【Oshi no Ko】 - Ch. 153 - FICTION

Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 10, 2020
Messages
626
Putting aside a critical matter for a moment, to some extent it's both more fitting and better revenge (mixed with redemption) if Aqua gets through to Kamiki that this wasn't fiction and that his whole basis for things was wrong. If he makes him truly and deeply regret it even while he's punished for it, vs "ah well someone better caught up with me", by undermining the foundation he lays out here. But the critical matter can't be put aside long:
How is this dude going to justify driving the incel to commit suicide and killing Katayose Yoru
Also Goro, aka, Aqua himself. That we know of. And yeah how Aka resolves that is going to be central IMO to whether he can stick the landing here, and I wonder if he wrote himself into something of a corner. Having the fan who killed Ai kill himself actually would kinda fit in a twisted manner, he was "just a tool" and "even if instigated, he's still guilty".

But killing completely unconnected people including a medical doctor, and continuing to murder and reveling in it for a decade+ afterwards? That doesn't really work. Maybe even Goro can be explained by the whole period being a black one of insanity he regretted afterwards, but that definitely doesn't apply any time afterwards. Kamiki's character in all the plot so far would have worked just as well if he had never hurt anyone else ever again afterwards. He'd still be guilty as hell, he'd still be covering it up, others would be too. Killing that actress had zilch to do with the core plot, it was just a "look how bad this guy is!" set of pages. Having established this guy has been a serial killer ever since, I don't think that's redeemable particularly given he doesn't seem to be bringing that up and there is no sign Aqua or anyone realizes it (and really, how could they?).

In some types of stories the Unreliable Narrator mechanism could play in, where it turns out this flashback isn't actually 3rd person omniscient but what Kamiki is revealing to Aqua, and in turn Kamiki is either lying or conveniently distorting thinks. So the readers themselves are challenged to interrogate what they're seeing and being told and not necessarily believe it. OnK hasn't really run that way though, flashbacks have been time travel flashbacks, seeing history play out. Maybe if challenged right away next chapter. But he'll need to face real justice. Anyway, guess we'll see.

I'm a little disappointed so far that so much has been focused purely on Kamiki too. Maybe more is planned for later, but still I thought there'd be a little more dealing with the large entertainment world and nature of power. In earlier sections it seemed like there might be more interrogation of who stood to make money off of looking the other way of a variety of dirty business culminating in the murders. So far though it's become very singular, more so then I expected.

I guess just in general it feels like a bunch of threads that were built up over the course of the series just got dropped hard in the last few chapters and it all rushed along. Granted that happens with plenty of manga but still too bad.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 20, 2018
Messages
803
i know this is fiction, but once you kill someone you lose all human rights and should lose all sympathy, this arc is retarded and author-san trying to somehow redeem Kamiki is omegaretarded

thank god the series is ending, a lot of authors really fumble the end of their series, but this is even worse than a fumble, what with the Kana romance and this bs
 
Active member
Joined
Oct 22, 2018
Messages
31
I hate Aka and he can't finish a series cleanly even if his life is at stake, but people who're thinking Aka is trying to redeem Hikaru doesn't understand what they're reading.
Yeah some of y'all are illiterate.
No duh murder is bad, this isn't a murder is okay if you're traumatized enough story.

But I like Aka still even if he sucks with ending.
 
Active member
Joined
Jan 27, 2018
Messages
28
I hate Aka and he can't finish a series cleanly even if his life is at stake, but people who're thinking Aka is trying to redeem Hikaru doesn't understand what they're reading.
Some people really think that showing that the villain has feelings, insecurities, a human mental through process, etc means that he's being redeemed.
Maybe you can acknowledge that the villain can still be a tragic person even if he deserves no forgiveness, or even at least just explain how did things end up that way even if it can not be justified any more due to how far he's gone.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 20, 2019
Messages
2,259
I don't know why some of you guys think they're trying to redeem to him lol. It's simply explaining why things got to where they are.
 
Active member
Joined
Nov 1, 2018
Messages
50
I'm guessing this is a lie too. Ai never loved him, Aqua just knows it'll make it hurt that much more if she did.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 24, 2019
Messages
455
I don't think this chapter is trying to redeem Kamiki but wants to show his motives. Many killers think they have a good reason for what they did. We get the flashback told by himself so of course it looks like he's the victim.
 
Supporter
Joined
Apr 5, 2023
Messages
3,870
I don't think this chapter is trying to redeem Kamiki but wants to show his motives. Many killers think they have a good reason for what they did. We get the flashback told by himself so of course it looks like he's the victim.
Trope: The villain is the hero of his own story.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top