Honzuki no Gekokujou ~Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen~ Dai 1-bu 「Hon ga Nai nara Tsukureba Ii!」 - Vol. 1 Ch. 2 - Books are Unobt…

[MangaDex]

 

[Liquidxlax]

Funny that she forgets she is a kid. One of the most common questions 1 to 4 year olds I find is "what's that?". They wouldn't think its weird in the least. Being older and not knowing common stuff is weird

 

[maisonaustyn]

Never thought the idea of a meat market would be disgusting to someone to the poibt of passing out. Even in a modern setting. She must have been beyond privileged in her previous life.

 

[Kampfarsch]

Yo is that a god damn 7 story building
thats seems kind of out of place for that sort of world lmfaooo

@maisonaustyn a god damn meat market doesnt usually have the dead animals lying around or straight up slaughtered right there
a lot of people cant see blood without freaking out

 

[Glomoro]

Funny that she forgets she is a kid. One of the most common questions 1 to 4 year olds I find is "what's that?". They wouldn't think its weird in the least. Being older and not knowing common stuff is weird

The problem here is probably that she doesn't know offhand which things she should already have known, I guess. Even if she got the body's original memories chucked in along with all of hers that sort of sounds like a jumbled mess unless she's defaulting to one set or the other, and she'd probably default to her own most of the time. Looked like she got flashes of the other memories when they were really important things like who her new family were, but perhaps other details she should know aren't getting drawn out as readily. I still don't think it's as much of a problem as she thinks it could be though, at worst what, they'll blame her memory issues on the fever she had and just occasionally deal with her asking a question about something.

 

[alexsdu]

@Glomoro @Liquidxlax
Now a question that might sound disturbing.
What happen to the real Main?
Did she died and her spirit possesed Main's body?

 

[Glomoro]

@alexsdu The original is 90% likely to just be dead as a doornail. Back into the cycle of reincarnation herself, perhaps. I can only recall one isekai reincarnation offhand that kept the original soul or what not around for more than five seconds if the body used to be someone else's.

 

[Liquidxlax]

@alexsdu I prefer to think that the "real" Main and Jap Main are one in the same. The thing is that J-Main was much older and had a very domineering personality with plenty of memories and defining moments while R-Main was sick most of the time couldn't do much, had to sleep a lot and therefore did not develop much of an "ego", personality or w.e, so it would seem like R-main basically disappeared and was replaced by J-Main, but J-Main did have R-Mains memories though a bit fractured due to the shock of gaining her old memories. I know this is all make believe or fantasy, but to me it doesn't make much sense how some bitch dying in japan has her soul transferred across the solar systems, galaxies and or even dimensions to some little sick girl who didn't die, but her soul left the body or her soul entered and squeezed R-Main's soul out. I just figure that most of these mangas are based on the belief in Reincarnation and replacing a soul in a body is not reincarnation.

high thoughts with colonel dipshit at midnight

 

[Lil-mochi]

@alexsdu the real owner of the body probably died of sickness.

 

[Mpwilson123]

Looks like no one questioned the fact that 150 read as 30 was their some current exchange references I missed like baht to pound or something.

 

[Lambie3]

What a worthless entitled brat, don't even help your family with the smallest chore just scream that you want something and throw a fit when it can't happen. 🤬

 

[dragondeathlord]

You sister Doll is a stick... but you want a Book that casts more than a house? Entitled brat covers it. I hope she never gets one. Not a good start already the MC..

 

[immortalartisan]

I’d give this 8 out of 10 for how realistic it is though this is due to the fact that normally the Mc is a noble
Also she is going into heavy withdrawal from the lack of books and general modern things

 

[Lunelune14]

Man, I know that she loves books. I love books too, but ransacking someone house (that you actually don't know) for books, then throwing tantrum, really makes me dislike her. She doesn't know any respect despite doing (supposedly) lots of reading. Shallow thinking. Only cares of herself. The scene when she screams because going to market and the smells... Yeah, she is a spoiled brat. I don't like her.

 

[Angelicsailor]

This actually got made into an anime!?!?!?
Shes a brat demanding that man let her touch a pricey book and then goes totally crazy for it is actually insane


How this appeals to anyone over the age of 15 I don't know and frankly I wouldnt want my kid reading / watching this as it shows bratty selfish behavior I head all these good things about the anime and manga and right now I'm looking at it and asking myself' "Bitch where-?" Where is there any good qualities.

 

[Ismalordy]

Because is something called character development? I mean not everyone needs to be a good cutout quality protagonist from the start.

 

[BakedBanana]

"A miracle at 10, a genius at 15... and then once' your over 20. you're just a normal person to others." (Page 21)

Ah I really like this quote, I especially love the isekai story that was inspired by this quote. Would definitely recommend.

But these comments make me laugh, never knew so many people disliked Myne at the start.