You may call him dumb but the dude was going through some pretty heavy emotional mess, not surprising that he was easily manipulated
Right? I don’t think commenters calling him an idiot understand what an abusive relationship does to your mind. (Combined with guilt over murder.)
Unfortunately, he was already so screwed up that he gaslit himself into believing that she was never abusive.
It's easier to fall into that trap than people think. Abuse disorts your reality. It's hard enough to realize how bad it is in the first place when you're eased into it. And when they act like a nice, normal person you wonder if you were just crazy.