Eroge Sekai ni Tensei Shita Ore ga, Oshi e no Ai de Netorare Heroine wo Shiawase ni Suru.

Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 10, 2018
Messages
644
I just realized how bad are the ratings of this manga. Bad enough to be considered according to the votes one of the worst manga in the entire site.
While i'm not really a great fan, is it really THIS bad? :thonk:

The synopsis blatantly lies about what the content of this story is. NTR content is completely and totally unacceptable to the vast majority of people, and this story lies to bait people into it by thinking the MC will be stopping the ntr like most other series in this type of story do. It's going to make people angry, this story deserves these absolutely awful ratings.
 
Active member
Joined
Aug 13, 2024
Messages
15
I just realized how bad are the ratings of this manga. Bad enough to be considered according to the votes one of the worst manga in the entire site.
While i'm not really a great fan, is it really THIS bad? :thonk:
Its not. I wouldn't say its a masterpiece, but at the very minimum its average.

The reason it has such bad ratings is because it deals with Netorare, and it blew up in exposure at the beginning, so people who hate the mere concept of netorare came and review bombed the manga.

I know this because I'm the one who has been comissioning the translation of this manga from the very beginning, and even when it was only 1-2 chapters it suddenly recieved hundreds of negative ratings.

I then discovered it had blew up in youtube, reddit or tiktok, where people read the synopsis, saw the first chapter and then gave it a negative rating because of their hatred of the genre netorare, not the manga itself.

Oh, btw
No, Ryou (The blondie) will NOT fuck every single girl. Yes, he assaults Karen Kiyohama (The Student Council President) and Marii Kakeki (a white-haired girl who has not yet appeared), and fucks the school nurse, but that's all. Obviously, he tries to corrupt other girls, but that's when the MC stops him.
Oh, and those two girls (Marii Kakeki and Karen Kiyohama) assaulted by him? Eventually they overcome what happened, and help the MC to defeat Ryou once and for all.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 16, 2020
Messages
1,124
Its not. I wouldn't say its a masterpiece, but at the very minimum its average.

The reason it has such bad ratings is because it deals with Netorare, and it blew up in exposure at the beginning, so people who hate the mere concept of netorare came and review bombed the manga.

I know this because I'm the one who has been comissioning the translation of this manga from the very beginning, and even when it was only 1-2 chapters it suddenly recieved hundreds of negative ratings.

I then discovered it had blew up in youtube, reddit or tiktok, where people read the synopsis, saw the first chapter and then gave it a negative rating because of their hatred of the genre netorare, not the manga itself.

Oh, btw
No, Ryou (The blondie) will NOT fuck every single girl. Yes, he assaults Karen Kiyohama (The Student Council President) and that white-haired girl who has not yet appeared, but that's all. Obviously, he tries to corrupt other girls, but that's when the MC stops him.
Oh, and those two girls assaulted by him? Eventually they overcome what happened, and help the MC to defeat Ryou once and for all.
Yeah look like someone looked at the raws, got it all wrong cause he didn't know japanese, and started a campaign against this manga saying that the MC is gonna be overcucked simply cause the NTR guy actually get laid with someone despite these girls not even being the heroines. Well, putting aside school prez that is heavily implied in the latest chapter that she is gonna be violated. But people say there is gonna be more to it than just "ah ah, you got cucked! Cry me a river and watch me fuck this girl you like!"
 
Active member
Joined
May 9, 2025
Messages
93
The mc does save the people that were raped and drugged into submission by ntr guy Ryo, he also saves Karen by halping her get with the woman she love by the end the nurse is the only one of the three women that Ryo got to that stayed loyal to him to the point of wanting revenge the other 2 joined the mc side to take down Ryo When Ryo loses he runs to a different country. Their are also times When the mc is talking about what happened in the game and it shows scene's from the game that are before the rapes and after the rapes and some that shows the end of a rape. In the main story Ryo only got 3 women and the only heroine he did get witch was Karen is a lesbian
 
Last edited:
Group Leader
Joined
Aug 15, 2018
Messages
1,053
If the artist wants to do an NTR manga at least make the art good enough and not this slop that was put together from trash in the great pacific garbage patch.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 15, 2023
Messages
596
If the artist wants to do an NTR manga at least make the art good enough and not this slop that was put together from trash in the great pacific garbage patch.
That reminds me of how good the artstyle and quality are in NTR doujins but it's different for NTR-themed mangas. It's almost funny how that works.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Aug 15, 2018
Messages
1,053
That reminds me of how good the artstyle and quality are in NTR doujins but it's different for NTR-themed mangas. It's almost funny how that works.
Yea. I think it boils down to the deadlines. NTR-themed mangas have to follow a more regular scheduled releases than NTR doujin so art had to be rushed to keep up with the schedule. Just look at Futamine Kobito’s NTR doujins. They only release like once or at most twice per year but the art is chef’s kiss.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Messages
1,817
Bro somebody give me the web novel or somewhere i can read this, somebody told me the general premise and its like completely different to what one guu at the start said a couple months ago. Lowk jus interested in how the series progresses from here on out
 
Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2025
Messages
18
The girls r hot AF, that's like the main thing that keeps me reading 🤣. Hopefully the main girl gets the end ending
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Sep 28, 2020
Messages
85
Why doesnt mc just kill the dude it would probably be more interesting if he spent the rest of the manga trying to not get caught or something bro
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 3, 2024
Messages
1,682
Its not. I wouldn't say its a masterpiece, but at the very minimum its average.

The reason it has such bad ratings is because it deals with Netorare, and it blew up in exposure at the beginning, so people who hate the mere concept of netorare came and review bombed the manga.

I know this because I'm the one who has been comissioning the translation of this manga from the very beginning, and even when it was only 1-2 chapters it suddenly recieved hundreds of negative ratings.

I then discovered it had blew up in youtube, reddit or tiktok, where people read the synopsis, saw the first chapter and then gave it a negative rating because of their hatred of the genre netorare, not the manga itself.

Oh, btw
No, Ryou (The blondie) will NOT fuck every single girl. Yes, he assaults Karen Kiyohama (The Student Council President) and Marii Kakeki (a white-haired girl who has not yet appeared), and fucks the school nurse, but that's all. Obviously, he tries to corrupt other girls, but that's when the MC stops him.
Oh, and those two girls (Marii Kakeki and Karen Kiyohama) assaulted by him? Eventually they overcome what happened, and help the MC to defeat Ryou once and for all.
If the story turns things around I'll at least remove my negative rating, but it looks like it would take a lot more chapters to tell and I can understand if nobody wanted to actually translate it.
 
Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2023
Messages
27
There's another manga out there with a similar premise. A guy dies and becomes NTR-man. But he's a normal good guy, so he just becomes friends with the women in the story and those girls fall for him instead.
Yeah I think I know this one, the mc is reicarnated as the ntr guy but since the takeover he treated the girls well and they fell for him while supposed mcs are nothing but creeps. At least there the story make sense
 
Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2023
Messages
27
ok so the premise is a lie.
To be honest, I don't care about the premise, I would prefer the story about what happens to the girls after getting dominated by the douche, while the mc is living his best life without the drama
Now this is interesting plot. A mc that decided to draw the line and be out of the drama from the get go. Him being like 'sure go on girls, become someone whores, got nothing to do with me' then live his life
 
Active member
Joined
May 9, 2025
Messages
93
The mc does save the people that were raped and drugged into submission by ntr guy Ryo, he also saves Karen by halping her get with the woman she love by the end the nurse is the only one of the three women that Ryo got to that stayed loyal to him to the point of wanting revenge the other 2 joined the mc side to take down Ryo When Ryo loses he runs to a different country. Their are also times When the mc is talking about what happened in the game and it shows scene's from the game that are before the rapes and after the rapes and some that shows the end of a rape. In the main story Ryo only got 3 women and the only heroine he did get witch was Karen is a lesbian
.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 7, 2023
Messages
460
The reason it has such bad ratings is because it deals with Netorare... so people who hate the mere concept of netorare came and review bombed the manga... where people read the synopsis, saw the first chapter and then gave it a negative rating because of their hatred of the genre netorare, not the manga itself.
Gonna disagree with you on that for the following reasons:

Yes, people who dislike NTR/NTR-adjacent content were obviously going to complain once it showed up, especially in a manga marketed as romance. That part isn’t surprising. However there were other factors that made things worse and clashed badly with an already controversial genre, creating a mess very early on and killing a lot of the manga’s potential.

1. Early focus and pacing issues
For roughly the first 20 chapters, the manga focused almost entirely on the antagonist and how NTR-heavy he is. Sex scenes involving him, while the MC constantly fantasizes about being cucked. Since this is a monthly release, that negativity really piles up. Normally you’d balance this with some progress: MC growth, ecchi scenes for him, or at least signs that he’s planning to fight back. Instead, we get chapter after chapter of passive daydreaming, followed by not one but two live cuck scenes. It dosent help the situation that the antagonist also gets a hot nurse added to his side.

2. Harem tag vs. story direction
From the start, the manga was tagged as a harem, yet the MC’s mindset was/is completely focused on a single heroine (the FMC). This creates confusion about where the story is supposed to go and what even counts as “being cucked.” If it were purely about saving the FMC, some readers might tolerate questionable scenes for the sake of plot. But with a harem tag, having 2–3 heroines already taken and used by the antagonist directly undermines the stated premise: “In order to protect Kotoha and the others from Ryou, he must achieve a perfect happy ending.” That doesn’t mean nothing bad can happen, but at that point it just feels like forcing NTR elements rather than serving the story.

Furthermore, the MC’s cross-dressing pushes even more readers away. I’m not sure whether that comes from the novel or was added because the artist (who is female) is into that kink -> going by her Twitter feed.

I also saw your spoilers, plus another one and apparently only after two real life years does the MC finally start stopping the antagonist when he approaches the other girls. Normally, I’d agree with the argument that this works better in a completed story, where readers can binge it and the prolonged negativity is quickly followed by payoff and revenge. But in this industry, where releases are weekly at best and often monthly, you end up reacting to and hating what the manga shows now, not what it might eventually do in the future.

With this said, you’re downplaying the manga’s issues by saying people disliked it "just" because "the mere concept of netorare" or "of their hatred of the genre netorare" -> but in fact "the manga itself." (And how it was hanlded)
 
Active member
Joined
May 9, 2025
Messages
93
The mc does save the people that were raped and drugged into submission by ntr guy Ryo, he also saves Karen by halping her get with the woman she love by the end the nurse is the only one of the three women that Ryo got to that stayed loyal to him to the point of wanting revenge the other 2 joined the mc side to take down Ryo When Ryo loses he runs to a different country. Their are also times When the mc is talking about what happened in the game and it shows scene's from the game that are before the rapes and after the rapes and some that shows the end of a rape. In the main story Ryo only got 3 women and the only heroine he did get witch was Karen is a lesbian
 
Active member
Joined
May 9, 2025
Messages
93
Gonna disagree with you on that for the following reasons:

Yes, people who dislike NTR/NTR-adjacent content were obviously going to complain once it showed up, especially in a manga marketed as romance. That part isn’t surprising. However there were other factors that made things worse and clashed badly with an already controversial genre, creating a mess very early on and killing a lot of the manga’s potential.

1. Early focus and pacing issues
For roughly the first 20 chapters, the manga focused almost entirely on the antagonist and how NTR-heavy he is. Sex scenes involving him, while the MC constantly fantasizes about being cucked. Since this is a monthly release, that negativity really piles up. Normally you’d balance this with some progress: MC growth, ecchi scenes for him, or at least signs that he’s planning to fight back. Instead, we get chapter after chapter of passive daydreaming, followed by not one but two live cuck scenes. It dosent help the situation that the antagonist also gets a hot nurse added to his side.

2. Harem tag vs. story direction
From the start, the manga was tagged as a harem, yet the MC’s mindset was/is completely focused on a single heroine (the FMC). This creates confusion about where the story is supposed to go and what even counts as “being cucked.” If it were purely about saving the FMC, some readers might tolerate questionable scenes for the sake of plot. But with a harem tag, having 2–3 heroines already taken and used by the antagonist directly undermines the stated premise: “In order to protect Kotoha and the others from Ryou, he must achieve a perfect happy ending.” That doesn’t mean nothing bad can happen, but at that point it just feels like forcing NTR elements rather than serving the story.

Furthermore, the MC’s cross-dressing pushes even more readers away. I’m not sure whether that comes from the novel or was added because the artist (who is female) is into that kink -> going by her Twitter feed.

I also saw your spoilers, plus another one and apparently only after two real life years does the MC finally start stopping the antagonist when he approaches the other girls. Normally, I’d agree with the argument that this works better in a completed story, where readers can binge it and the prolonged negativity is quickly followed by payoff and revenge. But in this industry, where releases are weekly at best and often monthly, you end up reacting to and hating what the manga shows now, not what it might eventually do in the future.

With this said, you’re downplaying the manga’s issues by saying people disliked it "just" because "the mere concept of netorare" or "of their hatred of the genre netorare" -> but in fact "the manga itself." (And how it was hanlded)
The mc does save the people that were raped and drugged into submission by ntr guy Ryo in the original game world, the mc does not Fantasizes about being cucked. Their are times When the mc is talking about what happened in the game and it shows scene's from the game that are before the rapes and after the rapes and some that shows the end of a rape the scenes are Their to show what the mc is trying to stop. In the main story Ryo only got 3 women and the only heroine he did get was Karen and she is a lesbian. The mc saves Karen by getting her together with the woman she love's out of the three women that Ryo gets in the story two are lesbian's that are in love with each other and one is the married nurse, and after Ryo's defeat the married nurse is the only one of the three women that stayed loyal to him and she want's revenge and she is the new main villain after Ryo is defeated, after Ryo is defeated he got kicked in the balls and he also flees the country
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 7, 2023
Messages
460
...1the mc does not Fantasizes about being cucked. Their are times when the mc is talking about what happened in the game and it shows scene's from the game that are before the rapes and after the rapes and some that shows the end of a rape the scenes are Their to show what the mc is trying to stop.
Right, I should clarify something first: him fantasizing wasn’t meant to imply that he enjoys it. That part is on me for wording it poorly.

What I meant is that these “dreams,” flashbacks or knowledge-from-the-game scenes, whatever you want to call them, keep showing up chapter after chapter. As I already mentioned in my previous post, I understand that this might be needed for plot reasons, like giving the MC something to stop or change. That part is fine.

But do we really need so many of them? Do we need nearly every chapter showing either the Antagonist character with the FMCs or harem-style scenes involving him? At that point, it stops feeling like plot necessity and starts feeling purely fetish-driven. Which is NTR. And we both know that dont mix well and that this manga aint popular kinda says its on its own.

In the main story Ryo only got 3 women and the only heroine he did get was Karen and she is a lesbian. The mc saves Karen by getting her together with the woman she love's out of the three women that Ryo gets in the story two are lesbian's that are in love with each other and one is the married nurse, and after Ryo's defeat the married nurse is the only one of the three women that stayed loyal to him and she want's revenge and she is the new main villain after Ryo is defeated, after Ryo is defeated he got kicked in the balls and he also flees the country
Yeah, sounds very lame I wont lie. Mostly you would execpt after all the negatives the douche did and was portrayed as, it would at least have a statisyfing revenge. But he dosent even have anyone the MC can steal away from. And him fleeing the country just as that? So easy? Dont tell me this is how they wrote him off to stabilie the story as the married nurse cant do much against the remaining FMC.

But then again, as I menitioned before, it was tagged as Harem. With having two lesbians, its focused on ecchi, having the douche fucking 2 love interest + hot teacher, having gender bender-ish forced "plot", writing the antagonist - which the story is the mian purpose - gets writen off that easly, almost like authro dosent want to punish him at all and since the story would end here, we have a prolonged one but its not the nurse but whats the point? Whats the appeal here? With all this said, its kinda obvious that people who like Harem would get insulted and disgusted by the very first chapters and if they would read what to expect, its not wonder the comments and reviews are as they are. If it was just "drama" or smut, I think it would stayed on itself for a bit more longer, but obvieticly speaking it has to many flaws, from either a weak MC, to no reall, or lets say, to late action taking from said mc, to not much intruge/mystery or sheming against the antagonist while also getting steamy with the various FMCs etc.

Edit: I read yesterday about the recent RAW chapters that either the FMC or another girl reacts with a strange, shocked, almost dark expression after hearing that the douche leaves the country. The poster suggested this might be hinting that she already slept with him or even that she’s pregnant.

I can’t confirm this myself since it’s hearsay, but their previous post did turn out to be correct. If that’s the case, why else would she react like that?
 
Last edited:
Active member
Joined
May 9, 2025
Messages
93
Right, I should clarify something first: him fantasizing wasn’t meant to imply that he enjoys it. That part is on me for wording it poorly.

What I meant is that these “dreams,” flashbacks or knowledge-from-the-game scenes, whatever you want to call them, keep showing up chapter after chapter. As I already mentioned in my previous post, I understand that this might be needed for plot reasons, like giving the MC something to stop or change. That part is fine.

But do we really need so many of them? Do we need nearly every chapter showing either the Antagonist character with the FMCs or harem-style scenes involving him? At that point, it stops feeling like plot necessity and starts feeling purely fetish-driven. Which is NTR. And we both know that dont mix well and that this manga aint popular kinda says its on its own.


Yeah, sounds very lame I wont lie. Mostly you would execpt after all the negatives the douche did and was portrayed as, it would at least have a statisyfing revenge. But he dosent even have anyone the MC can steal away from. And him fleeing the country just as that? So easy? Dont tell me this is how they wrote him off to stabilie the story as the married nurse cant do much against the remaining FMC.

But then again, as I menitioned before, it was tagged as Harem. With having two lesbians, its focused on ecchi, having the douche fucking 2 love interest + hot teacher, having gender bender-ish forced "plot", writing the antagonist - which the story is the mian purpose - gets writen off that easly, almost like authro dosent want to punish him at all and since the story would end here, we have a prolonged one but its not the nurse but whats the point? Whats the appeal here? With all this said, its kinda obvious that people who like Harem would get insulted and disgusted by the very first chapters and if they would read what to expect, its not wonder the comments and reviews are as they are. If it was just "drama" or smut, I think it would stayed on itself for a bit more longer, but obvieticly speaking it has to many flaws, from either a weak MC, to no reall, or lets say, to late action taking from said mc, to not much intruge/mystery or sheming against the antagonist while also getting steamy with the various FMCs etc.

Edit: I read yesterday about the recent RAW chapters that either the FMC or another girl reacts with a strange, shocked, almost dark expression after hearing that the douche leaves the country. The poster suggested this might be hinting that she already slept with him or even that she’s pregnant.

I can’t confirm this myself since it’s hearsay, but their previous post did turn out to be correct. If that’s the case, why else would she react like that?
The douche did not fuck any of the love interest the women he fucks in the story are not in love with the mc and as of the most recent chapter that I know of the mc is only in a relationship with one person that being the fmc. The fmc is never shown to have sex with Ryo in the main story, And she is the one that kicked Ryo in the balls and after that was when Ryo flees the country, as for the dark expression she had that when she found out how much of a douche her boyfriend, best friend was and that he was trying to fuck her boyfriend of couse at the time Ryo thought the mc was a female and when Roy found out the truth he did not care, and the other characters that did know keeped her out of the looped until the point in the story were the mc oust him in fount of everyone. The only other time the fmc get a dark expression is when she is having sex with the mc and she is imaging him getting close to other women. I don't know how true this is but I have seen a comment that said that the mc forgot that their was a fanmade game that turned a character into a yandere. as for Ryo getting away Ryo himself said in a pass chapter that he had a goddess on his side if true then said goddess helped him escape. The only character that I know of that got mad about Ryo leaving the country was the married nurse thats why she want's revenge and thats why the married nurse is the new main villain.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top