Suna Mahou de Suna no Oukoku wo Tsukurou ~Sabaku ni Tsuihou Sareta kara Ganbatte Sokoku Ijou no Kokka wo Tatete Mita~ - Vol. 1 Ch. 1

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 2, 2018
Messages
878
'nother one of those useless godly power story.

Aside from that, can you imagine a Japanese noble building a German fortress castle in Japan despite not having seen any German architecture?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
831
Most of the "useless skill trope" takes time in middle age civilization. Their mind literally goes like this:

Not common > useless
Can't use for combat > useless
And this is insane, even in a medieval setting.

At best, it might make sense in a prehistoric setting. Cavemen that barely manage to survive in a hostile environment might not realize the point of skills that don't have an immediate application to survival.
It can also work when applied specifically to combat-intensive jobs, like adventurers.
(Even then, humans developed past that point because they experimented with everything they got their hands on.)

More broadly, any society that managed past the point of immediate survival should know the benefits of non-combat skills. Particularly in a medieval setting, would I add. Literacy for example was low at that point, so reading and writing were rare non-combat skills, yet extremely valuable.

That's why when this happens outside of adventurer parties, I end up thinking that the premise is just plain insane.
No society can develop without creating tools and shelters, growing food in a sustained way, transmitting knowledge from one generation to the next... among many other things. You know, non-combat skills. Banishing someone for having an unknown or non-combat skill is just an insane premise.
Disinheriting someone as a noble for having a "commoner" job is the most I can find believable.

And all of this is basic consideration before we get to the fact that the basic benefits of some of the skills in these fictions should be pretty obvious, even as some might not be.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 20, 2018
Messages
1,440
Get sand magic
Get exiled to a desert
Have literally limitless resources at your disposal
People in Japanese fantasy settings these days have zero imagination over how something "useless" can be absolutely broken.
the goblins and ants feel weird in that desert. like i get that there are actual desert ants and stuff, but it feels unusual. like at that size maybe if they were beetles or something..? It could just be the body shape of the ants and the clothes of the goblins. dunno, cant put my finger on it, especially with the plot goin a mile a minute
The gobbos? Yes.
The ants? Nah, there is a ton of ant species that live in desert or desert-like environments. And since this is a fantasy setting, then having large honey ants isn't so out of place.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 17, 2020
Messages
346
BANISHED FOR BEING SPEEDRUN ANY% DONT FORGET TO RATE COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE
seriously we are like going through all the motions at breakneck speed what the hell.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top