Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2023
- Messages
- 689
this was axed, wasn’t it? And the author still wriggled her self insert in the end, shameless.
never mind im stupid
this was axed, wasn’t it? And the author still wriggled her self insert in the end, shameless.
I’m 90% sure this got axed, things usually get axed around 2 or 3 volumes in i’ve noticed.No epilogue? Damn, I was hoping for more but it ended alright. I did see the yuri in it. The nonstop chin rubbing means that Hane wanted to mark Uko as hers since the beginning and much more so at the end. Uko was really happy with it too. Also, when that happened at the end, it looked like extreme topage on Hane's side.
It needed an extra chapter.
Mangadex really needs the shoujo ai tag(just close girl friends) like other sites do to avoid these gay blue balling stories.Man this must be one of the least GL manga to ever GL, cause I honestly feel like nothing happened, literally no different than all those cute girls doing cute things mangas that never get anywhere, am I the only one feeling really disappointed?
Thanks for the confirmation @Nosebleed, wouldn't have been the first time a non GL gets tagged as such so I honestly couldn't help but wonder, I guess the manga really was axed since it did feel like it was going to get somewhere if it had more time.
Hopefully mangaka will be given more time for her next GL
I'm 100% sure a lot of Yuri / GL mangaka disagree with this, which is one reason Girl's Love as term became a thing."yuri is not just kissing, holding hands or being lesbian", I no longer have the screenshots but it's meant that yuri is a strong connection that doesn't need to manifest as romance.
I'll be real, this sound sexist as fuck and I honestly question how true that is for lesbians in japan.And well, I could end this with a fact, which is that unlike men (referring to any relationship where at least one member is not a woman) women don't express their sexuality as directly, strongly or spontaneous way a man does, in the sense that (always referring to stadistics from the collective) they're not that sex-driven and care more about how each other feel and how they want to build their relationship.
Yeah no, sorry again, sounds like pure copium and rationalizing, we can all see it was seemingly planning to get somewhere romantically, but the rabbits got killed by the axe.In short, yuri is not only romance and recognition, and they showed a lot of yuri while being consistent.
Shoujo-Ai is not a thing, long story short long ago some filthy gaijin decided that they had to separate explicit gay works from safe works, so they decided that Yaoi / Yuri is explicit while Shounen-Ai / Shoujo-Ai are safe stuff + those that are just subtext, there's no such thing in Japan, they don't make that distinction, either something is tagged as Yaoi / Yuri or it's not.Mangadex really needs the shoujo ai tag(just close girl friends) like other sites do to avoid these gay blue balling stories.
Well, I guess the next best thing would be a "Just friends" tag?Shoujo-Ai is not a thing, long story short long ago some filthy gaijin decided that they had to separate explicit gay works from safe works, so they decided that Yaoi / Yuri is explicit while Shounen-Ai / Shoujo-Ai are safe stuff + those that are just subtext, there's no such thing in Japan, they don't make that distinction, either something is tagged as Yaoi / Yuri or it's not.
In Japan Shoune-Ai and Shoujo-Ai are related to pedophilia.
Unfortunately there's no way to tag such series, Dynasty Scans solution was the Subtext tag, but even that is not exactly ideal, and in this case I do think mangaka was gonna go full-on romance, cause all her other GL and BL works seem to be explicitly romance, so it really is more of a case of axe killing the series before any progress happened.Well, I guess the next best thing would be a "Just friends" tag?
Though I guess that would be hard to do, since most of these just friends yuri/yaoi stories only pull the rug on you at the very end.
I replied to the wrong comment. Actual reply below.Shoujo-Ai is not a thing, long story short long ago some filthy gaijin decided that they had to separate explicit gay works from safe works, so they decided that Yaoi / Yuri is explicit while Shounen-Ai / Shoujo-Ai are safe stuff + those that are just subtext, there's no such thing in Japan, they don't make that distinction, either something is tagged as Yaoi / Yuri or it's not.
In Japan Shoune-Ai and Shoujo-Ai are related to pedophilia.
If I had to guess the use of Shounen-Ai in the west probably came from the fact that Yaoi also gets tagged as Boy's Love, which the same filthy gaijing probably rationalized that Boy = Shounen and Love = Ai, with Shoujo-Ai as the Yuri equivalent, also pretty sure Boy's Love is almost as old as Yaoi while Girl's Love was created recently so people know for sure the Yuri manga is indeed romance without any doubt, since some still use Yuri for close relationships between two woman that aren't romance.
I honestly don't remember the details well, so if I'm wrong and someone knows better do correct me.
Agreed. It's interesting how when discussing girls' love or yuri, people and authors suddenly feel compelled to wax philosophical about the nature of intimacy and the "true meaning of blooming flowers" to explain the non-romantic (or subtextual) aspects of a series.@Manko-sensei
I'm sorry if I'm misinterpreting anything of what you said and if I'll offend you, but I have be honest, that sounds like pure copium and rationalizing, "a trained eye can see yuri everywhere"? Seriously? Yeah he said that, and honestly? It's a bullshit argument, he was just handwaving why their relationship was never made clear even though it could.
Why is it that with Yuri we need to read between the lines? To read the clues? To "interpret" what is happening? If this was Yaoi nobody would have to do any of that, you wouldn't need to squint your eyes to see any romance because it would be the whole point, same if one of the characters was a boy, nobody would take their relationship as just close friendship.
But ok, fair, let me change the angle, wasn't Girl's Love explicitly created as a equivalent to Boy's Love? So that unlike Yuri people would read the label and know it is unquestionably romance between two women? Since after all some people still use Yuri to just mean close relationship between two woman without any romance involved? If this manga was only tagged as Yuri I could accept your argument, but it's not, it's very clerly tagged as Girl's Love too, so why do we still need to read between the lines and do detective work to see any actual romance between them?
Seriously, this is nothing but a fucking double standard, to put it short:
- Two opposite sex characters? Romance
- Yaoi? Romance
- Yuri? Roma- oh wait, nope, it's just friendship!
I'm 100% sure a lot of Yuri / GL mangaka disagree with this, which is one reason Girl's Love as term became a thing.
I'll be real, this sound sexist as fuck and I honestly question how true that is for lesbians in japan.
Yeah no, sorry again, sounds like pure copium and rationalizing, we can all see it was seemingly planning to get somewhere romantically, but the rabbits got killed by the axe.
Fucking 2024 and we still get:
Boy and girl? Romance.
Two boys? Romance.
Two girls? What good friends!
Fuck.
That.
Yeah no, I could accept if it was just Yuri, but it's explicitly tagged as Girl's Love, your entire argument completely falls apart due to that, you absolutely can't say Girl's Love is used outside of romance, mangaka clearly had a plan but wasn't allowed to continue long enough to get where she wanted, and if that was not the plan then it's the publisher fault to include Girl's Love since that tag will make people expect romance.
I'll be honest, I'm so annoyed by the fact you seemingly tried to excuse this disappointing ending as "yuri is not just romance" that I'm not even sure I'm expressing myself properly, at this point I'm just fucking rambling really, not even sure I'll reply if you say anything cause really, what I'll even say? Cause fact is Girl's Love made everyone expect romance in the series, and we got an absurdly disappointing ending, we all know that.
For real, I'm not even sure if I said all I wanted, much less say it in a coherent manner, cause fuck the logic that something tagged as fucking GL was not planning to go romance route, if it was only tagged as Yuri? I'll eat that, but fucking GL? No, fuck that, you'll convince nobody, nuh uh, you're being fucking disingenuous if you really try say GL can be used like that too.
keeps rambling to myself offscreen
Maybe all of those were actually yuri and you just don't know what yuri actually is?literally no different than all those cute girls doing cute things manga
Yuri as a genre was born from censorship of lesbian relationships in fiction, it was always meant to depict lesbian characters. The same standards from 20 or 10 years ago cannot, or rather, should not be used nowadays for what its created nowadays. Yuri is no longer just girls being close.Maybe all of those were actually yuri and you just don't know what yuri actually is?