Double-page supporter
- Joined
- May 18, 2026
- Messages
- 185
You don't know anything about the history of Jews in Japan.And while I can't say with absolute certainty that Nishi based Border Patrol's fervent rule to expel outsiders on Japan's historical isolationism that had them banish or exterminate outsider "heretics" as opposed to any commonalities between any groups in the USA or in 1930's Germany... I know which one I would say it much more likely.
You're very silly.I'll just say it, I find your statements that Nishi made the manga as a statement on real world politics just as ludicrous as the former admin of the Silent Hill wikia that said the developers of the first 4 games were "trying to wake people up" about "the sins of America" that involved satanism and circumcision conspiracies.
That's the most oxymoronic sentence I have ever seen.I agree it's a political statement. I'm just saying it's not based on any specific incident,
You don't know anything about our history.but more of how the powerful keep a minority underfoot and beholden to enrich themselves, which is a tale as old as humankind itself.
Thrembs went over all this.
Nazi isn't a dirty word. Fear of saying it is... odd.So I'm a bigot because I gave you Dumb reactions? Get the fuck over yourself. I'm anti-ICE, anti-N**i, anti anti-Semitsm. I called your statements stupid, because they're stupid, not for any other reason.
You can be both anti Nazi, and antisemitic.
You are probably unintentionally antisemitic.
The expository speech about their backstory has references to specific prayers, and mirrors our history. The reasons for the founding of their own country are the exact same that people use to justify the current disaster.
Look at the timing of that arc's release.
It's cringe, but it's BLATANT.
If you were Jewish, you would know.
Iruma facing down Kommandant Amy is a reference to a famous hasidic story.
THEY DO A POGROM WITH ARMBANDS.
It's so heavy-handed I was laughing and shouting the whole time I was reading it. "Yes yes yes yes no" style.
The shelves of books are referenced from Jewish libraries. Seforim have very distinctive spines.
Orias' office in the Mafia spinoff is just traced off some rabbi's office.
Kiddush cups everywhere. I saw ones I considered buying online in the past!
Demons have b'nei mitzvah.
THEY DANCED A HORA.
You don't know. You have no way of knowing, because you're not Jewish, and haven't studied the details of Judaism.
Hell, Thrembs was citing Talmud and Midrash Rabbah to predict plot points.
This manga is very much from a Jewish perspective (plus some chutzpah) by the time you get to the music festival arc.
We know our own. I can tell if a film was made by a Jew. Harder with music, but possible.
I can spot another Jew from across a room, regardless of any other ethnic background. Jewdar is real, and we all have it.
This is like people who deny that The Love Trio is a polycule...