Momiji to Kouyou - Ch. 2 - Pancakes and Napolitan

Active member
Joined
Nov 5, 2020
Messages
55
Just keep it here, forget these people, also they see a guy crossdressing to like "pay for the bad faith jokes/bullying he maded before" (which we didnt saw but i think he did it for an entire year of maybe till the first confession) and they just think of trans, like not every crossdressing guy is a transfem, if i would call a transfem a crossdressing would i be wrong? YES, So why the other way around is fine to do?

Rn at this point its a guy crossdressing, atleast for now

, also the girl doesnt even know if shes really lesbian, also "rap*" like wtf, she doesnt like him cause he was mean at that time, why are these people watering down words
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 6, 2020
Messages
424
Bro I just wanna enjoy my guy feeling pretty in the skirt and blouse and enjoying a hearty meal with his unrequited crush from elementary to high school.

Fucking hobnob goblin looking ass "allies" saying this is (g)rape and hexual sarrassment when it's well meaning.

Hell, I'll apologise and count myself wrong if it goes into GalClean territory but I'm on this hill and planting myself firmly.

Fuck Twitter is a joke.
 
Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2024
Messages
7
as a trans woman married to a cis woman TM we are very much lesbian and no woman that would date me is straight

that being said, I also agree that we need a tag for romances that fall between the commom gay, lesbian and straight Ones
i’d recommend a simple “queer romance” tag for these. Even if just to start.
not sure how i feel about pseudo yuri / pseudo yaoi but I agree its valid

but we also should add an policy of respecting the tags, even if you dont enjoy it. Leave quietly through the back door please
( like, im not going into gore mangas comment section commenting about hating blood or whatever)

also, thanks for the TL ! Keep on translating please!!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 4, 2019
Messages
1,289
throwing my 2 cents into the fountain

its these niche scenarios that i find more specific tags like from tracking sites to be helpful in distinctly categorizing what kind of story this is, even if the tag system is supposed to be for generalizing manga at a glance

all actual transgender stories have to resort to tags such as "Gender Bender" or "Crossdressing" when its neither, so the waters get muddied if one wants to find stories with that as its topic

can i see this as bad rep? yeah, its pretty crass
was that the authors intention? probably not! they probably just wanted to write your avg cute crossdresser x woman manga 💀
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 15, 2018
Messages
1,660
HE WILL TAKE A SKIRT...
AND WEAR IT!
What a dastardly plan she weaves!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 10, 2020
Messages
637
Crossdressing tag together with the cover art and summary description make it clear what the reader can expect moreso than yuri tag. Both main characters might be questioning so who really knows how it will develop. Author-san could even be flexible on that depending on reception and $$$. Visually, it has a strong yuri vibe so I wouldn't mind it having a GL tag, but I can see that being misleading. Whether the crossdresser ultimately identifies as trans or a femboy is not going to impact my enjoyment of the series. Wondering about that can actually be part of the dramatic appeal in longer running series like Prunus Girl, and Turned My Childhood Friend into a Girl. Most series like that seem to be B/? rather than G/? so it's great to see the latter for a change.
 
Supporter
Joined
Feb 12, 2024
Messages
1,363
Bunch of transphobia in those screenshotted comments.

No "man" changes his gender presentation to chase a woman.
-_-

It would never happen if the inclination wasn't already there.

Also she is clearly into trans girls.

When I transitioned one thing neither my girlfriend or I expected is how in to trans women she would be. They later came out as nonbinary, and playing with gender has been very spicy for both of us. 💕

People getting all butthurt over a fairly lighthearted take on gender bending is a result of their own sexism and or transphobia. I'm sure there are plenty of gender conforming manga out there to comfort then. They can also go make friends with famed author jk Rowling. Cause they are making the same stupid arguments.

Please continue to provide us with our vapid gender bendy Yuri. 🙏🏻

Not everything needs to be deep. Things can just be kinda cute and fun.
 
Supporter
Joined
Feb 12, 2024
Messages
1,363
It's comforting to see so many reasonable and/or at least open comments in response to the tl question in here. 🏳️‍⚧️💕

Bigots are everywhere, but they are not the only people out there.
 
Active member
Joined
Dec 20, 2018
Messages
21
the negative comments are also just??? overlooking the fact that there's no point where ao doesn't have all the information to make an informed choice about the relationship. momiji walks into the date literally introducing herself as being kouyou.
 
Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2024
Messages
29
I really feel like the normal reaction to this manga is "Oh hey a new take on cross-dressing romance where it's clear to both people involved the intentions and backgrounds of each other". I feel like a twitter reaction is "I'm going to threaten the mangaka and the translators with death for interacting with the concepts of gender in a way I have chosen to read as political statements on transgender rights. Also this situation where neither person is lying to the other and both are consenting is rape."
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top