Katainaka no Ossan, Kensei ni Naru ~Tada no Inaka no Kenjutsu Shihan Datta noni, Taisei Shita Deshi-tachi ga Ore wo Hottekurenai Ken~ - Vol. 10 Ch. 4…

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 17, 2023
Messages
267
Hmmm... I am really curious about Roze's motivation... clearly, it is religious; the prince is against the church and all that... but she seems smart enough to understand that the church and the faith are not the same.
I'm probably being incredibly naive, but I'm still holding out hope she's actually a double agent.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 22, 2018
Messages
667
Yup, I read the novels and I agree 100%, though I havent seen the anime. I bought the novels to support the series but I have to admit the manga is so much better.

Anime version is pretty much one to one to light novel more or less. It sticks pretty closely to what light novel did but due to that, especially for people who also read manga, you can tell how lacking some of it is.

You don’t see manga originals in the anime so there’s also that factor too.

While I liked the anime giving us the fights in motion. But it heavily relies on CG models of the characters for those scenes. Despite the good job making the CG models match their art style. Some of the motions feel too slow due to it. They kinda fixed this issue in the second season but due to anime directly adapting light novel without adding anything from the manga. Overall if one reads the manga while watching anime a sense of something is missing will happen. And unfortunately a sense of disappointment especially when comparing manga and anime together.

Anime is not bad, just the manga does way too good of a job taking the light novel material and making it better.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 30, 2023
Messages
38
Only watched the anime (which, by proxy, is more truthful to LN).

In the anime, there is no "Hinnis and the gang". The enemy assassin group is a nameless, generic, faceless NPCs and we never get to see what is going on with them and their details, outside of the exposition of they're an assassin group hired by Sven religion faction (the Pope) to take out Sven nation loyalist figurehead (the Prince).

The first breakout happened somewhere at the plaza, instead of a main road in the manga, where the assassins employed smoke screen to move through the royal guard defense line, but they ultimately thwarted with minimum casualty on defenders' side. Berryl noticed the assassin's attempt to kys during the fight, but most importantly, he saw Roze's fighting style being very aggressive and violent. She was more of a defensive type with proficiency at handling a shield back in the dojo. No restraint in killing the attackers despite the instruction to capture the assailants whenever possible.

Likewise, there's no scene about Royal Guards' initiative to assault the assassin's base (because the assassins are faceless NPC), so the scene went from that previous fight, to a bit of downtime and Roze's backstory (spoiler section below), and straight into what the manga is getting into: the City Tour chapter. Yes, Fey is manga exclusive character, just like Hinnis-and-the-gang is. Yes, there was no Prince depresso episode.
IIRC Hinnis was mentioned in the anime as the mastermind behind the prince attack in S2, when Beryl and Gatga meet again and discuss about the past incident. Maybe he/she will still appear?
 
Contributor
Joined
Feb 4, 2019
Messages
9,694
I'm very interested to see how they explain Roze not being hanged for conspiring to assassinate the prince after the arc finishes.

In the anime: Beryl kicks the shit out of her, and decides with her brother "Beard-Ponytail" to hide her involvement in the assassination and have her leave the church knights and country to go into hiding "due to severe wounds suffered in the battle.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 6, 2023
Messages
1,978
Only watched the anime (which, by proxy, is more truthful to LN).

In the anime, there is no "Hinnis and the gang". The enemy assassin group is a nameless, generic, faceless NPCs and we never get to see what is going on with them and their details, outside of the exposition of they're an assassin group hired by Sven religion faction (the Pope) to take out Sven nation loyalist figurehead (the Prince).

The first breakout happened somewhere at the plaza, instead of a main road in the manga, where the assassins employed smoke screen to move through the royal guard defense line, but they ultimately thwarted with minimum casualty on defenders' side. Berryl noticed the assassin's attempt to kys during the fight, but most importantly, he saw Roze's fighting style being very aggressive and violent. She was more of a defensive type with proficiency at handling a shield back in the dojo. No restraint in killing the attackers despite the instruction to capture the assailants whenever possible.

Likewise, there's no scene about Royal Guards' initiative to assault the assassin's base (because the assassins are faceless NPC), so the scene went from that previous fight, to a bit of downtime and Roze's backstory (spoiler section below), and straight into what the manga is getting into: the City Tour chapter. Yes, Fey is manga exclusive character, just like Hinnis-and-the-gang is. Yes, there was no Prince depresso episode.

Just as shown in the manga (and I hope it will be explored further, even if just one-pager), Roze is very caring towards children. This trait is noticed by the papal faction, and they basically weaponize it to coerce Roze into participating in the assassination attempt. I won't spoil further beyond what the manga have shown, because I think it is going to be a p good revelation, even though simple. And yes, there will be a 1-on-1 between her and Berryl.
Thank you very much for taking the time to write that. Let alone being conservative with the spoiler but just enough to shed some light. Cheers and enjoy your weekend homie!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 24, 2023
Messages
1,589
They’re really going to set up the rouge desciple for a redemption arc, huh?

It’s fine if she dies, and he learns some self awareness about his skill and maybe that he should be discerning about who he teaches.

Gonna be pissed if she survives and is added to the roster.
She was forced to be a spy. As you can see she is very protective of children, and belong to some orphanage knightsor some shi. I believe they hold all the children of the orphanage hostage or something. Manga is already much better then LN and anime, but they also changed quite much of the story, so I can't be sure if she'll survive or not
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 24, 2018
Messages
190
ohh things are getting more complicated now! guess we will see Rose fight Aleucia soon, since she's revealed she's the spy here, Beryl will need to put it all if he wants to defeat them, since the assassins will do anything to get to the prince, my guess is Rose will fight Aelucia she will defeat her in a kind of fake out that she killed her, to rile up Beryl some more later on, since the manga is deviating a lot from what happened on the anime since that one is based on the VN
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 25, 2018
Messages
2,964
Only watched the anime (which, by proxy, is more truthful to LN).

In the anime, there is no "Hinnis and the gang". The enemy assassin group is a nameless, generic, faceless NPCs and we never get to see what is going on with them and their details, outside of the exposition of they're an assassin group hired by Sven religion faction (the Pope) to take out Sven nation loyalist figurehead (the Prince).

The first breakout happened somewhere at the plaza, instead of a main road in the manga, where the assassins employed smoke screen to move through the royal guard defense line, but they ultimately thwarted with minimum casualty on defenders' side. Berryl noticed the assassin's attempt to kys during the fight, but most importantly, he saw Roze's fighting style being very aggressive and violent. She was more of a defensive type with proficiency at handling a shield back in the dojo. No restraint in killing the attackers despite the instruction to capture the assailants whenever possible.

Likewise, there's no scene about Royal Guards' initiative to assault the assassin's base (because the assassins are faceless NPC), so the scene went from that previous fight, to a bit of downtime and Roze's backstory (spoiler section below), and straight into what the manga is getting into: the City Tour chapter. Yes, Fey is manga exclusive character, just like Hinnis-and-the-gang is. Yes, there was no Prince depresso episode.

Just as shown in the manga (and I hope it will be explored further, even if just one-pager), Roze is very caring towards children. This trait is noticed by the papal faction, and they basically weaponize it to coerce Roze into participating in the assassination attempt. I won't spoil further beyond what the manga have shown, because I think it is going to be a p good revelation, even though simple. And yes, there will be a 1-on-1 between her and Berryl.
What a letdown
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 20, 2018
Messages
4,227
They’re really going to set up the rouge desciple for a redemption arc, huh?

It’s fine if she dies, and he learns some self awareness about his skill and maybe that he should be discerning about who he teaches.

Gonna be pissed if she survives and is added to the roster.
Yeah, I like her looks, but if she is truly a traitor, then she deserves to be put to the sword.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 23, 2023
Messages
1,090
i honestly hope these terrorist regicidal clowns die like the dogs they are, and die horrible excruciating deaths (ofc that's not going to happen, we have other manga like hero Raoul one for that)
Tried to search for Raoul and Raul mangas, is it the one with the shota vampire, the "Genderbent Knight Raul, the Fallen Whore" one, or the Raul Evans one?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top