"..." - me"interesting, this bracket-style tournament is very flawed" - ppl used to less flawed systems
"yes, is that not good!?It's the entire selling point, that people who are objectively worse might score better than others, and matches can be rigged such that a political rival gets difficult opponents early on and fails to show any clear competence to the audience!" - mc
The problem is those "less flawed" systems are constantly being rigged already behind closed doors, so the plan is to make it all very public instead, and that necessitates a format that won't bore random student spectators (and which busy high officials can afford to watch themselves)."..." - me
No, you can absolutely make a round-robin be public too. It is not the less flawed systems that are rigged, it is that the recommendation itself is rigged (which btw the tournament wouldn't truly fix, all the tournament does it enable the victims of the rigging to get a rec through another approach - the scouting royal knight watching them).The problem is those "less flawed" systems are constantly being rigged already behind closed doors, so the plan is to make it all very public instead, and that necessitates a format that won't bore random student spectators.
Elimination tournament at the very least is more showy, easier to follow for the audience and shorter. Spectacle wise it is the better option, but yeah, much easier to rig.No, you can absolutely make a round-robin be public too. It is not the less flawed systems that are rigged, it is that the recommendation itself is rigged (which btw the tournament wouldn't truly fix, all the tournament does it enable the victims of the rigging to get a rec through another approach - the scouting royal knight watching them).
No, it is the flawed system that she proposed that is going to be rigged behind closed doors, as where people place and how good of a showing they can perform, is entirely dependent on who they end up facing.
The idea is basically they are doing an excessive amount of training not to actually train, but just to show off to neighbouring countries. She wants to propose a new way to show off.I can't imagine how a tournament would ever replace large scale military training.