okay, but that was last chapter.
In this chapter, MC is wrong to apologise. I mean what would apologising even do? In this chapter, Hyouka is right. If people wanna complain, last chapter forum exist
Oh yeah, the MC was gaslit; he is wrong to apologize, but I see him as a victim of abuse and extreme gaslighting. There's a lot to complain about in this chapter because this is where Amaya gaslights the fuck out of the MC, and yes, the criticism should be directed at her, but still, the reason why she is wrong comes down to Hyouka being a complete bitch.
Not to mention that her whole dialogue in this chapter is about "but you thought of me that way," and there's never any acknowledgement that she literally said to his face what he accused her of. He accused her of looking down on him; in chapter 1, she literally says to him, "Keep living your gloomy little life while glaring jealously at my happy life! Just keep looking up from the bottom", so why in the fuck is Hyouka talking like the problem is that "he sees her that way" and not the fact that she openly stated this? I mean, sure she might not be lying (questionable) when she says, "When I never did anything like that", but that doesn't change the fact that she explicitly stated that she does.
Hyouka, in his chapter, said: "Did I ever once say that you were a nuisance, Iori?" In the first chapter, when they find each other on their way to school, she tells him to come later. What else could she mean but that Iori is a nuisance to her and that she doesn't want other ppl to see them coming together?
She is accusing him of lying about who was ignoring whom, but we can clearly see that, even in her memories, he was the last one to approach her, and she was the one who ignored him, even if she had her reasons, and yeah, maybe because of that there was a misunderstanding, but it is evident that the last to approach was him.
This chapter also has the MC trashing himself for not working on himself while Hyouka "worked hard" and "kept polishing herself", but for fucking what? What's the result? The MC is still a kind, chill dude, while Hyouka became a fake-ass person (the personality she uses with her friends is clearly not her own) who goes out of her way to constantly put down her childhood friend, calling him gloomy, trying to make him jealous about her perfect life, mocking him for his status, and then proceeds to interfere when she sees him getting a friend/love interest. This girl is only a bad person towards the MC; there's nothing she does that actually results in anything positive for him, but now the author is trying to gaslight us into thinking the contrary. The MC is already completely brainwashed into thinking that he had no good reasons for his conclusions, when the good reasons came directly from Hyouka's own mouth. And there's no single voice of reason that can come and fix things. The last hope for his situation is for Hyouka herself to go through the things she said to Iori and admit that Iori's conclusions made sense given her attitude, and for the MC to not immediately go and keep blaming himself for not reading her mind to find out that she doesn't look down on him despite explicitly stating that