Kimi ga Hoeru Tame no Uta wo, - Vol. 5 Ch. 23 - Parent and Child

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 28, 2025
Messages
5,355
That...was a bit abrupt for my tastes, but definitely not unexpected for the story and the author.

Haru being the one to tell her off feels like cutting into Yuu's moment of finally confronting her mother for a decade of abandonment, which I can't say feels great. It's good that Haru's grown to the point she can speak her mind like this with confidence, but this was Yuu's time to move forward on her own two feet. The two are a support for one another, sure, and I see the value in Haru condemning Ruriko's actions while Yuu forgives her and tells her to stop being selfish—thus giving Ruriko a path back into the family—but it was ten years. That's just such a long time, and even with the threat of cancer on the table, it just feels too neat and clean, for me, given this series is a about emotions and the intensity they can have, for good or ill.

Just comes off a bit ..."sterile", almost. But, it is what it is.

The important thing is the foreshadowed debut concert now, so I guess that will also coincide with Haru answering Yuu's confession.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 15, 2023
Messages
3,641
Yeah, nah. This was very poorly written and executed. Ruriko's excuse is ridiculous, to say the least, and I don't think she deserves any forgiveness. I also don't feel sorry for her condition.

But to be fair, I think the author kinda wrote themselves into a corner. The whole premise of a mother abandoning her daughter, never coming to see her, and then suddenly showing up out of the blue without even telling her daughter she's coming back makes it really hard to generate any sympathy for her.

Thanks for the chapter!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 17, 2024
Messages
1,001
ee1b6e160c9f.jpg


Good job Haru going forward and saying all that to mama, she needed to hear that to get her head straight.

Of course, her condition was indeed terrible and the fear of losing one thing that allows you to make money and be successful in life is terrifying though on it's own, it still does not excuse that she took the younger daughter with her and didn't got back for the last 10 years... Which I doubt, she had to find time to at least go back once a year and to check how her older daughter is doing but the manga will not show that to us...

In any case, this could have been handled better. And in all of this mess nobody asked some very important questions: where is dad? Where are her parents? Could nobody else help her? Advise her? Was truly her only option to go to USA and leave her older daughter behind so that younger one could develop her talent properly?

I have so many question but I will leave it at this. Entire point is for Haru and Yuu to sing together, get together and slick eachother. :meguusmug:

In any case, what's left now is just for the grand debut concert and we can finish this story. Which is a damn shame as it could have been a LOT better.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 10, 2023
Messages
113
Im glad Ruriko has been condemned for her actions, that Haru spoke up when Yuu couldn’t find her voice, and that this isn’t really just blown over.

The girls all clearly looked up to Ruriko, so it was made clear that she would eventually be forgiven, but I don’t think we’re at forgiveness yet.

This feels like a second chance. “What you did wasn’t okay. Now prove you’ll put your daughters first”
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 1, 2023
Messages
1,365
Yuu didn't forgive her. She essentially told her, "you're supposed to live your life for/with us, you selfish prick."

She was way too nice about it but yuu is a quiet type of person, thanks to her mom abandoning her.... She was never the type to yell excessively and her partner helped sooth a lot of her pain already so it's more dull than sharp now. Faced with her mom's mortality she relented for now. She should confront her more later.

A celebrity being too cowardly and selfish to lose what they feel makes them "special" makes perfect sense. Vanity and celebrity go together like pb&j. Prioritizing her voice and kid she figured best to continue her legacy and has the most potential fits the bill for a selfish celebrity. Cancer is horrible and her luck is shit but abandoning your family for your singing voice is objectable. I can't say I don't get it. Her one thing that made her feel worth something was at risk and she chose that over her kid and husband. It's very human to do something selfish like that. And, of course, we can hate her for it.
 
Last edited:
Active member
Joined
Apr 18, 2025
Messages
11
Im glad Ruriko has been condemned for her actions, that Haru spoke up when Yuu couldn’t find her voice, and that this isn’t really just blown over.

The girls all clearly looked up to Ruriko, so it was made clear that she would eventually be forgiven, but I don’t think we’re at forgiveness yet.

This feels like a second chance. “What you did wasn’t okay. Now prove you’ll put your daughters first”
Agreed. I don't think she's forgiven quite yet, and right now is her time to "repent" for her "sins" by being an actual mother again.

This was also only ever going to play out one way. Yuu tells us during her talk with Haru in Chapter 5 "You probably think she's a terrible mother, but she's still my mom." Yuu deeply loves her mom, so any expectations of her cutting her out of her life or even hating her was out of the question from Volume 1.

I have a feeling this manga will get axed...
Seems like it already did by how it's paced now T_T

Kashikaze just writes fast paced. Lonely Girl had the same breakneck plot resolution. Sora's mom was introduced in Chapter 15 and resolved in Chapter 16. She doesn't really linger on drama, and moves on from certain plot points quickly. It's just her writing style.

Next chapter (possibly the debut concert and Haru's response to Yuu's confession) should wrap up Volume 5, and then Volume 6, if I had to guess, will be the final volume. This would give it the same amount of volumes as Lonely Girl and be a pretty standard manga run length. I don't think there's any sign of the series being axed, it's performing fine domestically.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top