Horobi no Kuni no Seifukusha - Ch. 24 - Battle

Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2018
Messages
4
Yeah, resorting to violence at all during this meeting was just a disappointment.

I expected stuff more like burning their workshop, kidnapping, raping, and then discarding the girl he takes care of, and crippling the craftsman.
Going after the high-profile kid with violence at all is so damn b-rate, that I still expect this to be revealed as some kind of "test" of his mettle, next chapter. And I hate the plot even more than this chapter, if it does that...
To be fair, she thinks she is dealing with a simple rich kid. Most folks aren't going to be on their A game against something they deem so harmless. This is just the start, and the witches will eventually show just how evil they are, though their real fight against him won't start for a while.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 14, 2023
Messages
107
Yeah, resorting to violence at all during this meeting was just a disappointment.

I expected stuff more like burning their workshop, kidnapping, raping, and then discarding the girl he takes care of, and crippling the craftsman.
Going after the high-profile kid with violence at all is so damn b-rate, that I still expect this to be revealed as some kind of "test" of his mettle, next chapter. And I hate the plot even more than this chapter, if it does that...
Yeah I think the entire point is that the Witch thinks she's just dealing with another snotty rich kid who'd be easily intimidated when threatened since those kinds of kids wouldn't be real-world savvy enough to handle that kind of shit.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 26, 2018
Messages
4,677
Just shoot her and be done with it.

I still don't get why they are called "witches" if they don't have magic, if they are just normal women with some administrative power just kill them and be done with the situation all together.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 17, 2020
Messages
591
Didn't think it was possible for a character to be this badass while someone else was kicking ass lol
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 29, 2018
Messages
406
I still don't get why they are called "witches" if they don't have magic, if they are just normal women with some administrative power just kill them and be done with the situation all together.
"Witch" is just the weird term for "bureaucrat," existed since the time they were still an united Shantila Empire. According to some dumb-ass explanation, the knights had lost some influence after the collapse of the Empire, while witches rose in power and seized the control of central government.
Now, in a direct confrontation the Ho family would win easily. But acting like they owned the place is definitely a no-go, not in the royal capital at least. The majority of Shanti people are still revering the queen, so challenging her authority would be akin to starting a rebellion -- at that point they wouldn't just fight against the witches but other chieftain families too.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 2, 2019
Messages
5,002
Yeah I think the entire point is that the Witch thinks she's just dealing with another snotty rich kid who'd be easily intimidated when threatened since those kinds of kids wouldn't be real-world savvy enough to handle that kind of shit.
My point also implicitly included how resorting to violence during the meeting is a bad idea because he is high-profile. As in, his main family would likely feel forced to retaliate, and beyond even that, the royal family might get unnecessarily involved.
Easier to just target those around him to make him fold, and if he doesn't, send violence to him when he isn't on a very public and known visit to your base of power.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 17, 2023
Messages
2,350
Like a boxer's first jab, it begins!

For those wondering why the knight families put up with the witches:
It's division of labor. Students at the academy are typically sorted by gender into the knight or witch course. Knights learn combat, strategy, eagle riding, etc. Witches learn math, literacy, and bureaucracy. A long-term consequence of this system is a bunch of Knight families who don't want to take over the administrative tasks that the witches handle, and witch families who don't want to relocate to the outskirts to fight wars. In fact, they're both unqualified to do the other's jobs. While the knights could invade the capital and depose the witches, the reward would be a bunch of corporate work they don't want anyway.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 26, 2018
Messages
1,356
This does seem strange to me as well. The witch should know the Hou family fights in actual wars, so even if she was just measuring Yuuri's resolve, this indeed seems too cheap. You can't measure a warrior's resolve like this. It should be done through nefarious means, where the warrior can't rely on his best talents and skills. Like poisoning in secret, since poison was mentioned here. Isn't poison something that ought to belong to a witch family anyway? Poison someone close to the warrior and see how he will react. Of course the warrior might just attack in a straightforward manner in retaliation, knowing the identity of the enemy, so it's not necessarily a better option. Dependency on antidote might still work. Anyway, the witch (mafia) should work using their own best methods, not try to attack using the opponent's best methods.

Maybe the witch mafia has had so easy for so many years that they don't genuinely know what to do if the opponent knows how to fight back at all.
so i think she tried strong arming him cause quite frankly they think they have full monopoly on business knowledge and shit. they crush all competition in their infancy and normally they could crush him just as easily BUT he got a royal favor that protects him from their normal tactics. He has had them off their game from the getgo as you would suspect of a chieftains son.

The only other option left after this fails is to go after production or their workers, both things we know they have done in the past with ruthless lethal efficiency.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 24, 2024
Messages
339
Part of me wishes that his aide had come dressed in his military dress uniform to really REALLY drive that point home. But that’d probably have tipped his hand.
‘Still one hell of a chapter though.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 4, 2018
Messages
801
I still don't get why they are called "witches" if they don't have magic, if they are just normal women with some administrative power just kill them and be done with the situation all together.
I believe the term are there because once upon a time (like a Millennia or more ago) they are "real" witch. they do divination, potion making, physician, record keeping etc. well you can see them as "smart" women that the royalty keep as advisor.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Feb 25, 2024
Messages
14
Clever move.

No need to worry about disrespecting your elders when the elder is the one giving those SLAPS.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 11, 2019
Messages
419
On one hand it's great he is standing his ground, on the other he is simply directly opposing them. He need to stomp them out completely unless they will bite back.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top