After Snowfall, Wonder

[MangaDex]

 

[Tikibo]

If this manga won an award how low were others? Not saying it's bad, but it's a definition of mediocrity. Mediocre story, mediocre characters (or rather lack of them), mediocre storytelling (actually panel flow was worse than average), better than average drawing and that's all.

 

[VawX]

Oh this is pretty neat, a little cryptic and cliche but pretty nice imagery using poltergeist mmm...

 

[ghostkun]

She looks like Rei, so 1000000000/10

 

[Kalendel]

@Tikibo These are manga magazine contests. They put out an open call for oneshots, and pick the best. Generally it's a brand new author without any other publications -- their "debut work". I like doing debut works

 

[Tikibo]

@Kalendel first, thank you for your work on this manga. Second, I know how such awards work. That's why I was wondering if other entries were lower in quality, as this is just mediocre. Most award-winning debut works I've read have "that something" in them. Gimmicks or ideas which make them interesting even if a bit rough around the edges. I just found it lacking in some way, nothing special, really.

 

[Hachi015]

The story telling in this one is kinda good, the way the author makes you think what was the spirits true purpose is great.

 

[Magboost]

Thanks I needed this