- Joined
- Aug 7, 2018
- Messages
- 17
The recommendation to use Save for Web (PNG8) is generally bad, since it will produce an Indexed PNG which is only 99.6% lossless, not to mention some viewer software scales it horribly. Reducing colors below 256 with Indexed PNG also has a tendency to murder screentones and create horrible aliasing on edges. Unless you have a raw which which is already very low bitdepth without any edge smoothing, saving a few extra KB usually isn't worthwhile for the quality loss. To each their own though.
Most of the time, you should aim for a proper Grayscale workspace with Grayscale PNG8 output. A few more steps, but really what I'd personally recommend if aiming for maximum compatibility and quality.
[ul]
Ensure your Grayscale Workspace is set to sGray (Grayscale equivalent of sRGB, web default), Edit -> Color Settings -> Working Spaces -> Gray -> sGray
Open your Image
Image -> Mode -> Grayscale -> Discard Color (Workspace is now Grayscale sGray)
Always ensure your layers are Flattened before saving, Right click your layer -> Flatten (Removes Alpha, Workspace is now 8bit Grayscale)
Save as PNG and uncheck the color profile (Photoshop will output a Grayscale PNG8 automatically)
If you intend to re-compress with pinga/pingo afterwords, you can output uncompressed PNGs from Photoshop to save some time[/ul]
Most of the time, you should aim for a proper Grayscale workspace with Grayscale PNG8 output. A few more steps, but really what I'd personally recommend if aiming for maximum compatibility and quality.
[ul]
Ensure your Grayscale Workspace is set to sGray (Grayscale equivalent of sRGB, web default), Edit -> Color Settings -> Working Spaces -> Gray -> sGray
Open your Image
Image -> Mode -> Grayscale -> Discard Color (Workspace is now Grayscale sGray)
Always ensure your layers are Flattened before saving, Right click your layer -> Flatten (Removes Alpha, Workspace is now 8bit Grayscale)
Save as PNG and uncheck the color profile (Photoshop will output a Grayscale PNG8 automatically)
If you intend to re-compress with pinga/pingo afterwords, you can output uncompressed PNGs from Photoshop to save some time[/ul]