Hyoujou ga Issai Wakaranai Shirogane-san - Vol. 1 Ch. 1

[liquidsword]

@blablablub I agree.

 

[CursedLight]

Please don't do us a shark girl again :/

 

[pokperson1000]

I feel like pre serialization's lack of senpai was more fluffy and fun. now we just have an annoying senpai to deal with.

 

[salsudo]

When the editor ruins a manga😒

 

[Xystus]

Literally no reason to hide at all. Plain dumb reason just to show some fanservice. Ruined.

 

[entity_101]

Well, All I can say is that I hope that the editor gets changed before any other chapter is released and that the author is allowed to make a revised version of chapter 1 just like how Murata is doing in one punch man

 

[Leo_]

Disappointing. The pre serialization is much better.

 

[yayforpenguin]

kinda disappointing that the serialization is not as good as the pre-serial
some small changes and dumb cliches added that werent needed

its like doing a multiple-choice test, you put down (A) but start doubting yourself and change it to (D) but end up getting it wrong and your first answer was right all along.

 

[manot40]

Summary of this serialization:

 

[migh]

@kardyro dropped ?

 

[kardyro]

@migh nah, there'd be a note if so

 

[-Aincrad-]

This was nothing like the pre-serialization, it's just terrible.

 

[Pirate-Pierate]

The MC is so boring and basic, like they could have done ANYTHING to make him more interesting.

 

[jokerxhisoka]

"otaku idol finds out his mysterious classmate is the idol he likes", could the premise be any more disappointing? And here I thought this was going to be something like Takagi-san with a different take. At least the art is good and I can only wish this will have good development. Stories about "otaku Idol meets idol" are just really boring.

edit: sigh, the locker room scene is really over done, even more when you just have no reason to but you get in it anyway.

 

[TNT261]

Why did he hide them in the first place? Could they not just say what they were doing? Did the captain not tell everyone she got their committee to clean for them and to stay out of their way? Are they not well known as members of the committee that upholds “public morals” and does odd jobs? This cliché couldn’t have been more forced.

@Pirate-Pierate these series tend to love making the MC as bland and a blank slate as possible, so that readers can self insert. The thing is, author’ don’t seem to realize how instrumental the main character and their perspective is to a story. This is just boring when the MC (window through which I’m experiencing everything) is as interesting as a paint drying. Usually they get away with it by making the girls interesting.

 

[urtoast]

The moment she was introduced with that mask and you didn't immediately know she was the idol, you haven't read enough manga yet.

 

[TheGuiltyClown]

Pre-serialization was a thousand times better, I don't even know if I want to continue lol

 

[Snickrot]

@TheGuiltyClown yeah, i gotta agree. I would have liked it better if she wasn't an idol.

 

[GambierBay]

Huh.
Well I saw the idol thing coming.

 

[DrKodokushi]

The girl really looks like takamiya rion from nijisanji.