King's Proposal - Vol. 1 Ch. 3 - Garden (1)

[MangaDex]

 

[monkey123]

Another bullshit your way out manga.

 

[Thepandas12]

I haven't read this at all but I'll pretend I read it.

 

[BayuAH]

At any rate, I still do not know what magic is according to the manga. This is like how to draw a horse.

 

[Nolonar]

I still don't see the point of sending MC to school. I understand he needs to learn magic to protect himself, but it was obvious from the start that sending Saika the Witch to school was going to cause all kinds of problems. Wouldn't it have been better to select some trustworthy private tutors and explain the situation to them? Having Saika constantly ask oddly basic questions and messing up is bound to be suspicious after a while.

 

[RedRhetoric]

I still don't see the point of sending MC to school. I understand he needs to learn magic to protect himself, but it was obvious from the start that sending Saika the Witch to school was going to cause all kinds of problems. Wouldn't it have been better to select some trustworthy private tutors and explain the situation to them? Having Saika constantly ask oddly basic questions and messing up is bound to be suspicious after a while.

it's especially odd considering that

Spoiler: Minor Spoilers

Kuroe is an exceptionally skilled magician and should easily be able to teach the MC.
Now that i think about it, Kuroe actually does teach the MC later on in the story so i really don't see why she couldn't have done it now

 

[AncientWatcher]

That poor sexy teacher waifu just saw one of her students unleash raw power equivalent to some serious military ordinance. Of course any normal person would just faint after that.

 

[dive123]

At any rate, I still do not know what magic is according to the manga. This is like how to draw a horse.

Simply put the problem is the difference between saika's and normal mage's mana tank and output. What basically happened in this chapter is an amateur driver started his(?) ride. But instead of a car, he(?) mistakingly started a space rocket lol

 

[dive123]

I still don't see the point of sending MC to school. I understand he needs to learn magic to protect himself, but it was obvious from the start that sending Saika the Witch to school was going to cause all kinds of problems. Wouldn't it have been better to select some trustworthy private tutors and explain the situation to them? Having Saika constantly ask oddly basic questions and messing up is bound to be suspicious after a while.

There could be a lot of reasons. 1st, the most logical reasoning is since the attacker is still unknown, no one could be fully trusted. The victim here was the world-saving witch, so theoritically not many beings could harm her even if she put her guard down. The attacker could be an outsider, an insider, or maybe the alliance of both. Thus whoever it is, to limit the info regarding MC=saika condition probably would be the best.
2nd is to teach the MC about void garden. The time to seperate both of them is still remaining unknown, so it would be better to introduce him(?) to all things that saika knows so it's easier to act as her. Saika is the symbol of the savior, and also the final bastion of the humanity, so it would be better if "saika is still active" remains as status quo

 

[Wu]

I still don't see the point of sending MC to school. I understand he needs to learn magic to protect himself, but it was obvious from the start that sending Saika the Witch to school was going to cause all kinds of problems. Wouldn't it have been better to select some trustworthy private tutors and explain the situation to them? Having Saika constantly ask oddly basic questions and messing up is bound to be suspicious after a while.

If you're interested in my theory, it would be that Kuroe wants MC around other people since the attacker attacked Saika when she was alone, so being around other people (particularly someone strong like Ruri) could discourage the one that attacked Saika

 

[T10_]

There could be a lot of reasons. 1st, the most logical reasoning is since the attacker is still unknown, no one could be fully trusted. The victim here was the world-saving witch, so theoritically not many beings could harm her even if she put her guard down. The attacker could be an outsider, an insider, or maybe the alliance of both. Thus whoever it is, to limit the info regarding MC=saika condition probably would be the best.
2nd is to teach the MC about void garden.

I mean...
The only logical explaination why going to school wouldn't be a shit idea is because the other students could be used for protection
But as you said, saika is apparently the strongest, so the students probably can't do shit if she wasn't assassinated.

The problems outweight the benefits. It would be way better to keep mc isolated under lockdown while practicing magic.
For various reasons;

it was obvious from the start that sending Saika the Witch to school was going to cause all kinds of problems. Wouldn't it have been better to select some trustworthy private tutors and explain the situation to them? Having Saika constantly ask oddly basic questions and messing up is bound to be suspicious after a while.

it's especially odd considering that

Spoiler: Minor Spoilers

Kuroe is an exceptionally skilled magician and should easily be able to teach the MC.
Now that i think about it, Kuroe actually does teach the MC later on in the story so i really don't see why she couldn't have done it now

I also really don't like how they downplayed the attack on saika in the meeting.

 

[Ritsuaka]

Poor sensei

 

[Rex_Nichts]

I think it's pretty obvious that the attacker is this Kuroe maid. I mean, if even the second oldest person in the knights, as well as the person who's been with Saika the longest, doesn't know who she is, then that should have been a red flag. And an attendant just appearing out of complete nowhere and informing the group of an attacker is just a tad bit too suspicious. If the author is going for this surprise, then it's sloppily done. Absolutely sloppy.