- Joined
- Mar 23, 2024
- Messages
- 2
Por enquanto tô gostando mais, tão demorando muito pra posta em PT-BR
Isekai Saikouhou no Guild Leader ~Guild Saijaku no Boku da Kedo, Guild Members Zen'in no ai ga Omokute Guild o Yameraremasen~
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2024
- Messages
- 60
The people who did the English translation dropped it, with many other mangas as well… it’s sad
- Joined
- May 31, 2024
- Messages
- 8
The concept is interesting and I was initially invested in seeing how the guild was formed and how Crow met all of the members, but the over-the-top, violent yandere reactions to literally everything got old very, very fast. I get it, it's a gag manga and yandere is the focus but, when the close ups of crazy eyes and women slashing and smashing monsters and other women takes up five out of every six panels there's not much to enjoy. It's a shame since there's the bones of a potentially good story beneath all of this shallow, ambiguous violence. Even the way the women in the guild react is pretty much the same, as well, which kills individualism and character development.
tl;dr, Might be amusing for people with a yandere kink but too shallow to really enjoy long term.
tl;dr, Might be amusing for people with a yandere kink but too shallow to really enjoy long term.
I'll be honest here, this is strange grief copy(i dont know which come first) with the mc wear a mask similar to tsukimichi (mc is op but cursed to be ugly, which why he wear a mask) the difference between the strang grief is the mc is not that useless and the mc party not too overpowered. Lastly the jokes/skit not my cup of tea. I give the manga 5/10 for effort. Oh yeah plus is also simmiliar to isekai streamer i believe, so try read strange grieve want to retire, tsukimichi journey to the moon, and isekai haishin or isekai streamer, you will see the resemblance so much
Last edited:
Active member
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2018
- Messages
- 10
Wait, strange grief is a different story? I thought it was this one, given the exact same premise. Well, I don't really care for it either way.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2021
- Messages
- 795
Pros: -both the yandere women and men still being together even if having healthy competition for mc’s affection while (at least for now) not throwing anyone under the bus
-Mc’s indifference to the psychopathy of the yanderes while having his appearance-complex
-attacking of men and women so it doesn’t skew either niche reading group
Cons: -the cutesy or comedy or erotic moments are never good enough even in the face of contrasting dark violence/tragedy
-the main cast is not morally good… they’re not even lesser evils so far; the story lying to the reader that they are is strange… Overlord comes to mind on how to do that storytelling a bit better
-the pacing for moments vs exposition isn’t great. If this manga were an anime, one episode should be 6 minutes and the next episode should be a 40 minute special; that’s how bad the pacing is
Anyway, people shouldn’t call it peak but it’s definitely not trash. I like it, it's fine
-Mc’s indifference to the psychopathy of the yanderes while having his appearance-complex
-attacking of men and women so it doesn’t skew either niche reading group
Cons: -the cutesy or comedy or erotic moments are never good enough even in the face of contrasting dark violence/tragedy
-the main cast is not morally good… they’re not even lesser evils so far; the story lying to the reader that they are is strange… Overlord comes to mind on how to do that storytelling a bit better
-the pacing for moments vs exposition isn’t great. If this manga were an anime, one episode should be 6 minutes and the next episode should be a 40 minute special; that’s how bad the pacing is
Anyway, people shouldn’t call it peak but it’s definitely not trash. I like it, it's fine
bruh, i also thought something was wrong, but why tho? did they break rules?
They've been banned from Mangadex for taking the work of other scanlators and passing it off as their own.
i hope it doesn't affect others manga i follow, saw chapters under them on aggregator site that are not here
If they are the ones to release it, then it won't be here. You will need to either read them at that aggregator or at Philia Scans' site.
Group Leader
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2019
- Messages
- 506
Chapter 12~8 really just ruined my hopes for this manga. I thought it was decent and liked with how the girls reacted towards hostiles and people who tried to hurt them. Then THAT happened and man.......I hate this MC so much man. If anyone wants a spoiler.
they just fucking let the guy who wanted to ruin the MCs life, take his guild and harassed not only the women in his guild but other women go. One of the girls was about to kill him but then she had a flashback of his dumb teachings and let him live. Not only that the author tries to redeem him or make him seem redeemab some effing how???? Like what?????? Oh my god author you're beyond dumb if you think that was smart or makes him morally superior. No it just makes them look stupid. I cannot for the life of me read anymore after that. I actually wanted this to be good cus I liked how the girls didn't hesitate to kill and weren't limp dicks but the MC is so much of one that it's rubbing off on them.
Last edited:
Member
- Joined
- May 12, 2019
- Messages
- 98
You do realize it's still comedy with light adventure and there's no real need to kill every single person along the way?
The manga has proper balance between comedy, action and some darker parts of storytelling, like guild members past.
Besides
girls had big fight just because of it, it's not like it was something taken too lightly.
Try to remember previous arc, the guild members does a plenty of "cleaning" behind the scenes.
Group Leader
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2019
- Messages
- 506
That's what makes it worse wtf?
Member
- Joined
- May 12, 2019
- Messages
- 98
What makes it worse?
Member
- Joined
- May 12, 2019
- Messages
- 98
The latest arc is something else, there is even a few little twists. I like it even more :3 Now the waiting game begins.
Similar threads
