Chiyu Mahou no Machigatta Tsukaikata: Senjou wo Kakeru Kaifuku Youin - Vol. 8 Ch. 40

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 27, 2020
Messages
465
Shit that bitch is still alive hoping for her death fr
She can't die, that's equivalent to suicide, an easy way out. Got to suffer at least the same amount of time as the solo healer did, even better if same treatment.

The irony of thinking death and torture is appropriate punishment for a 10 year old bully, and still believing you have the moral high ground.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 20, 2019
Messages
965
The irony of thinking death and torture is appropriate punishment for a 10 year old bully, and still believing you have the moral high ground.
I mean, the first guy want death, I want her to suffer the same treatment. If you think the same treatment is equal to torture, what does that say on the treatment the solo healer suffer at a much younger age(if she suffering now)?

Death is final, suffering can at least build/break character.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Sep 7, 2020
Messages
66
This dynamic between Nack and his bully (I refuse to refer to her as anything else until she expresses remorse for her actions) is the most poorly-written part of an otherwise good story.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 23, 2018
Messages
1,624
Ay good shit Nack! I'm fuckin proud of you mate. Bro really has grown.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 10, 2023
Messages
165
Shit that bitch is still alive hoping for her death fr
She can't die, that's equivalent to suicide, an easy way out. Got to suffer at least the same amount of time as the solo healer did, even better if same treatment.
I mean, the first guy want death, I want her to suffer the same treatment. If you think the same treatment is equal to torture, what does that say on the treatment the solo healer suffer at a much younger age(if she suffering now)?

Death is final, suffering can at least build/break character.
I understand that Mina bullied Nack relentlessly, but I think that when she was finally reunited with him at the magic school, she was disappointed in him because he was depressed (parents shunning him and keeping him locked away from little sister (apparently inseparable) and friend (Mina)) and not his usual self. I think in the beginning Mina just wanted him to fight back or to do anything that would force him to move forward.

From the brief things that are said by Mina throughout the manga Mina is a tsundere and truly cares for Nack. As children the manga portrays their relationship as if they were best friends and probably, they were each other's only friend. I do understand that Nack's parents forced Nacks little sister to take his place as Mina's friend, but we all know that you can't just substitute someone else as a best friend, and loneliness and depression will often follow that type of transition. I think Usato summed up what is going on here very well to Nack when he stated, "Mina is a clingy childhood friend that keeps following you around". From the manga we can surmise that MIna is wants to be with Nack but not as he is now. She wants the confident Nack that she knew as a child.

In the final attack by Nack we hear Mina state that she doesn't want to lose him again while she was crying. Then she steps back afterwards and contemplates his position as a healer and a Noble and decides that he shouldn't relinquish his nobility but should go and train with the Rose. Mina continually tells Nack that she will come find him in the rescue squad once she graduates and Nack seems quite happy about the prospect of seeing her then. I think this is a foreshadow that she wants a romantic relationship with him and if he relinquishes his nobility that would be impossible.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top