183 Tejou no Sousakan - Oneshot

[MangaDex]

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

As an oneshot, this was nothing.
Not a good choice if the goal was to make a reader interested in a novel series.
We are just getting told that the convict is apparently good at the job, but he doesn't do anything to show that.
The entire thing is a bunch of hot air.
I am not interested in even looking at the novel, even if I was reading novels.

 

[UnluckyGrape]

183cm or in freedom units, around 6 feet

 

[maxyall]

Why would they make it seem like his height would be the main plot point or something smh

 

[Ares19373]

You smell that? Yes thats right.

Gay bait.

 

[DiaaaR]

Pairing detective with convict, kinda reminds me of Psycho Pass 🤔

 

[ieatass69]

6' vs 5'11

 

[Sunspawn]

You smell that? Yes thats right.

Gay bait.

Especially considering the artist's series.

 

[BCS]

You smell that? Yes thats right.

Gay bait.

I actually did a double take for the yaoi tag

 

[Oeconomist]

Instead of “Oneshot”, let's call this a “Pilot”, and add the tags “Commercial Failure” and “Artistic Failure”.

 

[feha]

read more like a promo than a oneshot, for some reason. Almost as if it was a mis-tagged promo

As an oneshot, this was nothing.
Not a good choice if the goal was to make a reader interested in a novel series.
We are just getting told that the convict is apparently good at the job, but he doesn't do anything to show that.
The entire thing is a bunch of hot air.
I am not interested in even looking at the novel, even if I was reading novels.

Instead of “Oneshot”, let's call this a “Pilot”, and add the tags “Commercial Failure” and “Artistic Failure”.

QFT

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

read more like a promo than a oneshot, for some reason. Almost as if it was a mis-tagged promo


QFT

Even as a promo, it did nothing to make me even the slightest bit interested in the story.
It was pure telling with nothing shown
Edit: Also learnt what QFT meant just now, mb

 

[Redaer-Feka]

As a promo, this feels bit lackluster? A shame cause I liked the artist, they probably should expand some more on what sort of dynamic the cop and convict got