@KRBlack Well, healing magic isn't always omnipotent even when a setting has it. I've seen some similar scenarios mentioned in other stuff where even if they can do something about injuries like this, it has to happen in a certain amount of time too. Almost immediately, like maybe a healer capable of it had to be on the scene while it happened to get there fast enough. Plenty of ways to go between just the "yes/no" versions of healing missing limbs.