Mahou Shoujo × Haiboku Saiban - Vol. 1 Ch. 3

[Nami]

Just asking transsexuals out of curiousity.

I know women have a harder time holding it in than men when they have to go to the washroom. Do transsexuals have the same problem post-surgery too?

Yes. Even pre-op, if you're on HRT for long enough.

 

[Imbued]

They (Court) was basically all allies backstabbers.

 

[NZPIEFACE]

but this is not hentai, if I wanted that appeal I might as well read that, because I am not finding this erotic, just miserable.

The author also makes magical girls being raped hentai. Like, if that wasn't blatantly obvious. The author just wanted to explore the idea of a world with laws this contrived and fucked up.

 

[watanuki-kimihiro]

So many people in the comments are coming halfway there with their understanding of the concept. Yes, it's absurd (that's halfway) and it's intentionally absurd (that's the other half people aren't reaching).

 

[portable]

How many chapter currently written for the moment ? Hope people continue to translate this one. I like how it is completly messed up.

 

[Nami]

So many people in the comments are coming halfway there with their understanding of the concept. Yes, it's absurd (that's halfway) and it's intentionally absurd (that's the other half people aren't reaching).

People are fully able to understand that and still not enjoy it. Not mutually exclusive things, my guy.

If someone writes a manga and intends for it to be bad and not fun to read (not speaking about any specific manga here), it's still bad and not fun to read. The intent is largely irrelevant.

 

[ArchivistAlex98]

The author also makes magical girls being raped hentai. Like, if that wasn't blatantly obvious. The author just wanted to explore the idea of a world with laws this contrived and fucked up.

Understanding the point of the series and actively disliking the series aren't mutually exclusive trains of thought.

No shit people are going to be offput by a manga about magical girls having to explain in detail why their loss and subsequent rape totally weren't their fault and was out of their control.

 

[evlbb2]

Wild storyline so far but honestly unique and kinda funny. I'm in. It'll be interesting to see if there's a dark plot twist later on with that mysterious other magical girl.

 

[NZPIEFACE]

Understanding the point of the series and actively disliking the series aren't mutually exclusive trains of thought.

No shit people are going to be offput by a manga about magical girls having to explain in detail why their loss and subsequent rape totally weren't their fault and was out of their control.

Wrong reply? The guy I was replying to didn't seem to know about the author's other works and so was lacking context for this one. I didn't say anything about understanding the point or disliking the series.

 

[Nami]

Wrong reply? The guy I was replying to didn't seem to know about the author's other works and so was lacking context for this one. I didn't say anything about understanding the point or disliking the series.

I assume they meant the dumb comment I was replying to above that. All the context fits. They probably just misclicked.

 

[gizzvn]

harsh + dumb world, magical girls there sure live in hell mode.

 

[TunguskaCASN]

THE SPIDERMAN CURSE

 

[monkey123]

Too bad no pregnancy punishment, but maybe someday?

 

[monkey123]

Spiderman has to be redone to make webs come out of the donger.

 

[chanzy7]

He is the werewolf! The spiderman references this chapter lol.

 

[asdasgfrw]

Who tf are those dudes in the suits shit talking every defendant, tgey certainly aren't jury, so who tf are they even

 

[KuroZer0]

WTF is wrong with this court.

 

[xr900]

UH
soo
when spiderman hangs from ceilings, did the web comes from...........

 

[onekele]

Main character got hit with plot convenience as a power. Wonder what the prosecutor's power is..?

 

[DLRevan]

People are fully able to understand that and still not enjoy it. Not mutually exclusive things, my guy.

If someone writes a manga and intends for it to be bad and not fun to read (not speaking about any specific manga here), it's still bad and not fun to read. The intent is largely irrelevant.

I think its good at what it's trying to do. Every turn is unexpected and well...degenerate. I've yet to see anyone criticize it in a way that can be described as being objectively bad.

Yes, subjectively bad, when taken in the context of various genres being thrown out....black comedy, ace attorney clone, etc, etc.

But this isn't really trying to be any of those, is it? Take the first example. I find it hilarious in itself that someone actually thought this was 'black comedy'. It's not like anyone has even died or that there is any focus on particularly bleak outcomes. The author presented stereotypical magical girl ends, so it's hentai satire.

I don't think there's any issue with not enjoying it. Whatever floats your boat, or doesn't lol. But not enjoying it then trying to validate your lack of enjoyment by misrepresentation, for a manga that is obviously going to be controversial in the mainstream? Now that's just both karma farming and snobbing.

Now as for myself, as light hearted and very...targeted satire, I also wouldn't say its the best, but it's still entertaining enough. Shame today's manga community would rather act like literature snobs, read the same shit over and over again, and be disingenuously "objective" about the stuff they don't like. Even when the strength of manga is we can have variety like this, and when there are thousands of manga people can read instead if they find one doesn't work for them.