Henkyou no Yakushi, Miyako de S Rank Boukensha to naru ~Eiyuu-mura no Shounen ga Cheat Yaku de Mujikaku Musou~

Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2024
Messages
50
I hate to break it to you, but fetish-friendly content isn't automatically porn.
True, but if you want to nitpick like that, then let me tell you that only fetish-friendly content also doesn't properly depict a fetish in the first place, meaning there's a difference between fetish and fetish-friendly 😁 (You see, phrasing things properly in comments is hard. This isn't a scientific thesis, so cut me some slack 😅)
Anyhow, an actual fetish has per definition sexual connotations. It simply wouldn't be a fetish otherwise. You're right that it doesn't have to be porn directly, but it's at the very least suggestive, meaning it still implies that direction and stuff, which I intended to address with the additional "in any way" part. I guess that didn't work, but that was the plan, I swear 😅
One way or another, that's more or less nitpicking, though. I'm not sure why that's the part you got hung up on.
Anyway, you could say the NTR element in this story was used in a fetish-friendly way, so to speak. Since I was the one who said that this is NOT (again in capital letters) about porn, you should see that I do know that fetish-friendly content isn't automatically porn very well. That's literally what all of this was about in the first place.
I wrote a reply to ScuffedGeo who pretty much said there are no NTR elements at all in this story because that element didn't completely jump into his face, which I argued against.
If you read his specific comment that I replied to, what he wrote about coom-brained weirdos obsessed with cucking (which is clearly referring to a very sexual/pornopgraphic NTR fetish in a bad way), you might get an idea why I could have phrased it like that.
I naturally had to pick up what he said to have any chance of convincing him.
You can't convince anybody by ignoring their points in an argument.
 
Active member
Joined
Apr 15, 2023
Messages
93
What is it with the parents etc. in these kinds of stories, that they utterly fail to teach the protagonist a realistic view on their own power scale? This is literally raising a overpowered idiot, which is one of the most irresponsible things you can do, since such a person is a danger to themself and others and the only reason this kind of stuff doesn´t end in a catastrophy is because there are no realistic consequences or the author uses deus ex machina moments to solve things. ... Seriously is this some kind of Anime trope or just lazy writing?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
139
I'm done with healers, blacksmiths and tamers at this point. The girl in the cover is cute tho
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 30, 2020
Messages
529
Considering the ntr argument, i haven't read it but personally, I'd say it's only ntr if both had feelings for each other. Other than that, it would be nothing more than just a one sided crush
 
Supporter
Joined
Feb 3, 2018
Messages
707
Idk myself but all of them feel the same and I tend to lose interest midway.

Probably because the messaging is the same. I'll admit that I don't remember coming across any manga with a blacksmith MC, but I'd be willing to wager that the one you're referring to features an MC that isn't very physically strong (despite being a blacksmith); probably stretches his hand out and poofs a piece into existence.

Tamers and healers (especially) are not roles that absolutely require strength--either magic or some kind of technique or spell. The MC will have that role, while you usually find some woman being the warrior, knight, or other direct combat role suitable for the strength of a man standing in front of him--like you'd see on such a manga's cover, because the authors know such a sissy can't sell.

Such a sissy is still needed to tell you that strength is bad for men, and they've been saying it for years, now. The authors just dress it up a little differently each time.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
139
Probably because the messaging is the same. I'll admit that I don't remember coming across any manga with a blacksmith MC, but I'd be willing to wager that the one you're referring to features an MC that isn't very physically strong (despite being a blacksmith); probably stretches his hand out and poofs a piece into existence.

Tamers and healers (especially) are not roles that absolutely require strength--either magic or some kind of technique or spell. The MC will have that role, while you usually find some woman being the warrior, knight, or other direct combat role suitable for the strength of a man standing in front of him--like you'd see on such a manga's cover, because the authors know such a sissy can't sell.

Such a sissy is still needed to tell you that strength is bad for men, and they've been saying it for years, now. The authors just dress it up a little differently each time.
Thank you for your time sir. Your thots are appreciated. (No satire)
 
Supporter
Joined
Mar 19, 2020
Messages
92
This feels really janky to read, because everyone the MC meets is immediately either exaggeratedly dissing him or exaggeratedly hyping him. Sometimes it's even the same person doing both! Be normal, people!
The MC is also wayyy overpowered. It would be OK to just have him be a medical nerd with one really underlooked skill combo or something, he doesn't need to also be casually curbstomping dragons everywhere he goes.
Overall I give it 6/10
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 25, 2023
Messages
9,820
This feels really janky to read, because everyone the MC meets is immediately either exaggeratedly dissing him or exaggeratedly hyping him. Sometimes it's even the same person doing both! Be normal, people!
The MC is also wayyy overpowered. It would be OK to just have him be a medical nerd with one really underlooked skill combo or something, he doesn't need to also be casually curbstomping dragons everywhere he goes.
Overall I give it 6/10
I gave this 5.5 / 10, because of the good art and cats. ( 5 for cats, .5 for good art ).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top