5Toubun no Hanayome - Vol. 11 Ch. 88 - A Certain Boy and I ①
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Member
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2018
- Messages
- 403
Hmm... I know I've argued different points on this topic but...
I think Yotsuba could have been the first "Rena" to meet Fuutaro in Chapter 42 and not Itsuki!! lol 😀
I had been going on the idea that first Rena was Itsuki because she saw Fuu's picture in his handbook in the Chapter 2.
But now I'm thinking... Itsuki did find the picture of Fuu and Yotsuba from 5 years ago... but afterwards she confronted Yotsuba and told her that she saw the pic of her and the boy in Fuu's handbook. It really makes more sense that if a sister finds a picture of a boy and her sister from 5 years ago, that she'd want to tell her (Yotsuba) of such a crazy find.
In Chapter 42 "Rena" shows Fuu the charm to show him that she is the girl from 5 years ago in Kyoto... Yotsuba knows the meaning of the charms! https://mangadex.org/chapter/381143/2
I got thrown off thinking only Itsuki knew the pic of them was in the handbook so Rena had to be Ituski... But if Itsuki told Yotsuba where the pic was when she saw it, then she would know too.
And even though Yots is notoriously known for being bad at pretending to be another sister... she's not pretending to be another sister... just in disguise.
In Chapter 34, Itsuki shows him the charm she keeps with her when trying to show him that she's determined to change herself too. When Fuu asked where she got it, she said she didn't remember if she bought it or given so doesn't know the whole story of how Yotuba bought them or that he was with her when she did.
Chapter 41 page 5.... I'm thinking yotsuba was the person hiding while Fuu and Itsuki was talking and Fuu told Itsuki that because of the girl in Kyoto that he had decided to become a person that would be necessary to someone. https://mangadex.org/chapter/363853/5
And in Chapter 42, Rena basically repeated and made the comment that he has become a person "necessary" to the sisters. https://mangadex.org/chapter/381143/9
Edit: Chapter 79, it was Itsuki posing as Rena since she revealed that after their second meeting but I think it helps the author throw off the readers in figuring out Yotsuba was the first Rena at the lake.
Anyways, that's just my current theory and tossing it out for fun lol.
I think Yotsuba could have been the first "Rena" to meet Fuutaro in Chapter 42 and not Itsuki!! lol 😀
I had been going on the idea that first Rena was Itsuki because she saw Fuu's picture in his handbook in the Chapter 2.
But now I'm thinking... Itsuki did find the picture of Fuu and Yotsuba from 5 years ago... but afterwards she confronted Yotsuba and told her that she saw the pic of her and the boy in Fuu's handbook. It really makes more sense that if a sister finds a picture of a boy and her sister from 5 years ago, that she'd want to tell her (Yotsuba) of such a crazy find.
In Chapter 42 "Rena" shows Fuu the charm to show him that she is the girl from 5 years ago in Kyoto... Yotsuba knows the meaning of the charms! https://mangadex.org/chapter/381143/2
I got thrown off thinking only Itsuki knew the pic of them was in the handbook so Rena had to be Ituski... But if Itsuki told Yotsuba where the pic was when she saw it, then she would know too.
And even though Yots is notoriously known for being bad at pretending to be another sister... she's not pretending to be another sister... just in disguise.
In Chapter 34, Itsuki shows him the charm she keeps with her when trying to show him that she's determined to change herself too. When Fuu asked where she got it, she said she didn't remember if she bought it or given so doesn't know the whole story of how Yotuba bought them or that he was with her when she did.
Chapter 41 page 5.... I'm thinking yotsuba was the person hiding while Fuu and Itsuki was talking and Fuu told Itsuki that because of the girl in Kyoto that he had decided to become a person that would be necessary to someone. https://mangadex.org/chapter/363853/5
And in Chapter 42, Rena basically repeated and made the comment that he has become a person "necessary" to the sisters. https://mangadex.org/chapter/381143/9
Edit: Chapter 79, it was Itsuki posing as Rena since she revealed that after their second meeting but I think it helps the author throw off the readers in figuring out Yotsuba was the first Rena at the lake.
Anyways, that's just my current theory and tossing it out for fun lol.
Contributor
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2018
- Messages
- 1,177
So who was the bell kisser?
Member
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2018
- Messages
- 403
@Nyaalter
So am I because the idea Yotsuba was first Rena just kinda popped up in my head this morning lol.
I could easily shrug it away and say Ch 79 revealed Rena was Itsuki so it had to be Itsuki too in Ch 42... but... the one thing that keeps me thinking about it is Ch 34 where Itsuki shows Fuutaro her charm and she didn't remember if she bought it or given to her so she doesn't know the story of Yotsuba buying the charms together with Fuutaro. But in Ch 42, Rena makes her first appearance to Fuutaro and shows him the charm to prove she's the girl from Kyoto. If she did know the story by then, that would mean that Yotsuba told her and that Yotsuba was aware of who Fuu is by then.
The charm is also what tripped up Ichika in Chapter 83 when Fuu asked her if she remembered buying the charms back then... she said yes and that she had it with her and about to show him... but Rena gave her charm back in Chapter 42 and he lost it in the water that's why he told her that answer of meeting 5 years ago was a lie too... well at least part of it. So Rena doesn't have her charm anymore.
Makes you wonder why he just didn't ask each sister to see their charm eh?
So am I because the idea Yotsuba was first Rena just kinda popped up in my head this morning lol.
I could easily shrug it away and say Ch 79 revealed Rena was Itsuki so it had to be Itsuki too in Ch 42... but... the one thing that keeps me thinking about it is Ch 34 where Itsuki shows Fuutaro her charm and she didn't remember if she bought it or given to her so she doesn't know the story of Yotsuba buying the charms together with Fuutaro. But in Ch 42, Rena makes her first appearance to Fuutaro and shows him the charm to prove she's the girl from Kyoto. If she did know the story by then, that would mean that Yotsuba told her and that Yotsuba was aware of who Fuu is by then.
The charm is also what tripped up Ichika in Chapter 83 when Fuu asked her if she remembered buying the charms back then... she said yes and that she had it with her and about to show him... but Rena gave her charm back in Chapter 42 and he lost it in the water that's why he told her that answer of meeting 5 years ago was a lie too... well at least part of it. So Rena doesn't have her charm anymore.
Makes you wonder why he just didn't ask each sister to see their charm eh?
Member
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2018
- Messages
- 403
@Nyaalter
If you thought you were confused now... look at this and if you can tell me... Ch 36 Page 15... When looking at Yotsuba smile and a thought of young Yotsuba/Ichika from 5 years ago comes to mind...
https://mangadex.org/chapter/307525/16
What does Fuutaro mean when he says, "She wasn't one of THEM."
Did he know that there was more than one sister back then? Did he know the girl he met in the evening was not the same as the girl he spent time with during the day?
If you thought you were confused now... look at this and if you can tell me... Ch 36 Page 15... When looking at Yotsuba smile and a thought of young Yotsuba/Ichika from 5 years ago comes to mind...
https://mangadex.org/chapter/307525/16
What does Fuutaro mean when he says, "She wasn't one of THEM."
Did he know that there was more than one sister back then? Did he know the girl he met in the evening was not the same as the girl he spent time with during the day?
Member
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2018
- Messages
- 403
Member
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2018
- Messages
- 166
Member
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2018
- Messages
- 403
@TheOrigArcader
How about this page then... Yotsuba see's Miku and Yotsuba notices her daggers and says, "Bloodlust!" Lol.
https://mangadex.org/chapter/439804/18
How about this page then... Yotsuba see's Miku and Yotsuba notices her daggers and says, "Bloodlust!" Lol.
https://mangadex.org/chapter/439804/18
Quintuplets it's almost ending 😭
"Episode 90 has been published in this week's magazine! Last story last story! It is a series that I started while preparing for early termination, but I am grateful that I continued to this point. 100 episodes with 10 episodes remaining! Next week I go to the wind Taroumi!" - Haruba Negi
https://mobile.twitter.com/GasaiShadow/status/1141648358685077504
"Episode 90 has been published in this week's magazine! Last story last story! It is a series that I started while preparing for early termination, but I am grateful that I continued to this point. 100 episodes with 10 episodes remaining! Next week I go to the wind Taroumi!" - Haruba Negi
https://mobile.twitter.com/GasaiShadow/status/1141648358685077504
Similar threads
