S-Rank Party wo Munou da to Tsuihousareta kedo, "Kantei" to "Chiyu Mahou" de Nariagari Musou - Ch. 9

[MangaDex]

 

[ciera]

thanks for the scanlation

 

[Volttekka]

Poor bastard, but a bastard nonetheless

 

[anideki]

Once again, this image fits perfectly.

 

[Dwarfy2k]

Gah I really hate when they try to make them look tragic by the end. What makes this even dumber is he isn't even repentant and MC is still sad about it. They may aswell not had the flashback and just offed him.

Also if the heal failed then why the feck would it seperate him from the dragon? Also his heal isnt a heal its a turn back time type thing. So all of this makes no sense and was clearly a writer cornering themself.

 

[Geejin]

THANK GOD. . .

he was still an asshole at the end

 

[Hiibiki]

Why not just kill him from the start

 

[kaminomikan]

yeah mc we "understand" he was "beyond saving" 😉

 

[Magpie_Bridge]

good riddance, see you never again.

 

[geal]

Good riddance

 

[Valve]

MCs plan: "I think MAYBE the dragon cant live without the stupid human part"
"I think MAYBE the shield only works on 1 thing at a time somehow because magic"
"I think rather than drive a sword into the crucial part I'm going to heal it because... Just trust me on this okay!?"

I want to complain about the logic but it's already a story about idiots using swords in a world where people can throw explosions and make barriers out of fucking nothing meaning a sword is completely uselss for anything other than assassinations...

 

[sherlock0790]

all of the victim that being hurts,
it's on the MC fault
because he's should kill the bastard friend in the first place (MC believe that the bastard friend wIlL RePEnT iN thE JaIL)

 

[imhungryn0w]

Any and all death that occurred due to this is on MC's head.
I don't know if the author is just bad at writing or their editor forced their hand but it doesn't matter. Ethically, both the MC and the antagonist are shit, MC is not a good person despite his delusions.

 

[Dwarfy2k]

Any and all death that occurred due to this is on MC's head.
I don't know if the author is just bad at writing or their editor forced their hand but it doesn't matter. Ethically, both the MC and the antagonist are shit, MC is not a good person despite his delusions.

Right? The MC is like "I'll let him live cause I knew him one point even though he wanted to kill me while working for the corrupt noble and guild."

If it's so well known the Guild and Nobles are corrupt for this stuff you can't even claim antagonist ex-party leader didn't know what he was doing was wrong. And with him not even repenting at the end of the "fight" it just baffles me to no end that MC gets sad over the death of someone who tried to kill him twice and treated him like less then dirt for years.

 

[Nunally]

Any and all death that occurred due to this is on MC's head.
I don't know if the author is just bad at writing or their editor forced their hand but it doesn't matter. Ethically, both the MC and the antagonist are shit, MC is not a good person despite his delusions.

If MC kill him earlier then what? Do you think Azel the only pawn the nobles has? Do you think the noble will stop trying to destoy the city because Azel is dead? I think not.

 

[Dwarfy2k]

If MC kill him earlier then what? Do you think Azel the only pawn the nobles has? Do you think the noble will stop trying to destoy the city because Azel is dead? I think not.

We don't know how easily that'd have been to do, how many "S" class groups do they have access to? Either way Azel should have been put down the first time, not the third time. MC while not the primary reason but it certainly would have done much to not have what just did happen and all the people that got injured and died.

Remember the Guild is corrupt and fired the girl for getting the S class in trouble for attempted murder. They only used Azels group cause they were already evil. MC also knew of said corruption before any of this happened, also knew of the corruption post secretary fired and did nothing so yeah as the saying goes:

“The world will not be destroyed by those who do evil, but by those who watch them without doing anything.” ​

With MC not doing anything to fight the corruption while knowing all about it makes him just as bad.

 

[Nunally]

We don't know how easily that'd have been to do, how many "S" class groups do they have access to? Either way Azel should have been put down the first time, not the third time. MC while not the primary reason but it certainly would have done much to not have what just did happen and all the people that got injured and died.

Remember the Guild is corrupt and fired the girl for getting the S class in trouble for attempted murder. They only used Azels group cause they were already evil. MC also knew of said corruption before any of this happened, also knew of the corruption post secretary fired and did nothing so yeah as the saying goes:

“The world will not be destroyed by those who do evil, but by those who watch them without doing anything.” ​

With MC not doing anything to fight the corruption while knowing all about it makes him just as bad.

Thats why I asking what happen after that? Killing Azel doesnt solve the fundamental problem, it just replaced a bad person with another bad person. If we follow your justice logic after killing Azel, he must purge the guild, then purge the nobles, then maybe purge the country too. On that path how many innocent people will be sacrificed, I wonder? Carelessly destabilizing a country can mean: unemployment -> poverty -> less public order -> crime (even honest people can turn to crime) -> less quality of life -> more disease -> ruin.
There is a reason why in a course of history, however corrupt that person is, its just better to keep them.

 

[imhungryn0w]

If MC kill him earlier then what? Do you think Azel the only pawn the nobles has? Do you think the noble will stop trying to destoy the city because Azel is dead? I think not.

It was never about preventing every disaster but doing right so that any disaster that befalls is not your fault.

Sure, he might find someone else to be his pawn in the fullness in time but that's neither here nor there. By not killing him when he should have, he is to blame for every action they caused.

You can only deal with what you know about in the moment the rest doesn't actually matter.

I mean with the logic you're putting forth, you're fine with people working for Nestle as a member of a militant death squad because preventing them isn't going to stop Nestle doing terrible things overall.

No, you kill those who've devoted themselves to psychopathy without repentance because it's the right thing to do and the consequences are on your head for letting them live. Just like how a few years back it was the governments fault that a child got raped due to them letting out a serial offender who had served his time.

More often than any would care to admit, death is an appropriate sentence for specific people.

 

[multithrust]

This manga sure is bad.

 

[avatarivn]

You really have to leave it to Mangadex forums for being the place to vent about how bad a Manga is (and this certainly is a BAD manga). This feels like rental girlfriend (where the story is so bad it is actually kind of funny) where people:

1. Roast the MC consistently in the comments after each and every chapter release,
2. swear they won't read the next one,
3. then come back the following week only to go back to 1.