Seikatsu Mahou wa Hazure Skill janai - Ch. 3.3

[MangaDex]

 

[mahtan]

No one asked the guild to do anything.
The guild accused him of breaking the rules and was treating him as a criminal because of that, which was all clearly Rosie-aho's fault.
Rosie should be penalized somehow even if the clerk girl is not, also it doesn't matter if her refusing quests have saved the life of adventures since by doing that she was breaking the rules and should be punished for it. It is not her place to decide something like that.

 

[Ilyonel]

idk about the whole rules, but i don't think armida, the receptionist, made any mistake. it didn't seem like she acted high and mighty or actually looked down on mc. she was just worried. on the other hand, mc didn't even try to give her a reason to let him take the quest and just gave up on it.

in the first place, it was the guild that didn't test new adventurers like him. so, she was just saying that based on her experience. but rosie was another matter. she deliberately accused mc and told armida to hide and lie, while knowing the truth. she deserved the punishment.

 

[Retro68]

 

[Cosmism]

Y

idk about the whole rules, but i don't think armida, the receptionist, made any mistake. it didn't seem like she acted high and mighty or actually looked down on mc. she was just worried. on the other hand, mc didn't even try to give her a reason to let him take the quest and just gave up on it.

in the first place, it was the guild that didn't test new adventurers like him. so, she was just saying that based on her experience. but rosie was another matter. she deliberately accused mc and told armida to hide and lie, while knowing the truth. she deserved the punishment.

Yeah, Rosie deliberately blew up the matter (accusing mc of violating his agreement with the guild) when it would have been easier to just pass over the faux pas. That would have been the better method to avoid conflict with someone capable of crushing seven Red Dragons and protecting her employee. (Nothing was mentioned about whether the guild's buying priority exists only when a quest is accepted, though I assume that to be the case.) Besides, Rosie's groupthink is baffling. The usual premise is that the Adventurer's Guild, true to it's name as a guild, is founded and managed by adventurers. The guild employees are merely administrative staff. Thinking of an adventurer as an outsider is thus a bit odd.

 

[Cosmism]

Y

Yeah, Rosie deliberately blew up the matter (accusing mc of violating his agreement with the guild) when it would have been easier to just pass over the faux pas. That would have been the better method to avoid conflict with someone capable of crushing seven Red Dragons and protecting her employee. (Nothing was mentioned about whether the guild's buying priority exists only when a quest is accepted, though I assume that to be the case.) Besides, Rosie's groupthink is baffling. The usual premise is that the Adventurer's Guild, true to it's name as a guild, is founded and managed by adventurers. The guild employees are merely administrative staff. Thinking of an adventurer as an outsider is thus a bit odd.

Furthermore, when I think about it, it seems absurd that the guild wouldn't have preventive measures in check to prevent newbies from rushing to their deaths. In that case, Armida's actions would be aboveboard. The whole premise is the usual 'serve the protagonist ev'rything on a silver platter' rubbish you see in light novels and web novels. It wouldn't hurt to think of a reasonable course of events, would it? Have they ever heard of beta readers? What are the editors doing?

 

[deathmailrock]

The receptionist isn't at fault... and neither is the guild.... UNTIL they tried to falsely accuse him

In fact, the guild master herself tried to be peaceful and properly clear things up...

Rosie was the ONLY ONE who was at fault....

Y

Yeah, Rosie deliberately blew up the matter (accusing mc of violating his agreement with the guild) when it would have been easier to just pass over the faux pas. That would have been the better method to avoid conflict with someone capable of crushing seven Red Dragons and protecting her employee. (Nothing was mentioned about whether the guild's buying priority exists only when a quest is accepted, though I assume that to be the case.) Besides, Rosie's groupthink is baffling. The usual premise is that the Adventurer's Guild, true to it's name as a guild, is founded and managed by adventurers. The guild employees are merely administrative staff. Thinking of an adventurer as an outsider is thus a bit odd.

That Rosie is just a dumbass.

They could have just accepted they made a mistake and correct it on their end. If she didn't try to arrest our boy or blow up the matter, none of this would have happened.

She could just admit they made the mistake and apologize. If they didn't try to frame him, none of this would have happened.

And yah, the author isn't being smart... but these are cheap quick stories published from webnovels... it's like original fanfics transformed into an official story...

The editors fix some small mistakes, but they don't have the time to go in depth because they are overworked and have too much to do...

 

[Cosmism]

The editors fix some small mistakes, but they don't have the time to go in depth because they are overworked and have too much to do...

Well, with the editors, I think it's that they can't ask the mangakas to redraw whole storyboards right before deadlines... Also, there's this emphasis on probable and 'rational' developments in modern fiction, which kinda blindsides us (myself included), to the fact that encountering an arrogant incompetent whelp -one who feels easily threatened and undeservedly possess a high position isn't actually all that improbable in real life... The fact that there are irrational and dumb people in real life is forgotten. The real issue is the rate at which the protagonist encounters these kinds of people... Also, thanks for responding. I like conversing about stuff like this.