[Mainsite] New comment bugs noticed

[grrman]

If MangaDex could stop trying to become a "real" company, that would be great.

 

[shwiftyshfifty]

I'm glad to see I'm not the only person experiencing this ludicrous issue.
Why did they break something that work perfectly well and intuitively?

Money!

 

[BlackUmbrella432]

im on laptop and since the New Comment update, i can't read the page at all because the New Comment cover all the view. i had already click the X many time and it won't disappear and when i click to see a comment, its expand covering all the view.

i hope they fix this issue soon, i had to zooming my chrome page 400% just to read the manga clearly. its annoying to zoom in and out every time.

 

[Lustrist]

now i cant comment my stupid takes. georger orwell

 

[Shot8manga]

Probably not a bug, if I block someone in MD forum I won't be seeing their comments but the same can't be said on the main site. I blocked a profile yet on the new comments section their message persist.

Aside from blocking one for grievances. Sometimes, you just doesn't want so see the same prolific commenter over and over again. 😅

 

[Tebix]

That whole new comment thing seems REALLY poorly thaught out. If they destroy the comment section by splitting it in two I have to look for a new site to read manga on.

 

[kouyo]

Hi, everyone's bugs reports are now being tracked, see
List of Known Bugs

 

[havelmom]

I'm glad to see I'm not the only person experiencing this ludicrous issue.
Why did they break something that work perfectly well and intuitively?

insert webdev joke here

 

[louloute0203]

Any ETA on the resolution of this issue ? And why wasn't the problem reverted or rolled back until it was functionnal? There's really no reason to let the issue fester like this, unless it's the intended experience.

 

[BananowyJE]

Even if the thread already exists for the comments to the chapter, sometimes it takes 2 or 3 clicks before it actually engages the loading on Mozilla 150.
Thanks for putting comments behind the paywall without even testing the thing....

 

[havelmom]

Any ETA on the resolution of this issue ? And why wasn't the problem reverted or rolled back until it was functionnal? There's really no reason to let the issue fester like this, unless it's the intended experience.

rolling back is heretical in webdev dogma
see the youtube scriptures

 

[kouyo]

Hi everyone, to clarify: we haven't put comments behind a paywall. We’re currently testing a new architecture with a small group (Supporters, Contributors, Group Leaders, etc.) to ensure the site doesn't crash under heavy load and to iron out issues before the full rollout.

We know the current bugs are frustrating. We didn't roll back immediately because the new system involves significant underlying changes, but our team is heads-down on a patch right now to address these reports.

 

[JVick]

Hi everyone, to clarify: we haven't put comments behind a paywall. We’re currently testing a new architecture with a small group (Supporters, Contributors, Group Leaders, etc.) to ensure the site doesn't crash under heavy load and to iron out issues before the full rollout.

We know the current bugs are frustrating. We didn't roll back immediately because the new system involves significant underlying changes, but our team is heads-down on a patch right now to address these reports.

Can you confirm users will be able to create the comment section like before, no matter their supporter status ?

 

[TR25]

Can you confirm users will be able to create the comment section like before, no matter their supporter status ?

That's the plan, yes

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

https://mangadex.org/chapter/154a18f3-f427-4827-b4b2-3b1ea44ded6b?comments=1
Another part of the bugs noticed:
On externally hosted chapters, like Mangaplus, comment threads on Forums cannot be started even if a comment exists.

 

[Angry_Panda]

https://mangadex.org/chapter/154a18f3-f427-4827-b4b2-3b1ea44ded6b?comments=1
Another part of the bugs noticed:
On externally hosted chapters, like Mangaplus, comment threads on Forums cannot be started even if a comment exists.

They can, but you have to click directly on the comment icon next to the chapter listing rather than the chapter title itself. (Since clicking on the chapter opens the external site.)

 

[panzerkampfwagyu]

They can, but you have to click directly on the comment icon next to the chapter listing rather than the chapter title itself. (Since clicking on the chapter opens the external site.)

That just leads to the social view, for some harebrained reason.

 

[Angry_Panda]

That just leads to the social view, for some harebrained reason.

Right, and from there you can use the usual route to start the forum chapter thread (which is currently limited to privileged users).

 

[asfhoiasfjoiasfjpi]

I'm glad to see I'm not the only person experiencing this ludicrous issue.
Why did they break something that work perfectly well and intuitively?

money

 

[asfhoiasfjoiasfjpi]

Right, and from there you can use the usual route to start the forum chapter thread (which is currently limited to privileged users).

so you still have to read through the dumb new paywall comments first?