since one of the capture targets is usually a teacher. Generally I have to shut off my brain to enjoy these, but it kind of makes you wonder 🤔. Is bullying really such a big deal that these ladies must die, be imprisoned, or sent to a brothel?

It's just exaggerated to raise the stakes.

 

[Veemons]

wet noodle villianess stories strickes again (cant wait for the big booba villianess dommy to show up )

 

[Ceiye]

Oh come on, author! You are in a time regression anthology, it doesn't have to be a villainess! At least she had some actually villainous actions to be accused of

 

[notekatha]

Oh come on, author! You are in a time regression anthology, it doesn't have to be a villainess! At least she had some actually villainous actions to be accused of

These are all web novels that were chosen and illustrated for an anthology. So it was whoever went and made offers to the authors who picked what kinds of stories were chosen.

 

[Ceiye]

These are all web novels that were chosen and illustrated for an anthology. So it was whoever went and made offers to the authors who picked what kinds of stories were chosen.

Alright then the editors, choose other types of stories! There has to have been some time regression stories that wasn't just another villainess

 

[Acrelorraine]

This is the best one which should be seen as a condemnation of the rest. Bland and generic, but at least it’s not infuriating.

 

[Sugarbeef]

So far this one is the best, but we only have 4 to pick from at this point. Not sure why the stories are so bad compared to the villainess anthology, hopefully they get better.

At least the translation is on point like usual. Thanks to the team for that.

 

[phoenixir]

This one was alright.

 

[sketches]

Started and ended with good stories this volume. Middle was a bit shaky. Gotta keep this ball rolling into the next volume.

 

[shadebane]

This one was fine for a story outline, but it needed so much more. Maybe I don't know what to expect from anthologies. But this one could have been longer, or needed more time between the FMC and the Prince.

 

[Izzydee]

So far, I only like one story. The others at least I can enjoy the art

 

[cultivatorA]

she was actually a blood relative of the royal family, the illegitimate child of the current king and a mistress

...a different king, right? or is the second prince courting his half sister

edit: nevermind, her fiance wasn't the second prince just some random marquis