Objectively speaking, there's no right answer to this. Either translation works, and they both represent the same idea. It's only a matter of which way was chosen first, thus became the norm for this series.
However, when you start trying to pick apart on the semantics of Japanese translative work like this, you start to look very weabish.
Not to mention, you did insult the translator by calling them "dumbass" in the first place. Some aggression is well deserved for trashtalking somebody's work whom you're enjoying for free.