Jinsei Gyakuten - Uwaki Sare Enzai wo Kiserareta Ore ga, Gakuen Ichi no Bishoujo ni Natsukareru - Vol. 2 Ch. 8

[marcelolbaka]

Never a childhood friend lost so hard. Today is a sad day.

 

[goodhunter]

Honestly, as much as it's great that all the adults in this manga seem like really capable adults who are actually taking action, and it's extremely refreshing to see that because almost every bullying and abuse focused mangas always have the absolute worst adults. However, I don't think I'll honestly be satisfied unless the NTR protag wannabe dies a dogs death, suffering till his last breath. Preferably by one of the girls he manipulated because that would be poetic. That, or he goes to prison and gets sodomized regularly by burly prisoners.

For the dumbass cheating bitch, she needs to get nothing but constant shaming from everyone around her to the absolute end and she lives in nothing but complete misery. Alone and hated even by her own family, till the day she dies or kills herself. There is absolutely no forgiveness for people who not only cheat on their partners, but on top of that make false accusations of abuse or rape against the person that they cheated on.

 

[goodhunter]

I want to see miyuki downfall the most. She had relationship and destroyed it cuz she got seduced by some guy, and even slept with him. Go on Kondo, make her fall, and then fall yourself when all goes out to light

You're also forgetting that she accused the MC of abusing her. She cheated on him, THEN she accused him of abusing her. Double whammy. Bitch deserves to be slut shamed by the entire nation wherever she goes, and also treated like a criminal for making false allegations on a real victim.

 

[goodhunter]

Spoiler: about the shadow mc

even after knowing how that otaku guy's ex-girlfriend acted, I still can't help but feel bad for her. She's got absolutely no one in her corner.

And why should she? Nobody forced these dumb bitches to cheat on their boyfriends and rub it in their faces.

 

[goodhunter]

Nah, yes, she is a clueless idiot that got swept along, but the level of Karma she gets in the WN is disproportionate to her sins. The ref needs to step in and stop the fight now.

The fuck are you spouting? Did anyone force her to cheat? Did anyone force her to make false accusations of abuse against the MC? Did anyone force her to CONTINUE fucking the dude and continue keeping up the lie to everyone around her, also including that she lied to her own mother about how she's still dating the MC? Everyone seems to keep forgetting that she made FALSE ACCUSATIONS PURPOSEFULLY AGAINST THE MC, THE VERY MAN SHE UTTERLY BETRAYED AND HUMILIATED AFTER SHE RECEIVED NOTHING BUT ABSOLUTE LOVE AND SUPPORT FROM THE MC AND HIS FAMILY FOR MOST OF HER LIFE

 

[goodhunter]

Yeah, that's a bit excessive to me. I've always been of the mind that a punishment should fit the crime. If Aono died, things would be different, but it was a short scenario that was resolved without irreparable damage. Suspend her, expel her, put her actions on record and pay reparations to the family. That is MORE than enough for this situation. I'd even say extensive reparations is overkill given that this is a shared incident involving multiple parties. Costing a whole college fund is way too much for someone who wasn't even seriously injured. The rest is just blatantly ridiculous. These are children. This is the time in their lives where they are permitted to fuck up within reason, and everything she's done is still within reason, based on action and intent.

I'm not gonna laugh at kicking a bad dog after you've already put it in its place. That's just sadism. I will laugh at NTRman who is actually deserving of this comical treatment because he is so comically and unreasonably malicious that I can't even picture him as a real kid.

What I really like is the presence of supportive adults and teachers, which almost never happens in these stories unless the teacher is a main character themself.

What in the dumb take is this? The actions that were taken could have very well ended with very horrendous results for the MC. Just because it didn't succeed in doing so doesn't mean all of a sudden everything isn't nearly as bad. Imagine if I shot you with a gun, but you ended up surviving because the right people were with you who subdued me, and gave life saving first aid that allowed enough time for you to get life saving treatment at the hospital. Does that suddenly mean I should just get a slap on the wrist and let go because you survived and didn't get "irreparable" damage? If nothing was done by the adults around him (including the fmc), MC would have killed himself or lived the most miserable life alone outside of his mom. Furthermore, just because he's being helped like this doesn't mean that there wasn't any lasting damage. I'm fairly sure he's traumatized by the entire event, regardless of the support, and that will still affect him. People don't just suddenly get over such traumatic experiences, they hold onto that trauma and pain. They just learn to deal with it better down the road.

 

[Beatrice]

What in the dumb take is this? The actions that were taken could have very well ended with very horrendous results for the MC. Just because it didn't succeed in doing so doesn't mean all of a sudden everything isn't nearly as bad. Imagine if I shot you with a gun, but you ended up surviving because the right people were with you who subdued me, and gave life saving first aid that allowed enough time for you to get life saving treatment at the hospital. Does that suddenly mean I should just get a slap on the wrist and let go because you survived and didn't get "irreparable" damage? If nothing was done by the adults around him (including the fmc), MC would have killed himself or lived the most miserable life alone outside of his mom. Furthermore, just because he's being helped like this doesn't mean that there wasn't any lasting damage. I'm fairly sure he's traumatized by the entire event, regardless of the support, and that will still affect him. People don't just suddenly get over such traumatic experiences, they hold onto that trauma and pain. They just learn to deal with it better down the road.

All this yapping and not a single bit of understanding. I dont know what kind of fantasy land you live in, but punishment is decided by both intent and consequence. This goes both ways. If you try and fail to murder someone, you'd be held for attempted murder. Succeeding in the act nets you a harsher punishment. On the complete opposite end of the spectrum, someone without any intent could actually end up killing someone, either through ignorance, carelessness, or neglect, and they'd be punished for the consequences of their mistake, with the absence of intent mitigating the degree.

Nothing that has happened to the MC is irreparable. I am specifically referring to the material. He's not dead. He's not suffered any disabilities. Trauma is something that can be overcome, so it's not irreversible or irreparable. He's already in a more stable place. Spare me.