Bokura no Hentai

Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
833
Well, I guess you should never judge a book by its cover! I liked the cover, in fact.

Appalling drawings, confusing pacing, weird interactions... From the first three chapters, my sole opinion is that this is just boring. And way too much drama looming over the horizon.

Perhaps the usual discord-lurking weebs with them flags on their walls might find this interesting. But not for me.
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2024
Messages
4
that was really fucking good. and it handled the trans stuff rather well. truly dont think im gonna find anything this good for a while, atleast this good at handling gender.

Youre embarrassing and its really sad that youre incapable of viewing or critically interpreting fiction in any other way than through latest culturally approved fad optics and-or academic slash environmentally imprinted programming. Limiting yourself to diet of 'queer' (even loosely) themed comics exclusively gotta be doing something to your brain, because so far Ive seen you posting here two types of things only: either giving a title your stamp of lgbutiq wokeness approval and singing its praises (which are sometimes amplified with trademarked kasparian iteration of the word 'fuck'), or expressing displeasure when you think the topic of broadly defined "identity" has been mishandled. It cant help that these manga are more of then not extremely removed from reality of how things are, not only in the west, but life in general.

There were also many bitch trips when people tried to challenge your beliefs, but lets not talk about them, cause there hasnt been one that didnt come off as pathetic or extremely petty.

Intellectually youre an equivalent of middle aged woman who believes herself cultured because she reads over 300 harlequin novels a years.
I liked the manga and Indentifyied in some points of the characters but you r totally right ,ts is too far from realty and if is taken seriously it may convince some chronically online guys to turn like marika (funny name considering the context and the use of it in Spanish)
 
Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2024
Messages
23
i don't see how people say this is the best trans manga
Aoki says she wants to be a girl a few times, many chapters later she disappears for a bit and comes out of the hospital as a girl, no mention of anything that actually goes into transitioning. everyone immediately accepts it and there's only one singular instance of transphobia that happens behind her back which is weird considering how (overly) messed up the other 2 MCs' childhoods are. also Aoki stops being the focus after that so she doesn't get any character development afterwards except for the time skips at the end.
also, convoluted romance that doesn't go anywhere with any character.
it's decent, but just not satisfying or convincing
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 10, 2020
Messages
4
that was really fucking good. and it handled the trans stuff rather well. truly dont think im gonna find anything this good for a while, atleast this good at handling gender.

edit: on the epilouge:
the epilogue is really fucking depressing, dont bother if you thought this ending was good enough.
Could you give a summary of it, please?
 
Joined
Sep 16, 2026
Messages
12
Spoiler ultra hell, thoughts after finishing


I'm so happy for Marika and Ryou, they had such happy and hopeful endings, so I immediately clocked Parou's storyline as feeling wrong and without closure, and I was, in fact right - because it was most likely intentional..

Author sent him to superhell, he did a lot of bad shit tho but damn, fuck, his backstory was arguably the most messed up... 😭😭😭 that extra epilogue he had was evil I went in maybe 90% expecting something better 10% bracing myself, went out way depressed lol.

Can we pretend his entire life is a dream, this is legitimately so sad, he's the only one who had a horrible ending and I was rooting for him since he just kept going through it all, but I do guess once again he kept acting so cruel to everyone. Doesn't make him less of a victim but still, doesn't remove him from accountability either. Rip man

Anyways I really loved the writing in this one, kinda sad that Marika kinda got pushed out of the way near the end but I suppose her arc was over. I love her so much, she is so shoujo, and while she's a regular schmegular shy shoujo schoolgirl mc, she has more depth than that (not as insane as parou) and I really loved her soo muchh! I also love that she legitimately HAS A SPINE OMG. I kind of get her just accepting it at the beginning (not really accepting but not responding) especially in terms of self-preservation (in a physical way only at least... rip).

MINI RANT:

But GOD i am so happy the author actually took her seriously!! Even researched!! Especially since Fumi highkey loves crossdressers and "femboys" I kinda just assumed she wouldn't create a distinction between them and transgender women, but even though it's the bare minimum... I guess I'm too desensitized, despite once loving "gender-benders" (kind of a term with a blurry line if not shape or definition - what even goes under gender bender or what makes something not be under gender bender?) I ended up disliking them because of the sheer lack of tact so many of them have. Look, it's different if it's a fetish if you just wanna diddle your widdle, I don't care about that and I'm not talking about them, especially when it's just lighthearted comedy. Feel free to jerk it off! it's when you take yourself so seriously while writing in the most bullshit way, which I see in MANY comics, about a real life group of people and not even trying while still benefiting from them and/or their experiences/most likely suffering that it becomes SO STRANGE. I wish people stopped treating people like will they wont they schrodinger's femboy written as an actually woman, writing based on the experiences of women, but still trying to appeal to people who empathize with said vulnerable minority and people who hate said minority yet jerk off to porn of them/genres while not literally about them are obviously derived from them! You can jerk off, porn is everywhere, majority of people have a libido, but just don't be a hypocrite especially when it involves and affects actual people.

I've just seen people try to create trans characters and end up writing them so weirdly it becomes offensive, especially when they don't research or heed the concerns of real life individuals under the minority, or individuals who've experienced serious traumatic experiences (in this case author herself, who I feel seems to have had placed a lot of herself in Parou especially considering her other works) they'll be writing about coughcoughIhatedThatOneMangaShitFromaButt so is this an ethical chaser or what? lol

On another note, and not directed to the story itself but in conjunction with my previous paragraph, as one study says: is the story explorative or exploitative of the transgender condition?

RANT OVER

Ryou was cool as hell too !! Tho idk if he deserves Hachi at all after all that... Akane was a sweetheart as hell despite some irks and Tomochi was soo lovely, idk if he and Marika ended up married but hey rooting for both of them regardless.. idk if we're gonna forget him being all touchy and shit with her at the beginning though lol. Parou in an alternate universe perhaps you are living happily, does [commenter] dream of Parou egolife and alternate universe happy ending where he actually heals and gets a boyfriend that doesn't continue to ruin his life and people who actually acknowledge that he was a victim and was abused for majority of his life? It's really fucked up because it truly, truly wasn't impossible for him to get better. But the ending-ending in his own epilogue didn't bode well and showed that it wasn't gonna get better soon/his life didn't seem to have a good trajectory at all. His relationship with sex as well as romance/true close friendships is really so shit, but considering it all, it checks out. I really, really wanted him to be happy and see him smiling and not degrading himself. Seems like fetishes/kinks related to a traumatic experience developing in a person is something the author herself displays considering everything she's written. I don't know what that says about how much a person, in this case Parou, truly enjoys or feels pleasure from what they're doing? He feels and looks truly unfulfilled and unhappy.

ILY Author!! Ur kinda evil but its still amazing


Honestly, I really really did like Osamu Tamura despite how cruel and twisted and mean he was, I loved how much of a personality he had and arguably he may have been the one character the author went way deeper about (and I liked the most imo). He was really quite harmful towards not just himself but others as well but he is undeniably both a victim most of all but a perpetrator as well. I feel just so sad he was never able to get peace or a good ending/direction but with all my heart I hope soon quickly after, in my delusions, that it begins to get better and starts healing. I don't have the same types of pains like CSA and sexual abuse but I've spent my life wasting away from many and i mean MANY issues where I feel most of the time as though I'm just floating as a theoretical cloud in the fabric of reality - and it brings me hope just to imagine him happier despite how fucked up he became and how much others "ruined" (read: abused and destroyed) him.

I guess it feels like he was the one she related to the most and projected so much / inserted so much of herself into his character and his everything? It makes a lot of sense that not everyone will have a happy ending, and much more if it was a reflection of how one in real life sees themselves as just as destroyed, gloomy, and unhealed as he is. It's truly not that easy, even though everyone in the story suffered and worked so that they may get better, sometimes, the circumstances just don't align. Everything was built against him, he had nothing, and when he finally had them, he kept pushing them away. And he can't heal because he is left to wallow and degrade, but he won't accept help and just hurts others while holding it in to bursting, and the cycle repeats again. Oh Osamu, just get better please...

Just talking as a writer who really really does that often, a lot of my characters and their traumatic/miserable experiences were like seeds I took from my ribs like Adam and Eve and left to grow. For some, it's literally just a recollection of my experiences molded in some ways so that it makes sense with the character without being entirely a self-insert and still making sense within the context/not feeling forced (not forcing the character within said experiences but I guess that parts of them/their lives are very much derived from and reflect a lot about me, the author's, self, experiences, and perspectives) so in way they're less like puppets but like other people in an alternate parallel world that have the same experiences rather than just a toy I carved. I guess they feel like real people to me rather than something I forced to create you know? Ahh... I really don't know how to explain it. Just that they're very much just people who have lived like me and felt the same pain, not a projection of my pain in a plain proclamation paper. It's really hard to explain, I can't put it into words. But it really helps oneself untangle everything and express the pain you typically won't be able to just let out. Doesn't make it disappear, but helps you cope with it even just a little bit and understand it more. And seeing them as actual people makes you more empathetic to both them and yourself.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Sep 16, 2026
Messages
12
i don't see how people say this is the best trans manga
Aoki says she wants to be a girl a few times, many chapters later she disappears for a bit and comes out of the hospital as a girl, no mention of anything that actually goes into transitioning. everyone immediately accepts it and there's only one singular instance of transphobia that happens behind her back which is weird considering how (overly) messed up the other 2 MCs' childhoods are. also Aoki stops being the focus after that so she doesn't get any character development afterwards except for the time skips at the end.
also, convoluted romance that doesn't go anywhere with any character.
it's decent, but just not satisfying or convincing


I think theres more than one instance of such but I do agree with your qualms, I guess I personally really liked it especially because I keep seeing misinformative "gender bender" mangas all the time who treat trans women like schrodinger's girls and femboys while acting performative, I'll never forget some of those, I'm not a woman myself but even I felt so weird reading those lol. I assumed she went on blockers or medical therapy at the doctor but I legit have no idea because there was no growth during the grad pics, only when she was already an adult in the parou epilogue. I'm still glad that even then the author always took her seriously without being overly positive about things they shouldn't have been.


I guess the bar really dropped because of the low saturation that's mostly fetish stuff. 😭😭😭 But I do highly agree, leaves a lot to be desired, felt like something was missing and felt a little unsatisfied. A certain storyline hurt me a lot because of how miserable it was, but it was mostly positive but not too toxically so. Have a great day!!
 
Joined
Sep 16, 2026
Messages
12
miserable after reading this and the extra πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚
 
Member
Joined
May 4, 2019
Messages
65
cried way too many times reading this...I also agree with the other commenter in that I thought marika would end up facing more transphobia in the school than she actually did? not that I want the character to go through that LOL but the bit with the guy who bullied her seeming to have a spiteful denial sort of crush on her went like nowhere
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top