Ore no Imouto ga Saikou no Okazudatta - Vol. 1 Ch. 9

[Mist221322]

Ad, not axe. Spoilers on page 2 here.

i mean the manga being axed not the source material i know that's out there.

 

[definitionofinsanity]

Alright, I'm going to spoil a ton stuff up to chapter 46 of the WN; save you all the torture. Ask if you need more:

Spoiler: It's a lot, so strap in

Haruka is a cancer on this story. Everything goes back to her, despite the fact that she's barely present. The trip is announced in chapter 13. For the next 30+ chapters, it, and Haruka, keep getting hyped up more and more. If there's a mystery, a secret, or some piece of missing information, chances are good that it goes back to Haruka.

I won't beat around the bush any further: Haruka and Miyu are lezzing it up on the trip. Haruka is a high-end lolita fashion model. Miyu is selling herself to Haruka so Haruka will lend (not give) her some lolita outfits, and give her money to make her own. The way the manga had built it up, you'd think they were doing travelling sex shows for rich lesbians, or doing gangbangs. She masturbates to herself (With a vibrator, and a full-body mirror) in these dresses at home, and keeps a physical album of the lesbian stuff she did on the trip in her closet, along with the lolita clothes. The album, and the fetish for herself in lolita clothes are a source of shame, and embarassment and tucked away for now. Almost all of this happens off screen, save for a single description of Miyu getting off to herself. The trip comes, and we're stuck with MC's POV back home, while the FMC goes off to do porn things away from the audience in a PORN novel. This "secret" is, by far, the second or third most vanilla thing to happen in this story, so I don't know why all the fucking mystery just to tell us after the fact.
Miyu is also scared of being caught in Lolita clothes in general because her parents and teacher told her she's seducing her classmates in the third grade, and was told to stop wearing them.

TL;DR: The trip was relatively vanilla lez stuff, happened off screen, and wasn't worth the buildup. Haruka is Miyu's benefactor on top of being friends, so she's extra protective/tolerant. Miyu gets off to herself in lolita outfits, so she sleeps with Haruka to get paid, and borrow outfits. EDIT: If more happens on the trip, we haven't found out yet.



Miyu is not nearly this stoic in the Web Novel. This goes for her reaction to drinking cum for the first time too. Manga makes it look like she's used to all this, but she was shocked, and MC believed it was her first time ever due to the fact that she was so uncomposed despite offering herself like that.

Miyu has androphobia. She's ok with men in theory, but the moment they approach her, she's immediately turned off, no matter how attractive (explicitly stated that attractiveness is a turn-off, but this may just be rationalization). She's been confessed to by men and women. She thought she might be a lesbian, but she never found one she liked (Though she doesn't mind being touched by them in that way). Eventually got her harsh attitude after rejecting so many people. Miyu has never been with another man, and we personally saw the first time she drank cum. The reason she decided to start helping is because her brother, unlike all other men, didn't disgust her, despite the fact that she caught him masturbating, furiously, to a character with her name; she wanted to explore this new thing, and see what she'd be ok with.

The cum catching was done on a whim. She let the intrusive thoughts win once, and after realizing she's not bothered by it, and is actually only turned on by close relatives, she kept going (In for a penny, in for a pound). The lack of blowjob (among other things) was her trying to wrestle with the confused feelings. She's very much cognizant of the fact that it's her brother she'd doing this all with, and she's like to maintain some modicum of "Ew, no. I'm not going to suck my actual brother's dick!". Naturally, the acts escalate, sometimes by accident, sometimes deliberately, and she reluctantly loses her inhibitions.

TL;DR: Miyu is only into family, and hates attractive men. MC fits the bill to be her lover, and he's the only guy she's been with. Her boundaries are inconsistent because she's confused herself. She's bothered by her lack of resistance to doing more with MC, so she resists.

I went through over one million characters of chicken scratch with some shitty MTL help to get to this. Be grateful.

...Tell me how I can pin a medal on you for jumping on this fucking grenade for the entire community.

Also:

Spoiler

It's rather surprising Miyu turns out to be into all this lesbian-but-not-really-but-maybe-but-also-for-money stuff. I mean, her brother asked her if she was into girls like Haruka and she seemed entirely unphased and not nervous in her reaction at all. Then again, with her saying Haruka is off limits because... reasons... it does make some sort of sense... I... Guess?

Although the whole "I'm fearful of guys but I'll lick cum off my brother's crotch" is rather contradicting and conflicting even if we just chalk it up to "intrusive thoughts win for once."

Just... fuckin' weird. Even for degenerate Japanese incest stories, it's weird.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

...Tell me how I can pin a medal on you for jumping on this fucking grenade for the entire community.

I'm still only halfway through the story, the author hasn't actually solved the mystery of the trip, and I'm slowly building up the patience to do this a second time in hopes that we get a flashback or something, instead of just people telling us what happens in the trips generally, after the fact. I NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THIS ONE, IN GREAT DETAIL. WHY EVEN INCLUDE IT IF YOU WON'T LET ME SEE?! All I need is moral support, and you're doing wonderful on that front. Thank you.

Spoiler: In order

It's rather surprising Miyu turns out to be into all this lesbian-but-not-really-but-maybe-but-also-for-money stuff. I mean, her brother asked her if she was into girls like Haruka and she seemed entirely unphased and not nervous in her reaction at all.

Miyu is definitely not any stripe of lesbian. She categorically denies this. Like I said: She never found a girl she liked, but doesn't mind being touched by one. Miyu refuses to answer many questions, so it stands out that she answered this one so clearly. If the answer changes in future chapters, it's a retcon, and the author is an even bigger hack than I thought.

Although the whole "I'm fearful of guys but I'll lick cum off my brother's crotch" is rather contradicting and conflicting even if we just chalk it up to "intrusive thoughts win for once."

She's been asked about this repeatedly throughout the story. In this author's typical fashion, she's avoided the question, and the whole "It's the first time she's eaten cum" thing, while technically sound, given everything the story's said so far, there is, in the strictest possible sense, room for "Actually, I blew everyone in town before I realized I won't get over my fear of men", since technically hasn't answered the question. The line that concerns me in particular with regards to this wiggle room is being asked if she's ever considered drinking other guys' cum, and instead of saying "yes", or "no", she rephrases the question to something like "If she'd ever allow anyone else to have her drink their cum", then, in typical Miyu fashion, refuses to answer even her own rephrased question!

Sure, she might be refusing to answer because confirming or denying it basically lets MC know she actually wants to drink his cum, but then it also gives a bad writer a chance to retcon all of this and have her blow guys despite the phobia. Everything else in the story points to this being a case of the "intrusive thoughts".

P.S.: Not fearful of men. At all. She's repulsed by them, not scared. She even got into fights them them in school, and won.

 

[definitionofinsanity]

I'm still only halfway through the story, the author hasn't actually solved the mystery of the trip, and I'm slowly building up the patience to do this a second time in hopes that we get a flashback or something, instead of just people telling us what happens in the trips generally, after the fact. I NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THIS ONE, IN GREAT DETAIL. WHY EVEN INCLUDE IT IF YOU WON'T LET ME SEE?! All I need is moral support, and you're doing wonderful on that front. Thank you.

Spoiler: In order

Miyu is definitely not any stripe of lesbian. She categorically denies this. Like I said: She never found a girl she liked, but doesn't mind being touched by one. Miyu refuses to answer many questions, so it stands out that she answered this one so clearly. If the answer changes in future chapters, it's a retcon, and the author is an even bigger hack than I thought.

She's been asked about this repeatedly throughout the story. In this author's typical fashion, she's avoided the question, and the whole "It's the first time she's eaten cum" thing, while technically sound, given everything the story's said so far, there is, in the strictest possible sense, room for "Actually, I blew everyone in town before I realized I won't get over my fear of men", since technically hasn't answered the question. The line that concerns me in particular with regards to this wiggle room is being asked if she's ever considered drinking other guys' cum, and instead of saying "yes", or "no", she rephrases the question to something like "If she'd ever allow anyone else to have her drink their cum", then, in typical Miyu fashion, refuses to answer even her own rephrased question!

Sure, she might be refusing to answer because confirming or denying it basically lets MC know she actually wants to drink his cum, but then it also gives a bad writer a chance to retcon all of this and have her blow guys despite the phobia. Everything else in the story points to this being a case of the "intrusive thoughts".

P.S.: Not fearful of men. At all. She's repulsed by them, not scared. She even got into fights them them in school, and won.

I think I get it. Is it sort of like knowing you're seeing a dumpster fire but it's such a puzzling/bizarre thing that you just have to know?

 

[bk3k]

Bro, she drinks his cum. What are you on?

If you can't even make babies with your sister, why live?

 

[HoangDinh]

expected tbh

 

[MovieT]

A group called DegenTL has recently started translating the web novel (at least according to Novel Updates). I can't find where they are being posted or a link for this translation group. Does anyone know anything about this?

 

[Kurmon]

A group called DegenTL has recently started translating the web novel (at least according to Novel Updates). I can't find where they are being posted or a link for this translation group. Does anyone know anything about this?

You need to log in to see the links on Novel Updates
Anyway, here: https://www.degentl.com/novel/ore-no-imouto-ga-saikou-no-okazu-datta/

 

[MovieT]

You need to log in to see the links on Novel Updates
Anyway, here: https://www.degentl.com/novel/ore-no-imouto-ga-saikou-no-okazu-datta/

Thanks so much. That is useful information.

 

[MusicSkyG]

Just reading the synopsis for the novels on ani list made me just go what is this series

 

[nickypoor]

Very nearly, around the 44-47 mark. Miyu is super turned on by doing stuff with bro, and now that she's actually touching blowing him, she's turned into a sex zombie once so far. He shouted her out of the state because he's worried about pregnancy.


EDIT: Blowing, not touching. The touching started earlier.


Not Axe; Ad.

Did you happen to read this online? If so where? If not then it’s ok.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

Did you happen to read this online? If so where? If not then it’s ok.

There's a link right on this page. And then a guy quoting the original thanking him for it, and thus copying the link.

 

[Satriya72]

https://x.com/kazamihitori/status/1791249922127511675
It's not over?!

 

[dirtylolotrainer]

What that's it!??? I need more, does anyone read the novel!?

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

What that's it!??? I need more, does anyone read the novel!?

If you hadn't immediately posted without so much as reading the first page, you'd know there's spoilers up to chapter 47.

TL;DR: The author doesn't shut the FUCK up about that trip he mentioned, makes it the single most important thing in the story, then refuses to tell us what happened on it.

 

[Dreamsicle92]

My advice for anyone considering reading the web novel to get to the good shit: don't waste your time. At chapter 58, I'm probably close, but not sure it's worth my sanity anymore. I can safely say that pretty much all of the main characters need many, many years of therapy, and that's coming from someone that just wanted the MC to bang his little sister lol. 95% is just fucking exhausting to read.

 

[BuyVelomobiles]

My advice for anyone considering reading the web novel to get to the good shit: don't waste your time. At chapter 58, I'm probably close, but not sure it's worth my sanity anymore. I can safely say that pretty much all of the main characters need many, many years of therapy, and that's coming from someone that just wanted the MC to bang his little sister lol. 95% is just fucking exhausting to read.

I just want to know about the trip...

 

[-Zerous-]

Alright, I'm going to spoil a ton stuff up to chapter 46 of the WN; save you all the torture. Ask if you need more:

Spoiler: It's a lot, so strap in

Haruka is a cancer on this story. Everything goes back to her, despite the fact that she's barely present. The trip is announced in chapter 13. For the next 30+ chapters, it, and Haruka, keep getting hyped up more and more. If there's a mystery, a secret, or some piece of missing information, chances are good that it goes back to Haruka.

I won't beat around the bush any further: Haruka and Miyu are lezzing it up on the trip. Haruka is a high-end lolita fashion model. Miyu is selling herself to Haruka so Haruka will lend (not give) her some lolita outfits, and give her money to make her own. The way the manga had built it up, you'd think they were doing travelling sex shows for rich lesbians, or doing gangbangs. She masturbates to herself (With a vibrator, and a full-body mirror) in these dresses at home, and keeps a physical album of the lesbian stuff she did on the trip in her closet, along with the lolita clothes. The album, and the fetish for herself in lolita clothes are a source of shame, and embarassment and tucked away for now. Almost all of this happens off screen, save for a single description of Miyu getting off to herself. The trip comes, and we're stuck with MC's POV back home, while the FMC goes off to do porn things away from the audience in a PORN novel. This "secret" is, by far, the second or third most vanilla thing to happen in this story, so I don't know why all the fucking mystery just to tell us after the fact.
Miyu is also scared of being caught in Lolita clothes in general because her parents and teacher told her she's seducing her classmates in the third grade, and was told to stop wearing them.

TL;DR: The trip was relatively vanilla lez stuff, happened off screen, and wasn't worth the buildup. Haruka is Miyu's benefactor on top of being friends, so she's extra protective/tolerant. Miyu gets off to herself in lolita outfits, so she sleeps with Haruka to get paid, and borrow outfits. EDIT: If more happens on the trip, we haven't found out yet.



Miyu is not nearly this stoic in the Web Novel. This goes for her reaction to drinking cum for the first time too. Manga makes it look like she's used to all this, but she was shocked, and MC believed it was her first time ever due to the fact that she was so uncomposed despite offering herself like that.

Miyu has androphobia. She's ok with men in theory, but the moment they approach her, she's immediately turned off, no matter how attractive (explicitly stated that attractiveness is a turn-off, but this may just be rationalization). She's been confessed to by men and women. She thought she might be a lesbian, but she never found one she liked (Though she doesn't mind being touched by them in that way). Eventually got her harsh attitude after rejecting so many people. Miyu has never been with another man, and we personally saw the first time she drank cum. The reason she decided to start helping is because her brother, unlike all other men, didn't disgust her, despite the fact that she caught him masturbating, furiously, to a character with her name; she wanted to explore this new thing, and see what she'd be ok with.

The cum catching was done on a whim. She let the intrusive thoughts win once, and after realizing she's not bothered by it, and is actually only turned on by close relatives, she kept going (In for a penny, in for a pound). The lack of blowjob (among other things) was her trying to wrestle with the confused feelings. She's very much cognizant of the fact that it's her brother she'd doing this all with, and she's like to maintain some modicum of "Ew, no. I'm not going to suck my actual brother's dick!". Naturally, the acts escalate, sometimes by accident, sometimes deliberately, and she reluctantly loses her inhibitions.

TL;DR: Miyu is only into family, and hates attractive men. MC fits the bill to be her lover, and he's the only guy she's been with. Her boundaries are inconsistent because she's confused herself. She's bothered by her lack of resistance to doing more with MC, so she resists.

I went through over one million characters of chicken scratch with some shitty MTL help to get to this. Be grateful.

Miyu doing lesbian shit just ruined the story imo

Lost all interest in this manga

(FYI, I don't mind lesbian stuff, I just heavily dislike when a character has sexual relations with multiple people, just something about that strikes a cord with me)