With all due respect, villain was kind of right about having a ruler that folds under threat it's kind of incompetent and unworthy to rule.
I more or less agree that a ruler who is able to be deposed by a single hostage isn't exactly a great ruler security wise, but if the alternative is the one going around blackmailing and holding people hostage I'm not sure I want them as a ruler either.
But also, if I had to choose between defending someone who would give up their life for someone else, or siding with the one doing the killing...I'd side with Queen too. I don't think either of them make the best ruler, but if those are the options, then I know which I'd pick.