Black Madougushi Guild wo Tsuihousareta Watashi, Oukyuu Majutsushi to shite Hirowareru - Ch. 6

[MangaDex]

 

[Bladist]

The ship sails strong, bois.

 

[DeadKinginHell]

About those who insulted her, no consequences whatsoever on the spot? There should be some repercussions at the very least, maybe to their reputations in general. It should be made public that they made such insults towards the one who saved the queen/princess.

 

[weshwg]

Is it just me or this manga didnt have a reverse harem tag before? God please let the tag be a mistake i dont want any sort of harem..

 

[forecast]

About those who insulted her, no consequences whatsoever on the spot? There should be some repercussions at the very least, maybe to their reputations in general. It should be made public that they made such insults towards the one who saved the queen/princess.

swept under the rug to avoid friction between countries. I imagine there would be a formal thanks for saving the queen, as well as an apology for the insults but it won't be public.

 

[Mageos]

thank you for the chapter

 

[Haezer]

The queen's guard is useless af bruh

 

[WhimsiCat]

About those who insulted her, no consequences whatsoever on the spot? There should be some repercussions at the very least, maybe to their reputations in general. It should be made public that they made such insults towards the one who saved the queen/princess.

They were just doing their jobs. It'd be more doubtful for bodyguards to just take the word of a stranger at face value.
They WERE in the process of asking her to show her proof of identity when the assassin act.

Also as seen in the chapter, once the shadows show up they prioritized protecting their charge, some being injured/possibly dead in the process.

Meanwhile Noel was so preoccupied with trying to catch the culprit she almost let the princess get harmed.

And YOU want them to face more consequences?

 

[Valve]

"No guests ware harmed" Yup, no guests, just the guards the guests brought with them to the party, shown dead on the floor a few pages back, but yes, no guests ware harmed.

 

[Elmithian]

They were just doing their jobs. It'd be more doubtful for bodyguards to just take the word of a stranger at face value.
They WERE in the process of asking her to show her proof of identity when the assassin act.

Also as seen in the chapter, once the shadows show up they prioritized protecting their charge, some being injured/possibly dead in the process.

Meanwhile Noel was so preoccupied with trying to catch the culprit she almost let the princess get harmed.

And YOU want them to face more consequences?

Yes. They did nothing to try to restrain him as well. All their focus went on her rather than half-half.

If I was their superior then I don't think it was beyond reason to permanently fire them. If their immediate reaction is to purely focus on the one who pushed the drink out of the way and called someone a poisoner, not even trying to at the very least try to restrict the potential poisoner, they are worse than trash.

She at the very least tried to take the threat down quickly before it could pull off more magic or attacks, since if she had just defended, she would have gradually gotten worn down. Sure, she did not make the best decision, but unlike the others, her decision wasn't incorrect, merely was not the ideal one.

 

[WhimsiCat]

Yes. They did nothing to try to restrain him as well. All their focus went on her rather than half-half.

If I was their superior then I don't think it was beyond reason to permanently fire them. If their immediate reaction is to purely focus on the one who pushed the drink out of the way and called someone a poisoner, not even trying to at the very least try to restrict the potential poisoner, they are worse than trash.

She at the very least tried to take the threat down quickly before it could pull off more magic or attacks, since if she had just defended, she would have gradually gotten worn down. Sure, she did not make the best decision, but unlike the others, her decision wasn't incorrect, merely was not the ideal one.

Ah yes, clearly when facing dubious person some should've at least take their words at face value and split attention, reducing combat power facing the one making the claim.
Not to mention the person being doubted is supposedly a veteran butler of the royal palace.
So in your opinion: They don't know who's right, but apparently doubting a court mage who's acting as secret security deserve firing, but believing a 'stranger' and doubting a trusted royal butler will totally be a-ok?

Surely if a villain actually do that and the guards facing them get taken down before the ones with their back turned get hit by surprise attack you'll just say 'oh well, they don't deserve to get fired for being fooled like that' right?

Again, they were about to confirm her identity which once done her words would have a lot more credibility (since she would also be able to explains she found the real butler)
I don't see you calling for Noel to get fired for disregarding protecting VIPs (the main job) to hunt down assassin for achievement.
She DID get gradually get worn down AND distracted away from the VIP (she didn't even notice the other guards has been taken out until then) and the situation only got saved by Luke arriving.

her decision wasn't incorrect, merely was not the ideal one.

If that excuse work for her, why not them. From their view she was close to VIP while the other guy was a good distance away.

 

[Meridis]

"No guests ware harmed" Yup, no guests, just the guards the guests brought with them to the party, shown dead on the floor a few pages back, but yes, no guests ware harmed.

yeah, see, we don't include the red shirts in the statistics...that would decrease moral.

 

[JACGohu]

Thanks for this, but could the editor do something about consistency please? Page 4, "Queen". Page 18, becomes a "Princess"?

Unless there was some other noble there, only other people I can tell are there are the assassin and the security teams.

 

[kinkajou]

Many thanks for the update!

 

[cryum]

About those who insulted her, no consequences whatsoever on the spot? There should be some repercussions at the very least, maybe to their reputations in general. It should be made public that they made such insults towards the one who saved the queen/princess.

I mean they might be dead, so...

 

[DeadKinginHell]

They were just doing their jobs. It'd be more doubtful for bodyguards to just take the word of a stranger at face value.
They WERE in the process of asking her to show her proof of identity when the assassin act.

Also as seen in the chapter, once the shadows show up they prioritized protecting their charge, some being injured/possibly dead in the process.

Meanwhile Noel was so preoccupied with trying to catch the culprit she almost let the princess get harmed.

And YOU want them to face more consequences?

She was preoccupied with the assassin due to him clearly targeting the princess/queen. Should she let her attention off of him, he would take the chance to kill the target.
So, Noel here was trying to limit the assassin's movement instead. She was actually making the best decision possible. Unlike the morons who was suspecting her for no good reason at all. Besides, in the previous chapter, she already told them about the suspicion albeit instantly. It was an emergency.
Instead of just pointing swords at her and insulting her like that, they should inquiring both parties. This is why those morons need consequences.

 

[WhimsiCat]

She was preoccupied with the assassin due to him clearly targeting the princess/queen. Should she let her attention off of him, he would take the chance to kill the target.

Ah yes, her focus was so necessary to prevent the assassin from reaching the VIP- oh fucking wait
If you want to punish incompetence, why not start there? She could've been closer to the guards or cooperate with them now that the assassin revealed himself.

So, Noel here was trying to limit the assassin's movement instead. She was actually making the best decision possible. Unlike the morons who was suspecting her for no good reason at all. Besides, in the previous chapter, she already told them about the suspicion albeit instantly. It was an emergency.
Instead of just pointing swords at her and insulting her like that, they should inquiring both parties. This is why those morons need consequences.

It was an emergency, yes, and they WERE reaching the point of asking her for proof of her identity.
Y'know, because at that moment there's only her words and no proof she IS a court magician, or that the disguised butler was indeed assassin?
From the time she landed in last chapter to them demanding she prove her identity, there's probably less than a minute that passed.
Give them a few more moment for her to prove her identity and they'd probably cooperate with her.
The assassin knew he couldn't let the situation de-escalate that's why he dropped the act and went for the frontal assault.

But hey, apparently if you're a guard and a random assassin just barge in and say they're part of security, YOU'd believe them and let them walk up and kill your VIP won't you.

 

[DeadKinginHell]

Ah yes, her focus was so necessary to prevent the assassin from reaching the VIP- oh fucking wait
If you want to punish incompetence, why not start there? She could've been closer to the guards or cooperate with them now that the assassin revealed himself.



It was an emergency, yes, and they WERE reaching the point of asking her for proof of her identity.
Y'know, because at that moment there's only her words and no proof she IS a court magician, or that the disguised butler was indeed assassin?
From the time she landed in last chapter to them demanding she prove her identity, there's probably less than a minute that passed.
Give them a few more moment for her to prove her identity and they'd probably cooperate with her.
The assassin knew he couldn't let the situation de-escalate that's why he dropped the act and went for the frontal assault.

But hey, apparently if you're a guard and a random assassin just barge in and say they're part of security, YOU'd believe them and let them walk up and kill your VIP won't you.

Then it would be too late. The moment they pinned her and she stopped moving, the target would already be dead. It's clear, they're the incompetent ones here. Too subjective to be guards. They don't even have the skills to do decision-making like this and they're called guards? Pathetic.
They didn't even coordinate with the court magicians for missions like these, what a bunch of idiots they are? Must be their pride or something getting in the way....

 

[WhimsiCat]

Then it would be too late. The moment they pinned her and she stopped moving, the target would already be dead.

What the heck are you talking about? If Noel stopped moving the target will be dead?
Did you miss the page where Noel was still moving AND the target was about to get killed?

Not to mention she already shown an option that would keep the VIP safe: Do you remember what she did before

It's clear, they're the incompetent ones here. Too subjective to be guards. They don't even have the skills to do decision-making like this and they're called guards? Pathetic.

At least when the fighting began, they actually focus on protecting the VIP, unlike another person who forgot that her job is priority is protection

They didn't even coordinate with the court magicians for missions like these, what a bunch of idiots they are? Must be their pride or something getting in the way....

It's almost like this is a secret operation, to not ruin the atmosphere.

 

[Otong777]

What? This manga get reverse harem tag?
Fuck I thought this will be focus on just Male Lead and Female Lead