Amayo no Tsuki - Vol. 11 Ch. 41 - Courage

Joined
Jan 7, 2025
Messages
2
Do give me more details
Saki gets hit in the face during gym so the school doctor sends her to hospital/home(not sure which). While she’s waiting for a bus the crush from middle school—Mahiro—shows up and Saki immediately has a panic attack. Mahiro is then aggressively “friendly” and pushy while Saki is obviously miserable. The latest chapter ends with her dragging saki onto a bus, and Kanon is getting worried cause Saki isn’t reading any of her messages.

So definitely pretty bad.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 2, 2019
Messages
3,232
Saki gets hit in the face during gym so the school doctor sends her to hospital/home(not sure which). While she’s waiting for a bus the crush from middle school—Mahiro—shows up and Saki immediately has a panic attack. Mahiro is then aggressively “friendly” and pushy while Saki is obviously miserable. The latest chapter ends with her dragging saki onto a bus, and Kanon is getting worried cause Saki isn’t reading any of her messages.

So definitely pretty bad.
Wow.
I'll check back when that arc ends...
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Dec 28, 2019
Messages
144
...I mean... dating someone does tend to require matching compatible genders and orientations...
what i mean to say is that saki has been fearful about being found out and lose her friend's affection since the start, and since way before during her entire life she has known she's a lesbian she's always had to hide herself. this would be a great way to focus on saki's development and psychology and emotional needs in a manga that has dealt mostly with kanon's. if kanon sorts out her feelings and.. idk, asks her out or something, we would be robbed of seeing that development because the problem never arose in the first place. saki's feelings would be requited and she will never have dealt with her fear on its own, without a love confession to "solve it". this is a story about their love yes, but also about their friendship and this has been the primary issue from saki's perspective for a long long while. it's not just that she's in love with kanon, but that she can't bring herself to trust her friend to even say she likes girls in the first place (plus, her love for piano is intrinsically tied to her first love for her teacher). if kanon finds out without them touching on their feelings, saki will finally know the relief of opening up to a friend about it and being accepted as she is. she doesn't have to necessarily be requited. she deserves to know kanon would never reject her from her life particularly because of her sexuality. not as a lover, but as a friend. (her life isn't just kanon after all. this is a fear that permeates all her relationships.)

this is also good for kanon's development. kanon has been confused about what she feels for a while now and she subconsciously suspects what it is. if she found out saki's gay it would make it real. one thing is to harbor feelings about someone you think is impossible to entertain, another is to know reality is closer than you thought.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
May 11, 2019
Messages
61
Do give me more details
In chapter 43, saki is thinking about her problems with "that" girl and thinking about kanon and what she need to do, in gymnasium she's was distracted and a ball hit her head and she left earlier and waiting for the bus to come, her "friend" from middle school appears and that triggers saki bad experience with her and she talks to Saki and asks why she's there, and Saki explains about the ball, etc., and then she forces Saki to go with her on the bus to Saki's house.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 2, 2019
Messages
3,232
what i mean to say is that saki has been fearful about being found out and lose her friend's affection since the start, and since way before during her entire life she has known she's a lesbian she's always had to hide herself. this would be a great way to focus on saki's development and psychology and emotional needs in a manga that has dealt mostly with kanon's. if kanon sorts out her feelings and.. idk, asks her out or something, we would be robbed of seeing that development because the problem never arose in the first place. saki's feelings would be requited and she will never have dealt with her fear on its own, without a love confession to "solve it". this is a story about their love yes, but also about their friendship and this has been the primary issue from saki's perspective for a long long while. it's not just that she's in love with kanon, but that she can't bring herself to trust her friend to even say she likes girls in the first place (plus, her love for piano is intrinsically tied to her first love for her teacher). if kanon finds out without them touching on their feelings, saki will finally know the relief of opening up to a friend about it and being accepted as she is. she doesn't have to necessarily be requited. she deserves to know kanon would never reject her from her life particularly because of her sexuality. not as a lover, but as a friend. (her life isn't just kanon after all. this is a fear that permeates all her relationships.)

this is also good for kanon's development. kanon has been confused about what she feels for a while now and she subconsciously suspects what it is. if she found out saki's gay it would make it real. one thing is to harbor feelings about someone you think is impossible to entertain, another is to know reality is closer than you thought.
I think you're WAAAAY overthinking this.
The way this is described here is way more dramatic than reality needs to be.

You don't need to go through the 12 steps of queerness before you do anything.

You don't need to come out in a very specific fashion, trauma dump, guage acceptance, wait until things are "back to normal" then ask someone out. (Don't need to come out at all)

You can just ask them out, and talk while a couple of it works out.

She doesn't need to sort out a specific label and hold a press conference.

She can just like a girl and be liked by a girl.

People these days are simultaneously clinging to labels like they're clubs instead of adjectives while simultaneously changing the definitions thereof into increasingly-vague parameters... But I digress.

The point is that you can just live your life as it comes. The future isn't purely dictates by the past.
She does not NEED to bring past drama into this relationship. She can deal with it in other ways.

Why does putting that on one's partner help anything?

Seek comfort with your partner, if course, but that shouldn't be the first thing you do! I ended up in a horrible relationship because of that.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
20
I think you're WAAAAY overthinking this.
The way this is described here is way more dramatic than reality needs to be.

You don't need to go through the 12 steps of queerness before you do anything.

You don't need to come out in a very specific fashion, trauma dump, guage acceptance, wait until things are "back to normal" then ask someone out. (Don't need to come out at all)

You can just ask them out, and talk while a couple of it works out.

She doesn't need to sort out a specific label and hold a press conference.

She can just like a girl and be liked by a girl.

People these days are simultaneously clinging to labels like they're clubs instead of adjectives while simultaneously changing the definitions thereof into increasingly-vague parameters... But I digress.

The point is that you can just live your life as it comes. The future isn't purely dictates by the past.
She does not NEED to bring past drama into this relationship. She can deal with it in other ways.

Why does putting that on one's partner help anything?

Seek comfort with your partner, if course, but that shouldn't be the first thing you do! I ended up in a horrible relationship because of that.
Well, from Saki's pov she is being held back by whatever struggles and trauma she's had had, and it is shown such. She does need to get over whatever she's being hung up on in order to move forward.

Am kinda happy that the JP chapters are finally touching on her past to see what's also affecting her actually.

Aside from the 'friend', none of the characters presented thus far had explicitly mentioned any negative comments about same sex relationships.

Akira in the earlier chapters even stated that it's just a normal want.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
20
some spoilers from chapter 42

Even Ayano, who has figured out what's up with these two idiots wasn't even phased by it. Anyway, would like to see the translator's take on this

I'm really thinking Saki is just the sort of person who just didnt want to impose her wants on others, in contrast to Kanon's tendency to do things on a whim. Even the earlier chapter with Rinne kinda implied so. She seems afraid of hurting other people's feelings.

A much earlier chapter where these two went on a movie together, Kanon even told her that there will be times Saki might do something that would hurt her, but she would know Saki's intent was genuine and thus would be ok with it. I'm thinking this might be why we had that chapter.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 31, 2019
Messages
739
There's just something that's been bugging me since the fireworks: Kanon has been pretty obvious that she was starting then kept crushing harder and harder for Saki romantically. But Saki didn't seem to notice any of those times, which is a bit jarring. Lately, it's been much more interesting to reframe the problem from her point of view as the possibility of romance might threaten the friendship they both value very much.

Rinne clocked Saki early then noticed Kanon next, the new photographer gal did it from afar, so I hope there will be the excuse that Saki had to lock away for her time her feelings when she had trouble even looking Kanon in the eye (but see, she didn't react when Kanon had the exact same reaction when she found her this pretty in her recital dress!)

Then again, I think the fact the jig is up might explain Saki's anger and frustration. From her point of view, she can't confess anything without risking too much, so it's true that it's more than time that Kanon asks Miura-sensei the definition of homosexuality because it might get hold to hear wonder wonder why the both of them keep getting this flustered.

This is just a mild criticism (mostly because I binged this and I'm pissed there's no confession when I'm done) but mostly about pacing. Otherwise, this story really translate well The Struggle of never knowing if you want/should risk a friendship for romance that so many (if not all?!) queer folks go through.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Dec 28, 2019
Messages
144
I think you're WAAAAY overthinking this.
The way this is described here is way more dramatic than reality needs to be.

You don't need to go through the 12 steps of queerness before you do anything.

You don't need to come out in a very specific fashion, trauma dump, guage acceptance, wait until things are "back to normal" then ask someone out. (Don't need to come out at all)

You can just ask them out, and talk while a couple of it works out.

She doesn't need to sort out a specific label and hold a press conference.

She can just like a girl and be liked by a girl.

People these days are simultaneously clinging to labels like they're clubs instead of adjectives while simultaneously changing the definitions thereof into increasingly-vague parameters... But I digress.

The point is that you can just live your life as it comes. The future isn't purely dictates by the past.
She does not NEED to bring past drama into this relationship. She can deal with it in other ways.

Why does putting that on one's partner help anything?

Seek comfort with your partner, if course, but that shouldn't be the first thing you do! I ended up in a horrible relationship because of that.
ok, thank you for the life lesson, but i'm talking about a fictional story with fictional themes and characters that were created to go through a certain development logic. i'm not looking at saki and kanon as real people here. i'm looking at them as characters with specific hangups in this certain genre of story that tends to adress hang-ups because the narrative itself brought them forth. if you're looking at that from a completely different view, nice, congrats, but you decided to engage with my opinion and this is the principle i'm coming from.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 29, 2019
Messages
675
Saki gets hit in the face during gym so the school doctor sends her to hospital/home(not sure which). While she’s waiting for a bus the crush from middle school—Mahiro—shows up and Saki immediately has a panic attack. Mahiro is then aggressively “friendly” and pushy while Saki is obviously miserable. The latest chapter ends with her dragging saki onto a bus, and Kanon is getting worried cause Saki isn’t reading any of her messages.

So definitely pretty bad.
I mean it's not horrible, there are worse arcs

Sounds like a good time for Kanon to figure things out and Saki to move past her trauma - type of arc.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top