Asobinin wa Kenja ni Tenshoku Dekiru tte Shittemashita? ~ Yuusha Party o Tsuihou Sareta Lv 99 - Ch. 45

[avefenixflames]

how will readers know harems are allowed???

it's a fantasy ecchi manga😑... literally the MC slept with both together before, but you really needed the manga to spell it out for you now... huh...

 

[deathmailrock]

it's a fantasy ecchi manga😑... literally the MC slept with both together before, but you really needed the manga to spell it out for you now... huh...

Except that is different from sleeping around.

In our real world, people can have 3somes in places without polygamy... so no, that isn't enough.

And frankly, a very simple explanation doesn't break a fantasy either.

 

[avefenixflames]

Except that is different from sleeping around.

In our real world, people can have 3somes in places without polygamy... so no, that isn't enough.

And frankly, a very simple explanation doesn't break a fantasy either.

You are trying to give the same constraints that the real world has to a fantasy story, you already failed to see my point again. The Harem concept was already present since the very start, just like human/cat hybrids and magic, Like I already said there is no need to justify their existence unless is to enhance the plot specially when they are presented as native concepts of said world. And yet again, that explanation they said clearly was only to justify it's concept to the reader not to the world since yet again, it's a concept that has been there since the start and they also said is something common to that continent/world.

And I didn't say it breaks the fantasy, I said it was unnecessary...

 

[deathmailrock]

You are trying to give the same constraints that the real world has to a fantasy story, you already failed to see my point again. The Harem concept was already present since the very start, just like human/cat hybrids and magic, Like I already said there is no need to justify their existence unless is to enhance the plot specially when they are presented as native concepts of said world. And yet again, that explanation they said clearly was only to justify it's concept to the reader not to the world since yet again, it's a concept that has been there since the start and they also said is something common to that continent/world.

And I didn't say it breaks the fantasy, I said it was unnecessary...

But it was necessary. It makes it known he can legally marry them.

Old rich people having mistresses and stuff isn't unusual either.

The point is to give the girls a LEGAL position. Without that, we wouldn't know if he could only have 1 wife or not...

He could ALWAYS have multiple LOVERS... but that isn't a wife... that isn't a legal position....

 

[avefenixflames]

But it was necessary. It makes it known he can legally marry them.

Old rich people having mistresses and stuff isn't unusual either.

The point is to give the girls a LEGAL position. Without that, we wouldn't know if he could only have 1 wife or not...

He could ALWAYS have multiple LOVERS... but that isn't a wife... that isn't a legal position....

He could have married everyone before the justification was said and it would have not changed a thing or felt out of place considering what the story has presented before and also considering the genre and tropes that the manga is following... it was quite unnecessary... also, the "legality" clearly was only brought up as a justification for future new additions to the harem group...

 

[deathmailrock]

He could have married everyone before the justification was said and it would have not changed a thing or felt out of place considering what the story has presented before and also considering the genre and tropes that the manga is following... it was quite unnecessary... also, the "legality" clearly was only brought up as a justification for future new additions to the harem group...

No, even "harem" series that won't allow real harems randomly add more girls.....

And honestly, I feel it isn't unnecessary, it just clarifies things and is giving readers a context while also being very short and unobtrusive.

And the issue would be if he married everyone at the end is that a legal harem is not the norm in the real world and even in a fantasy, it's not always allowed...

Too many fantasies also have no harems... so that legal clarification allows us to know that he can marry them.

It means it's not a sudden change, cause the other option is that only 1 of them can legally marry or he doesn't get married at all... and those are actually not uncommon either...

I read plenty of harem stories where the MC never marries his harem or he only had 1 legal wife....
_______________
In fact, I think the opposite is worse.

When the MC is in a world where harems are legal or some other dude gets a harem and then the MC is in a normal relationship.

I'm thinking that the author should just not have the harems at all and just have the 2 person relationship just be a 2 person relationship...

THAT is the norm after all and no harem mention needs to exist...