Mods refuse to fix incorrectly labeled erotic doujin

Status
Not open for further replies.
Contributor
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
503
Mods refuse to remove the girls love tag from Chin Make Les Couple despite several reports on how the doujin isn't girls love. Please remove the girls love tag
Instead of yelling that the mods "refused" to do something you think they should of done, you could just ask about it.

Most of the time with situations like this it's a mod or even several mods that have a different opinion, or didn't feel that there is a solid enough justification for making a change.

While I agree this title probably shouldn't be tagged as girls' love, I do understand why other may have a different opinion.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 6, 2019
Messages
590
This narrative and threesome is basically what they did in hentai before the mid 2000s and the yuri part is a joke, not a bait. So basically an harem with double NTR to add them as his personal slaves, so at most you could tag it as bisexual. In hentai sites exist a different tag for this kind of doujinshi different to yuri (or girls love), and considering how Mangadex works it is not proper to tag it as such. It happens with both SFW and NSFW titles, but since not everyone has yuri knowledge and functional yuri glasses then it is bound to repeat. This series falls under the same category and shouldn't have the yuri tag either (worse even, it's only because of one panel, but I already explained that there). If it helps with this title in particular, you can check the genres from the seller and the original post + raw.
 
Power Uploader
Joined
Jul 12, 2020
Messages
211
This narrative and threesome is basically what they did in hentai before the mid 2000s and the yuri part is a joke, not a bait.
My god, the plot itself is irrelevant. The tags are content descriptors. Just as it doesn't matter whether a rape scene is actually a dream or not, it doesn't matter why there are females in an homosexual relationship depicted having sex. What does matter is being able to filter it in or out, and since MD isn't a porn website such as exhentai with a highly granular tagging system, GL alone will have to do. Tag also present on exhentai by the way, I wonder why. 🧑‍🦼

This take is such a high level of double standards it's preposterous. If those two women had been men shown having anal sex and/or sucking each other's dick, the BL tag would have been slapped twice. And it would have been right, as not everyone wants to see that.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 6, 2019
Messages
590
I put all the links so you could compare (the publisher doesn't categorise it as yuri but the scanlator did, and I always was told that publishers take precedence), and basically said that if "bisexual" tag were added it could be filtered out more precisely as they do with girls/boys love so people don't see them. And well, you made it clear that the tags are being used to filter out regarding sensibilities and not actually making it easier to find titles with the desired content, so in that sense you don't need to make any changes. No need to make retorts or being arrogant, you want to protect sensibilities and I want people to find the desired content easier, we have different objectives. This way people who want to read yuri (hentai or not, same example for other niche genres) come across with series with elements they don't want to find, it's a double-edged sword. In other words, genre and content get confused, and since there's already a box in hentai titles to put all the contents people can know about the contents beforehand so adding it seems unnecessary.
 
Last edited:
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jun 14, 2020
Messages
251
My take on this would have mainly been how horrific the series is. Converting Lesbians?

Its a scary subject since there's all varieties of people who try to do this in the real world ,and by that I mean converting gay people to heterosexuality in general; using various kinds of 'therapy' or torture (therapeutic or otherwise) and frequently detainment and/or inprisonment.

I have a strong stance against censorship but jeezh. 😵‍💫😵💀💀
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jun 14, 2020
Messages
251
Also, I'm starting to think the tag system really doesn't work the way it should as it's setup here on the site.

Like, if we want to read yuri, and we search titles with that tag, we could end up getting baited into reading an offensive title about converting gay women over to hetero, so they can join some guys harem. Cringe ☠️

Maybe we should have tags for the primary intended genre of the title, and then content tags describing the rest of the content. I.e, does it maybe have some scenes or themes of girl's love or such.
 
Supporter
Joined
Aug 1, 2019
Messages
412
Also, I'm starting to think the tag system really doesn't work the way it should as it's setup here on the site.

Like, if we want to read yuri, and we search titles with that tag, we could end up getting baited into reading an offensive title about converting gay women over to hetero, so they can join some guys harem. Cringe ☠️

Maybe we should have tags for the primary intended genre of the title, and then content tags describing the rest of the content. I.e, does it maybe have some scenes or themes of girl's love or such.
I feel like if you read a hentai manga titled "Lesbian Couple Defeated by Penis" you kind of deserve it at that point.

Add on to that this
lrikW2S.png

is also pretty clear on the page.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jun 14, 2020
Messages
251
You guys are missing the point entirely. The yuri or girls love tag shouldn't be on a series like this. Just because it has a theme or a motif including elements of that doesn't mean it needs the tag.

To make my point, the synopsis can convey all of this information just as easily as the tag. In fact it can do so a million times better since you can type that very description into it so that people can properly be horrified and avoid it. 😅
 
Last edited:
Aggregator gang
Joined
Jun 14, 2020
Messages
251
I feel like if you read a hentai manga titled "Lesbian Couple Defeated by Penis" you kind of deserve it at that point.

Add on to that this
lrikW2S.png

is also pretty clear on the page.
Dunno. Never read it.

I just read the description given here in this thread.
It's porn, what do you really expect? What's worse with this than mesugaki correction? 💢💢💦💦
Expect? Nothing really. I don't read any of that kind of stuff, ever, ever, ever. And I want it to stay that way...thus my stance on the tags.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 24, 2019
Messages
1,305
I have him ignored for a reason, it's like someone that needs to vent and then logs in Mangadex. I don't remember reading anything constructive from him either, so at least I don't get notified when he goes berserk.
He's probably one of the weirdest people here with some strange opinions. At first I thought he was just underage, but at lot of the stuff he writes is retarded really stupid a little weird. Good to see others also have noticed and I'm not the only one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Top