S-Rank Party wo Munou da to Tsuihousareta kedo, "Kantei" to "Chiyu Mahou" de Nariagari Musou

Double-page supporter
Joined
Jul 28, 2018
Messages
291
I might've liked this if the MC wasn't on some "we can all be friends/happy" ideology. MC is way too forgiving, antagonist are extremely cliché and idiotic. I need an MC with some rage.
 
Joined
Apr 22, 2020
Messages
123
I like the art but this story sucks, it feels like I'm not even seeing half of it and the parts I am seeing are moving ridiculously fast
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 23, 2019
Messages
247
Rated 1star as of chapter 17. This whole manga is absurdly bad. Events are ridiculously forced at the expense of the established world rules, the bad guy only seems intelligent because they continuously strip the intelligence and common sense from all the other characters, and as someone else made a good point which is basically if mindwipe magic is so fast/easy then why isn't this whole manga plagued with evil empires everywhere and a total dystopia
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
650
A word of warning to prospective readers.
Story has no sense of pacing or clear rule setting for power scaling
Translation is barely understandable as context is lost by bad phrasing
It could've been just another power fantasy but this is some shoddy story telling with sub par work from the translator group that's only barely redeemable due to the cleanliness of typesetting.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jan 26, 2018
Messages
301
The writing of the story is a power fantasy. The character building is at the pretentious level. This a deus ex machina solely for the MC.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Sep 17, 2023
Messages
97
I won't repeat all the other comments from before so I'll ask about something else instead: has MC actually appraised himself at any point?

I think I'm about chapter 17 so maybe it'll come in later but it just feels like everything is leading up to him realizing he hasn't actually understood his 'true' power and it'll somehow be easily figured out when he does the simple act of using the ability he's been using on everyone else, on himself for once.

Okay and I take back my first statement I do feel like I have to comment on the current 'big bad' for this whole first arc. It feels really short-sighted if no one else is able to understand what he is doing, and it's extremely problematic if the clueless MC has to be the one to figure it out. There really is no reason that the big bad shouldn't be able to just take over everything before ever bothering to fight MC. And even if that's not necessarily the goal there's no obvious reason that he wouldn't have had the opportunity and time to do it all at his leisure. If the argument is there ARE forces that vigilant and he has to remain on the down-low, they are clearly being lax letting him get away with a lot of not-very-discreet power imbalancing activities.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
525
The story is a mess and plot point is forced, the translation feels like mtl ( not that i mind but for people who's not used to it might have headache reading it ) there's a better manga if you only looking to read to pass time
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 17, 2023
Messages
2,104
Looks like author has tons of idea but don't know how to develop it properly, so he choose to crammed all of them as soon as possible.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 12, 2024
Messages
144
Okay... there's a limit to the amount of trash I can stomach out of pure boredom, and this series tip-toed that line from the very beginning. Nothing's been unique at all, and everything's been retirement home food levels of bland, but it was still something to read. This most recent chapter genuinely just crossed that line and sprinted the other way, because holy hell was that bad.

Forced build-up with absolutely no pay-off since the protagonist just protagonists all over the place and everything somehow worked out for him and the power of friendship (which has been used unironically in this series so much that it's practically taking the trope and murdering it all over again) and his very basic power set evolves to the point of godhood to beat a "you beat me, just kidding, you didn't" type of enemy. At this point, I think the author died of cringe at their own series and their elementary school age sibling took over with everything they learned from Saturday morning anime and a google search on "strongest healer in manga" that took them to a re:do of healer forum. Or they just got axed. Either way, shit went from "meh" to "mother of god have mercy on my soul and the lost time I spent reading this". 1/10
 
Joined
Jan 22, 2018
Messages
64
Which chapter do I skip to see the MC's former party fail spectacularly? It's the only reason I read these.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 18, 2023
Messages
524
This is bad, on multiple levels:
  • KS Group pulled a ManhwaFreak. The "translation" they provide for this manga simply sux. Big time.
    • There are signs that they doesn't even translated from the original Japanese, but from Spanish.
      There is a race they translated/named as Nino. (Halfling?)
  • The manga itself is subpar.
    • The story is simply an amalgamation of clichés.
    • This should be an adaptation, but apparently it falls short in this aspect as well.
      (I did not read the WN/LN myself.)
      • While in the manga the MC simply hit the antagonist once (!!!) in his stomach:
        Curious, I checked out the web novel to see how the fight between the MC and Azel played out. The MC kept breaking Azel's bones and healing him over and over again. It got to the point Azel tried to run and begged him to stop, but the MC kept breaking his bones and healing him. MC finally stopped after Azel had passed out and stopped reacting to the pain.
    • ... "dragon".
      Holy shit they fought an honest to god digimon. This art is all over the place. First shown the dragon BIIIIIG then FMC get swiped with a huge tail and then MC punch a... smol dragon digmon.
    • aycx36f.png

I dropped it at Chapter 8, and I dropped it because of the dumb story, and not for the dumb "translation".
 
Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2023
Messages
18
"I don't think weathering death is a natural disease"
WELL YOU DON'T FUCKING SAY🙄
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top