Childhood Friend Romance where CF actually wins

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
1,249
I’ve read a couple of them and honestly didn’t think there were that many, but I feel like you missed Dungeon no Osananajimi. ^^

Also, not sure where this is going at this point, but this series feels like it could be up your alley (and I hope you can read Spanish, ’cus the English version is abandonware at the moment…).
:thumbsup:
I have read very few chapters of these two. I dropped Dungeon no Osananajimi cuz it didn't click with me and the later cuz it seems quite messy and I don't like it when there's multiple childhood friends.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
1,249
If you're fine with ones that haven't been fully translated (I seriously want to translate it but don't have the RAW chapters), I'd recommend Boku ga Boku de aru Tame Ni. It's an uneasy story at times, but it qualifies.
The MC is a boy named Shun who moved away in the fourth grade and came back in the eleventh. He always wished he could be more direct about his feelings rather than saying whatever seemed likely to cause the least conflict. He gets back, thinks it'd be great if he could tell his CF Sana how he's always felt, and finds Sana is best friends with a guy who looks just like him but is much more open. He starts swapping places with this guy, Ayumu, and Sana finds herself falling for Ayumu all of a sudden, only it's pretty clear that every bit where Ayumu makes her heart throb it's actually Shun. You can imagine the drama that ensues, but it does have a happy ending (a little open-ended just like One Week Friends, but still clearly a happy end).
I don't like reunion ones :/ . Thanks for the rec tho.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
1,189
I have read very few chapters of these two. I dropped Dungeon no Osananajimi cuz it didn't click with me and the later cuz it seems quite messy and I don't like it when there's multiple childhood friends.
Full disclosure, the fact that there are two of them, and that they won’t accept any other outcome than a throuple, is a good part of what draws me to this series.
:smugnako:
 
"Mucho texto" enjoyer
Group Leader
Joined
Mar 1, 2023
Messages
303
I don't like reunion ones :/ . Thanks for the rec tho.
Very well. Thought you might, since there are "reunion" works in your list. Tends to be the case very frequently. And kind of makes sense. If they were together every day there's little threat of change, and this can make it far more comfortable to simply stay as you are.

If you're fine with younger characters some volumes of Naisho no Tsubomi would qualify (I'd have to look back to find which do and don't, since every volume is a different story with different characters). Also pretty sure another of the author's works, Mizuiro Jidai, goes this direction.

Asagiri no Miko also fits the bill (though I don't know if anyone will ever translate it).

Love Rush, Misoshiru de Kanpai, Hatsukoi Zombie (sorry reunion series), Ginen Shounen (one of my favs), Joyful Days (oneshot), and Karakai Jouzu (?) no Nishikata-san (also reunion) also fit.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
1,249
Full disclosure, the fact that there are two of them, and that they won’t accept any other outcome than a throuple, is a good part of what draws me to this series.
:smugnako:
Isn't there a 2nd Male CF who just gets... nothing?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
1,249
Very well. Thought you might, since there are "reunion" works in your list. Tends to be the case very frequently. And kind of makes sense. If they were together every day there's little threat of change, and this can make it far more comfortable to simply stay as you are.

If you're fine with younger characters some volumes of Naisho no Tsubomi would qualify (I'd have to look back to find which do and don't, since every volume is a different story with different characters). Also pretty sure another of the author's works, Mizuiro Jidai, goes this direction.

Asagiri no Miko also fits the bill (though I don't know if anyone will ever translate it).

Love Rush, Misoshiru de Kanpai, Hatsukoi Zombie (sorry reunion series), Ginen Shounen (one of my favs), Joyful Days (oneshot), and Karakai Jouzu (?) no Nishikata-san (also reunion) also fit.
Yeah, there are some on my list but I generally avoid them. Thanks for reaching out.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 22, 2026
Messages
533
Well I'm certainly a Nisekoi enjoyer but I didn't include it cuz I didn't enjoy it because they were childhood friends. Also I avoided a few where basically everybody goes way back.
A Nisekoi enjoyer, huh…?
Nisekoi was the first romcom I can really remember reading, and although I enjoyed it, I have words to say about the ending.
Did you enjoy Nisekoi because of the ending, despite it, or something else?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
1,249
A Nisekoi enjoyer, huh…?
Nisekoi was the first romcom I can really remember reading, and although I enjoyed it, I have words to say about the ending.
Did you enjoy Nisekoi because of the ending, despite it, or something else?
I never got to the ending lol. I was pondering about picking it back up but I got spoiled with the ending about 3-4 years ago. Was that fair? No. Was it in the realm of my expectations? Nope. Did I wish for it? Heck yeah! I was a huge tsundere fan back then (I was 14). That's why I didn't put it on the list cuz I couldn't care less about the childhood friendship with Onodera.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 22, 2026
Messages
533
I never got to the ending lol. I was pondering about picking it back up but I got spoiled with the ending about 3-4 years ago. Was that fair? No. Was it in the realm of my expectations? Nope. Did I wish for it? Heck yeah! I was a huge tsundere fan back then (I was 14). That's why I didn't put it on the list cuz I couldn't care less about the childhood friendship with Onodera.
I see… that actually makes a lot of sense. Looking back on it now, I also really liked it up until Marika‘s second character arc
Personally…
I hated Chitoge. When I first heard of the series I thought “chitoge‘s gonna win.” Then I actually read it and I wasn’t so sure. Out of everyone, I really thought Onodera should’ve won (and I still do), but that didn’t happen. I could explain in excruciating detail why I hate Nisekoi’s ending and how much of a formative event it was for me, but that would take forever
Seishirou Tsugumi was by far my favorite, and to this day, she remains my #1 waifu
 
"Mucho texto" enjoyer
Group Leader
Joined
Mar 1, 2023
Messages
303
When you say you don't like multiple childhood friends, does that include "marry them all" scenarios? Because thinking back I know a few series with childhood friends as part of a guy's wives or even with them making up ALL the wives. Though the ones that I can think of off the top of my head are very dark and have the characters go through some awful stuff (like the first two I thought of include mind-control NTR) before ending up together, and the manga versions aren't even complete yet.
First, there's The Hero May Have Stolen Everyone From Me, but I Won’t Give Up. In the End, I Know I’ll Be the One Who Wins: the main character has a bunch of childhood friends, all girls and all in love with him. There's a ceremony where they'll find out their skills and whatnot, and at that moment a summoned "Hero" shows up, identifies the girls' skills as having some kind of connection to the Hero and makes them part of his party. He "lets" the MC be part of the party too. Thing is he has mind control powers and regularly takes any girl he wants to his bed, brainwashing them to adore and serve him. Additionally, the "connection" between the girls' skills and him gives him an excuse to "strengthen their bonds" regularly. The manga version isn't over, but according to the forums there are several endings/paths, all but one having the "Hero" lose his powers through a curse by the Demon King, resulting in all the girls gaining full control again. Any brainwashed girl who was impregnated had her memory altered to lighten the burden, but this didn't happen to any of the CFs thankfully. Either way, before the Hero can be executed the girls go to his dungeon and do the job themselves, very thoroughly and brutally. In one ending the MC doesn't know the girls were brainwashed and rejects them. In one he knows and they all live happily ever after together. In the path where there is no brainwashing the "bug" that caused that guy to be summoned as a Hero is finally fixed, and the MC becomes the Hero instead, succeeding in the quest and having a happy future with his childhood friends (and the little sister of the would-be Hero who was the one who was supposed to be summoned in the first place).
Second, there's Keikenchi. Also has the MC be a comrade in the "Hero's" party. In this case, the party consists of MC Thor, his two childhood friends Nei and Soara who grew up with him and loved him for ages, and Hero Thane and Lisa who moved into the village at around 12. Thor fell in love with Lisa and got engaged to her, but one day Thane and the girls sat him down and told him they wanted him to leave the party on account of his inability to increase his level no matter how he trains. Thor notices Lisa is wearing a new ring where her engagement ring should be, and that the other two also have the same ring. He attacks Thane in fury at having stolen his fiance and childhood friends and making up a dumb excuse to get him out of the way, only to be literally kicked out. Very shortly afterward it's revealed that Thane has a brainwashing power that showed up out of nowhere, that he'd been using it on Lisa for ages to sleep with her behind Thor's back and recently used it on the other two girls as well. After a while Thane gets rid of Nei and Soara for various reasons, and when Thor saves them and discovers the brainwashing he offers to break the spell, which nearly breaks them mentally. Both of them return to their home village for maybe a year to recover, come to grips with things, etc. As for Lisa, well... Soara says she's secretly a traitor, and eventually this is revealed to be beyond an understatement. She's actually the young Demon King in disguise. As long as the Demon King lives a Hero will be found somewhere, so if she kills the one she'd found she'll just have an unknown Hero out there somewhere she doesn't know, and by the time she finds him he may become too powerful to stop. So instead, she decided to corrupt the Hero Thane. She seduced him and Thor simultaneously, agreed to marry Thor to infuriate Thane, then gave Thane those brainwashing powers (which don't work on her because she's too strong). Once things had gone for a while and Thane was thoroughly wrapped around her fingers, she convinced him to get rid of his true allies one by one so he'd have no one with him but herself and disguised demons. This way, she's able to keep him weak and isolated and completely helpless, right up until her true identity is revealed. While the story isn't over yet, it's been confirmed by those that have read the original that it does indeed end with Nei and Soara marrying Thor (along with several other girls).
 
Joined
Jun 29, 2026
Messages
1
I Want to End This Love Game / Aishiteru Game Wo Owarasetai definitely needs to be here!!! Probably the best CF manga romance I've ever read. (Made an account just to post this reply lol)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top