A Returner's Magic Should Be Special - Vol. 5 Ch. 268

[mahtan]

Shouldn't it be Romantica?
Like Desir likes Adjest as a friend and all but he has been in love with Romantica from the start.

 

[mahtan]

Can confirm, in the raw he says 나는. It's"I" not "me".

I thought he choose himself at the end there, it would make sense to us because of his talk with his past self even if it doesn't make sense for the characters.

 

[Darklordkirby]

pretty good. the changes confused me a bit but i did enjoy them. the "open" ending doesnt really bug me as he was probably forced to take adjest as main wife and romantica as second since neither would yield and both would probably guard him like hawks. the only part of the ending that does bug me in what become of lunia as her pendent seem to operate separate of the system seeing as she could still be active after the systems complete destruction. i can only assume desir keeps it on him

 

[yourbaldhead]

Anyone recommend me finishing it I haven't read it since the end of season 1

yes, finish the novel instead

 

[Goldenzeal]

Shouldn't it be Romantica?
Like Desir likes Adjest as a friend and all but he has been in love with Romantica from the start.

Its even her in her name
But yeah, im also more on the Romantica train then Adjest.

Both are great and the Novel has a different clear cut ending where he marries Adjest.
But im not against this considering it gives Romantica a better chance.
Im not against a harems in fantasy stories, if you are going to make a harem a fantasy story is the right place for it.

 

[Goldenzeal]

Anyone recommend me finishing it I haven't read it since the end of season 1

if you enjoyed season 1 you probably will enjoy season 2.

 

[idkanymoredotexe]

yes, finish the novel instead

Ill just read the novel then thx

 

[XeraPyro]

Made me cry 7/10 Me's

 

[tm22zoro]

this makes me hate Romantica character What the author has done now is unforgivable I despise her character
because he couldn't make a decision and to keep it to Source material ! I feel like throwing up because of the lack of the decision 💀💀💀

 

[MLGOffensive]

Thanks for the manwha Mr. Author, the story is great, I like the open ending, and I dig the art. You really made my week

 

[Chickes]

Pussy author. I really don't understand why they didn't choose one. Choose one god damn it. Create the consequences for that choice but also reward the reader for it. Am I dumb thinking it's not that hard of a choice?

 

[Xero210234]

I guess my head canon is that he took both of them because he is greedy

 

[Xero210234]

Desir realizes: "Women are too stressful, I'm just going to jerk off".

FR

 

[Valzicplayz]

Why not make 2 endings? 1 where his with the blonde girl as a what if ending, and the one where he's with the other one. Even though it doesn't make sense to be single as he was already in a romance with brown hair girl.

 

[PyroclasticFlow]

kind of a crap ending overall...the final arc felt pretty forced, especially with the way it was resolved and the way the Saint just gave up, then the generic "every main character is now the most important person in the country" thing, and of course the all-timer "gosh I just can't decide" open-ended romance ending

 

[Asphalttt]

Was the Adjest romance more fleshed out in the novel? It's like they were bros (not the Sacred Band of Thebes kind of bros) for 265 chapters and then suddenly she wanted to bone.

 

[dokidoki]

Imagine making almost 300 chapters and you still can't fucking make up your mind on which girl MC should be with Holyshit man way to kill this series, dude should've either just gone with full on Romantica route like he wanted OR have just done the harem route OR make 2 endings 1 chapter for each girl ffs they've done it in harem manga's b4, idk how this series started so great and just kept getting worse and worse half way in, the second the art changed I knew the series was over, legit fucking feelsbadman

 

[kmd3133]

tbh i'd choose adjest; yeah romantica and desir loved each other before the return but after return, since romantica didnt know anything and desir was too busy saving the world, both adjest and romantica's feelings were kinda equal (in my perspective adjest was expressing her emotions a little better bc of her straightforwardness (and it was her first time learning about those emotions) unlike romantica who was behind the ''tsundere'' card, i couldnt feel the love in romantica it felt like a nice friendship until she watched desir's life.) until the end. thats why it made author choose an open ending sadly...

well for me: adjest + romantica > adjest > romantica > pram > any other girl > open ending

this is my ranking list for how ending should be. i would be able to say that ''oh this felt nice, perfect'' if it finished as adjest + romantica or adjest only with showing some after story about kids or something. it would be still fine if it was only romantica or pram or any other girl with some after story.

regrettably its open ending and that can clearly make me drop my rating to 9 from 10 for this story. bc, imo, even if there isnt romance tag on genres you r making a story 268 chapters long and develop romance aspects all the way to the end you should finish it to honor all that work. it made me feel like its incomplete, thats why its important for to finish romance part too in my perspective.
also its sad that author didnt write about pram x swan katarina i was waiting something from them too. anyway it was considerably long but a short journey for me since i started this when it was completed and finished it in 3 days i can say that i enjoyed it. thank you for the chapters and translations.