Dungeon ga Arawarete 5-nen, 15-sai de Dungeon ni Idomu Koto ni Shita. - Ch. 8

[Solipsist]

I don't think that was just a MC is a normal guy moment.

MC probably also has some doubts about if they were actually responsible/guilty. He may admire Nagumo, but he isn't blindly trusting him either. He is probably worried about Nagumo's morality. He already has questions, when he gave the lady a lot of money for notifying Nagumo if he showed up again. Nagumo, a really high level adventurer, went out of his way help a nobody, like the MC. I'd be super suspicious, about why. By making the MC "responsible" for their deaths, he might have been playing an psychotic Edgelord trick on him. Ha Ha, you caused these people to die, whoops!

The first question MC asks, is do they remember murdering someone. Not just do they feel guilty about the crime (and assuming their guilt). Do they remember committing it. Hozumi questions his authority, not the accusation. If I'm being questioned like that, I answer: I didn't kill anyone, wtf are you talking about.

If the MC was doubting the validity of those claims, he'd question whether or not he can trust that guy's words, or if "they're really the culprits". But he didn't. He just focused on whether or not "he can make that decision", i.e: can he "kill" someone or not.

The rest of the interaction was fine, no problem in trying to make double-sure by interrogating them, that they really "deserve to die".
The "lol moment" stems from such an anime-moment, where the MC immediately scratches their nape, and goes: "haha I'm not sure...", even if contextually it makes no sense.
Personally, I feel like a much more natural reaction would be to despair at the situation, to feel: "Why do I need to decide if someone dies or not?" -- and then resignation: "If I don't, they'll fuck me up. I don't want to do this shit, but what choice do I have?"

 

[DrunkinDonut]

If the MC was doubting the validity of those claims, he'd question whether or not he can trust that guy's words, or if "they're really the culprits". But he didn't. He just focused on whether or not "he can make that decision", i.e: can he "kill" someone or not.

The rest of the interaction was fine, no problem in trying to make double-sure by interrogating them, that they really "deserve to die".
The "lol moment" stems from such an anime-moment, where the MC immediately scratches their nape, and goes: "haha I'm not sure...", even if contextually it makes no sense.
Personally, I feel like a much more natural reaction would be to despair at the situation, to feel: "Why do I need to decide if someone dies or not?" -- and then resignation: "If I don't, they'll fuck me up. I don't want to do this shit, but what choice do I have?"

Maybe? But he discovered the body, so he's probably had those emotions already. And he made the decision to leave that dungeon because of that specific danger.

As the Team Leader, he's already gone past the decision point of are they a danger. Page 8, he makes the decision for the group that they're going to avoid Ikeburo. Nagumo counters by saying he can take care of the problem for them, not out of any sense of justice, just because he's annoyed. He's being asked to ensure the safety of his comrades. Page 17, shows he's anguished by the decision he's making, which goes towards your Normal guy statement.

 

[GreC_89]

Last page kinda confusing especially the bubble with "what?"

The near end part miss me, can someone explain please?
?.?...

Probably going to visit and 'talk' with this guy in Yokohama.
He speculated that his old protege, even with police giving up on punishing them, wasn't going to ended up like this by themselves. They are probably were taught something else in Yokohama.

 

[Seinvolf]

Probably going to visit and 'talk' with this guy in Yokohama.
He speculated that his old protege, even with police giving up on punishing them, wasn't going to ended up like this by themselves. They are probably were taught something else in Yokohama.

Seems like I really need to re-read all of it again...

 

[lolfacesayshi]

Good, that takes care of this group of a-holes. No "human life has value" bullshit, these people are clearly corrupt and needs to disappear.