Going back the objections in Chapter 54/55 comments:
Ok guys, I can explain why Hiromi was trapped by a woman half his size. Regarding Anju, Hiromi's number one goal is trying to re-establish mental/emotional stability. How do you say no if you can't reject her? He believes stopping her will cause more harm.
Let me setup what this means for this Manga, Hiromi, and his relational blindness:
Anju
This arc is important, because Hiromi has yet to experience consequences for how he chooses to structure his relationships. His main weakness, as everyone called him out, is being overly-responsible. His background taught him to stabilize everything, and this sharehouse is the perfect recipe to reinforce him as an emotional anchor. His pathological caretaking did not stop Anju in the past leading to this moment. Anju is the perfect stress tester. Narratively, she is functioning as the embodiment of what happens when emotional ambiguity is allowed to rot. And she does so, more potently than all the other women because she is pulls out his character failings directly. His paralysis with Anju is purely (externally) moral and that is exactly the problem. Hiromi prioritizes damage control over truth.
The Four Women
The four women (Yes, four. We'll come back to Yukari in a bit) in this sharehouse aren't just opportunities for Hiromi to become an emotional anchor. They are reflections of his own problems. Lili and Mio represent Hiromi's questioning of his efforts and lived experience. A sort of relational-imposter-syndrome. Anju and Tsubasa represent Hiromi's self worth and perceived desireability. These unresolved attachment issues and their solutions are revealed when Hiromi takes care of the sharehouse ladies. They foretell the growth Hiromi needs that readers frustratingly desire.
Readers are angry because they want Hiromi to be good. They want clean moral alignment. And reassurance that choosing Nonoka (or really any woman) fixes everything. But Sasuga Kei refuses to comfort us. Instead, Sasuga Kei is responding on the
Narrative Layer:
Note: Not an actual quote. Just my interpretation on what she is doing.
Nonoka
Nonoka's introduction right now is the most important. On the
Emotional Layer, she represents what Hiromi wanted before he became overly-responsible, before things became unstable, before clarity was lost. For the first time Hiromi's weakness now presents consequences: to someone he loves (Nonoka), someone he feels responsible for (Anju), and the ethical coherence of his life (his morals and his
actual lived actions). He can't maintain this relationship because being overly-responsbile makes him the most irresponsible in the one place that matters most: Hiromi never asks what he wants. Hiromi cannot align with anybody because he can't align with himself. And that's why he seems boundary-less.
The four woman in this sharehouse all reveal that fatal flaw. And the stress-testor, Anju (with the help of the other three), will show Hiromi that situation where old rules no longer protect him, and his avoidance becomes active harm.
His relationship with Nonoka will fail on both the Emotional and Narrative Layers to pave a path for what comes next.
Yukari
This manga is not punishing us with melodrama. These incidents with Anju (and the other three) are showing the logical escalation that Hiromi has to confront due to his passivity. It's uncomfortable and effective without breaking any layers. These incidents aren't about cheating or wavering feelings. They are forcing individuation in Hiromi: a process to pull out the inner situation Hiromi struggles with in order for him to mature.
This scene with Anju pinning and kissing Hiromi while on the phone with Nonoka is setting up how Hiromi will not be able to hide behind rules, concerns, and "I didn't mean to" rhetoric. He will have to answer the core question: "Who am I willing to hurt by choosing... and by
not choosing?
And that's where Yukari (Day 1 Best Girl,
hands down) comes in.
Like the four women in the sharehouse, Yukari is also reflection of Hiromi. But she is representation of Hiromi
in the future. That's why her arc was shown first in the beginning of this manga. It was the only arc where Hiromi sat back and did
nothing. In fact, whenever Yukari's "arc" appeared, they are short and to the point. During those arc's, Sasuga Kei shows us on the Emotional Layer of how Hiromi is now the one being emotionally anchored (for the future). And on the Narrative Layer, a seed was planted for how Sasuga Kei wants to responds to readers (see quote above and linked "Narrative Layer").
We are now entering another arc with Mio after the heat on this sharehouse has been turned up. And it looks like Hiromi is already showing up to support her the same way he did with Lili. This is his second chance to show what he learned about himself and the women he deals with. Sasuga Kei is using the four women in the sharehouse to reflect Hiromi in pairs. The first in the pair reveals, and the second shows how he applies the lessons learned.
Yukari's Past as a Future for Hiromi
Nonoka and Yukari both bared the overly-responsible pains that plagued Hiromi. Nonoka did so with a vision that Hiromi believed he would live: a fun and lively family with the one who makes that dream come true. However, Yukari does not do so anymore. Yukari learned to stop lying to her heart and that it is her duty to ensure her own happiness: she's not afraid of her own choice. Nonoka
is Yukari's pair: his past, before the maturation of his shadow, vs the future maturation of his growth.
By future, I mean that Yukari is
proof to Hiromi's struggle:
can you allow others to carry their own conseqeunces? As Yukari has shown, the answer is yes, choosing does not require collapse. This is the answer Hiromi will come to realize as Nonoka's entry tests if Hiromi's actions match his values. For now, Yukari acts as a non-anxious reference point to Hiromi's failings.
These pairings act as a
diagnostic phase for what is wrong with Hiromi. A phase that is ending soon. Sasuga Kei is setting up the
decision phase: Anju, Nonoka, and Yukari determine what must be chosen. Do not be mistaken though. Sasuga Kei is not asking which woman is the answer. She is asking which demand will Hiromi stop trying to satisfy simultaneously. Until he chooses, Anju will escalate, Nonoka will be hurt, and Yukari will remain untouchable.
Final Predictions
Even though she joked about being married with Hiromi before, Yukari cannot have a proper arc in this manga with Hiromi. His relationship with Nonoka
must fail, and his boundary-less protection of Anju must rupture, possibly hurting everyone. Until all the boundary collapses with the four women in the sharehouse, and until he learns from his eventual break-up with Nonoka, Yukari will not move until Hiromi demonstrates self-authorization.
Here is what to look out for:
Hiromi will be forced to choose the first time someone
explicitly asks him to take responsibility for the harm he caused. It will look something like:
Everything so far has had no consequences or was gently brushed. "
What were you thinking?" "
Do you like her?".
- There needs to be a clear victim. Best candidates: Nonoka or Anju. Most likely Nonoka.
- A direct questionthat can't conveniently pass him:
- “Are you choosing me: yes or no?”
- “Are you going to keep protecting me from consequences?”
- Witnesses at the time of the event or its inevitable spread. Others will know, and it will redefine his role in the house.
- Yukari will not intervene. She already answered the question for herself and exists to prove that choice itself is survivable.
What that explicit choice will be about narratively:
- Option A — Containment Without Truth (The "Bad" Ending)
- Hiromi will continue to be a stabilizer. Specifically with Anju but I won't discount the others.
- Lose Nonoka through ethical incoherence
- Preserve the illusion of goodness
- Become morally fragmented
- Option B — Truth With Harm (The "Good" Ending)
- Hiromi will finally say no clearly. He will not falter to stabilizing someone in a way that will comprise a choice he made earlier.
- Allow someone to be hurt by reality
- Accept guilt without losing clarity
- Become an adult agent
Sasuga Kei is going to be ruthless about either ending. She is sending a message: avoiding harm is not the same as being ethical. This is what Hiromi has been confusing. And when it all plays out, readers can't make up excuses for Hiromi because the story will have shown that
not choosing is choosing.
I think that Sasuga Kei will go with Option B (The "Good" Ending), because Yukari is a bit too close to a Checkov's gun. It would be a waste to not show
something about her in respect to Hiromi's transformation.
When that finally happens, Hiromi will be moved up into the Narrative Layer just like Yukari. The title question of this manga will be revealed into a single meaning:
That is the end-state Sasuga Kei is building toward. It is my hope when that point arrives, she gives us a retrospective on Hiromi's dreams:
what does family look like to him?