Replay Girl - Oneshot

[RomanceKnight]

both of em are insane.. but if i could i would read a whole series of this shit lol

 

[pushpakg]

I want a series out of this with no drama bs moving forward

 

[H2lo]

That was a wild story, but I still don't understand why she admitted to cheating when she didn't 😕

Because she was done with him and in the rage of the moment wanted to end it quickly.

 

[the_zrn172213]

Well she deserved it, now they can truly heal from the hurt and get back together! If the guy is still willing to forgive her.

 

[Hussam4]

Ok this was pretty good. I'd love to read a serialized manga that continues from where the oneshot ends

 

[invrl]

If your immediate conclusion is "they're cheating 100%" to seeing your husband/wife/bf/gf that's low self esteem talking. How do you expect to be married for life if you are skeptical of your partner every time they interact with the opposite sex. The normal person (or at least me) would be suspicious at BEST if they saw them outside a hotel (it's not as incriminating as outside their house, or a love hotel). Then they would try to figure out who the other person is. You see common tropes like "Girl is cheating, but it turns out it's their relative" too damn often after all.

Also, see it from the girl's angle. Her boyfriend out of the blue accuses her of cheating. She denies it and he shows "proof" (basically a creepy stalker photo with her dad). At that moment she was just done with him since he didn't seem to have a notion of trust in her, so she didn't deny him.

Although I'm not defending her fully: If I was treated like the way he was, I would probably assume she's cheating too.

MC didn't just see her outside the hotel, he saw her leaving the hotel. Huge difference. To Japanese where prostitution is very common this insinuates more than you'd think. No wonder he thought she was cheating, imagine you just randomly see your girlfriend leaving some random dude's hotel room all by themselves, not even with family or at least family you don't know, you'd be suspicious too.

 

[invrl]

But if they know they both like each other so much in the present, why is this guy being a needlessly edgy contrarian and forcing her to chase after him like some wimpy Heisei era harem MC who's afraid of women? What is the purpose???

Cause he doesn't like her anymore? DAFUQ? lol

 

[Beastkun]

it really is to bad this was just a oneshot

 

[Limiter4447775]

Why All one-shot manga are so good😭

 

[Limiter4447775]

Fun read. I hope these two eventually get together.

Well it's a one shot manga tho

 

[Lewd_Beast]

Because we all help our family members by taking them into a love hotel....

 

[AICyberCogGenAI]

In my perspective she cheated because she still go out with a guy not knowing it was old boyfriend some would say it was moving on then that yandere look tells enough what if the guy she go out was a psycho who took her to a love hotel or something. THIS IS MY PERSONAL OPINION

 

[ycnbm_8]

This went from grotesque to madly sweet really fast.

 

[Kami_Nana]

He has a nasty personality too: with how he just burst in and accused her and his present actions of harboring a grudge for years and creating an intricate revenge plan.

Wait...he has a nasty personality to you because he confronted his cheating girlfriend(I mean, he had proof...what else would you think seeing a man and woman exiting a hotel?)? That's a completely normal thing. Even him having a grudge is completely normal...especially when she was his first girlfriend/love. Well, normal for imperfect humans with normal emotions, anyway. As for him creating the revenge plan. A little excessive, but also within the bounds of normal human behavior...especially considering their history.

 

[Kami_Nana]

In my perspective she cheated because she still go out with a guy not knowing it was old boyfriend some would say it was moving on then that yandere look tells enough what if the guy she go out was a psycho who took her to a love hotel or something. THIS IS MY PERSONAL OPINION

What? She was moving on and they were no longer together? How is that cheating? Yandere look? Also, you're going on a lot of what ifs that aren't backed by the actual story. She was just a normal girl trying to move on from a horrible break up that she allowed to happen because she wasn't honest and such.

 

[Kami_Nana]

If your immediate conclusion is "they're cheating 100%" to seeing your husband/wife/bf/gf that's low self esteem talking. How do you expect to be married for life if you are skeptical of your partner every time they interact with the opposite sex. The normal person (or at least me) would be suspicious at BEST if they saw them outside a hotel (it's not as incriminating as outside their house, or a love hotel). Then they would try to figure out who the other person is. You see common tropes like "Girl is cheating, but it turns out it's their relative" too damn often after all.

Also, see it from the girl's angle. Her boyfriend out of the blue accuses her of cheating. She denies it and he shows "proof" (basically a creepy stalker photo with her dad). At that moment she was just done with him since he didn't seem to have a notion of trust in her, so she didn't deny him.

Although I'm not defending her fully: If I was treated like the way he was, I would probably assume she's cheating too.

He caught them exiting a hotel, not just hanging out in front of it. So, that was just as incriminating. Also, her accusing him of being a creepy stalker is common things cheaters do to gaslight their exes when caught red handed.

Said trope doesn't usually involve them leaving a place that everyone understands is a place where lovers hookup. Usually the trope just has them hanging out in public when they're spotted...not a damn hotel where people go to make love.

 

[AICyberCogGenAI]

Chill chill that was my personal opinion

What? She was moving on and they were no longer together? How is that cheating? Yandere look? Also, you're going on a lot of what ifs that aren't backed by the actual story. She was just a normal girl trying to move on from a horrible break up that she allowed to happen because she wasn't honest and such.

 

[goodhunter]

If your immediate conclusion is "they're cheating 100%" to seeing your husband/wife/bf/gf that's low self esteem talking. How do you expect to be married for life if you are skeptical of your partner every time they interact with the opposite sex. The normal person (or at least me) would be suspicious at BEST if they saw them outside a hotel (it's not as incriminating as outside their house, or a love hotel). Then they would try to figure out who the other person is. You see common tropes like "Girl is cheating, but it turns out it's their relative" too damn often after all.

Also, see it from the girl's angle. Her boyfriend out of the blue accuses her of cheating. She denies it and he shows "proof" (basically a creepy stalker photo with her dad). At that moment she was just done with him since he didn't seem to have a notion of trust in her, so she didn't deny him.

Although I'm not defending her fully: If I was treated like the way he was, I would probably assume she's cheating too.

You're fucking retarded. She was WALKING OUT OF A HOTEL WITH A DUDE. This wasn't like where she was just talking to another guy in a normal conversation. ANYONE would misunderstand if they see their partner walk out of a hotel with the opposite sex. Tropes existing in a Japanese manga doesn't prove anything other than that it's a literary device unimaginative writers like to rely on. If you're going to bring up tropes as some kind of proof, then you need to look at the tropes where the cheating individuals always try to gaslight their partners by calling them creeps or losers, which the girl here clearly also did. And like you said, she wasn't treating him well from the get go, she took everything for granted and treated him like garbage. Of course you'd think she'd be cheating if she walked out of a hotel with another dude.

 

[Remedil]

Why are there so much dumb slop with an 8+ score on this site